Re:The 10,000-hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth
by yborg on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:32AM
(#13855675)
2014 article, and the pushback on Gladwell's book began almost as soon as it came out. I think there is a certain level of misunderstanding the argument he makes, in that it is assumed that the person engaging in the practice meets the minimum requirements for the activity. If you can't amass enough muscle mass, no amount of practice will make you into an NFL lineman. The problem is that in more complex activities or in areas of aesthetics like the arts, what the required level of talent to attain a high level is hard to quantify or recognize.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The 10,000-hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth
by Marazan on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:59AM
(#13855987)
Matthew Seyd (the Author of Bounce: The Myth of Talent) absolutely makes the argument that there is not minimum requirements for an activity by denying any form of genetic predisposition (or 'talent') for any activity.
He puts skill at any activity, from 100m sprinting to fine arts, down purely to practice and does some amazing logical fallacies to get there.
Re:The 10,000-hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth
by ktRolster on Monday March 13, 2017 @04:23AM
(#13856095)
He puts skill at any activity, from 100m sprinting to fine arts, down purely to practice and does some amazing logical fallacies to get there.
How does he deal with the fact that certain body types are more conducive to sprinting? Or does he just ignore that altogether?
Re:The 10,000-hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth
by goatlover on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:32PM
(#13859349)
Yeah, because there's literally nothing 99.99% of people on Earth can do to get them close to Usain Bolt's physical advantages as a sprinter. Sure, he had to work hard to maximize his ability, but that work plus his freakish body means smashing 100 and 200 meter records.