News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by jdoliner on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:10PM (#13824861)
Why shouldn't he be a source for it? His comments on Trump were insightful and very far from an endorsement. Vilifying everyone tangentially associated with Trump failed spectacularly during the election. At this point it's just beating a dead horse without any particular goal in sight.

Sama realizes full well that he's speaking for all of YC, as a YC founder I'm glad he is. I agree with him here.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:14PM (#13824906)
> His comments on Trump were insightful and very far from an endorsement.

They were shallow and normalizing, rather than insightful and far from an endorsement.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:16PM (#13824917)
They were more than normalizing. They were suggesting that the single most frightening thing about the Trump administration --- which is not that they're Republicans, but that they're crazy --- is, to the extent it's true, actually an asset.

I worry about digging too far into this because it's just going to generate a political debate. I just want to be clear about why I think this article and Sam's decision about how to participate in it is so alarming.

I am less disturbed by Trump's Republican supporters, at least the level-headed ones. At least they believe what they're saying. I am far more disturbed by someone who claims to be in the opposition but rather than publicly opposing continues to give every sign of being in fact a quiet supporter of the administration. Why should I have to worry that that's true? What was the upside for YC here?

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by nostrademons on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:37PM (#13825068)
Silicon Valley has for a long time lauded "crazy" ones. Andy Grove's book is titled "Only the paranoid survive." Steve Jobs's first Think Different commercial was "Here's to the crazy ones". YCombinator has stated on several occasions that they're looking for "extreme" personalities who "see the world differently", a16z says explicitly to "hire for strength rather than lack of weakness", and Chris Sacca loves to parade out Travis Kalanick's Wii tennis story and talk about how he's not a normal person.

The reason for this is because "crazy" is usually an appellation that the rest of society sticks on you for being "not normal". Silicon Valley is looking for the crazy person whose "normal" will become the normal for the rest of the world. You can't change the world if you think the world is already pretty good as-is.

My concern about Trump (and his few Silicon Valley supporters) is that they're applying ideas outside of the domain where they're sound. Most crazy people are, in fact, crazy, and not great visionaries who will bring the world to a higher level of being. A crazy startup founder will at most hurt himself and his investors if he's completely detached from reality; he requires the consent of his customers to do anything significant. A crazy POTUS could literally destroy humanity, so the stakes are a little bit higher.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:31PM (#13825023)
I think we are in rather violent agreement substantively here, and quibbling over details, but:

> I am far more disturbed by someone who claims to be in the opposition but rather than publicly opposing continues to give every sign of being in fact a quiet supporter of the administration.

Taking the quote at face value, Altman seems to endorsing Trump's approach to governing but not the ideological goals it is directed at; this isn't supporting Trump but in some ways it might be seen as worse—the usual anti-Trump message that unites liberal, moderate, and the notable conservative voices skeptical of the regime is that normal political ideological questions aside, Trump's approach is a danger to the viability of American democracy (obviously, as you move roughly toward the left, that process critique is leavened with increasing opposition to policy goals of the Trump Administration.)

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by Gargoyle on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:29PM (#13825010)
>I am far more disturbed by someone who claims to be in the opposition but rather than publicly opposing continues to give every sign of being in fact a quiet supporter of the administration. Why should I have to worry that that's true?

You're stating you believe Sam is a Trump administration supporter?

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:33PM (#13825038)
The evidence would suggest he's more a supporter of the style of populist authoritarianism embodied by Trump, but a dissenter from the policy goals which Trump is using that to advance.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by nostrademons on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:42PM (#13825097)
Sam's quote:

"He’s an outsider. He took on a system he thought was broken and then disregarded the rules, he got to know his users well and tested his product early and iterated rapidly."

An outsider who disregards the rules is the polar opposite of an authoritarian. Rather, I think he's admiring Trump's bias toward action and disregard for conventional wisdom, as well as for people who have a vested interest in the conventional wisdom.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:43PM (#13825100)
What? No they aren't. Kim Il-Sung was an outsider who disregarded the rules. So was Pol Pot. You've made a category error.

It might be the case that history's most effective authoritarians are disproportionately likely to be rule-breaking outsiders.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by nostrademons on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:55PM (#13825180)
They're hardly outsiders once they've become the leader of the country.

Trump is in a similar position now: he was an outsider during the campaign, but now that he's won, he's the consummate insider. The same phenomena applies to successful Silicon Valley startups: Google, Facebook, and Uber were all scrappy little startups until they became huge, at which point they became giant multinationals which need to be feared and resisted.

This I think illustrates the paradox in Sam's quote: in my read, Altman is referring to candidate Trump, while your outrage is devoted towards President Trump. As Obama said in one of his farewell addresses, "campaigning is very different from governing". Tactics that can be very effective (even necessary) on the campaign trail can become dangerous threats to democracy within the government.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:58PM (#13825202)
> They're hardly outsiders once they've become the leader of the country.

A formal position of authority doesn't stop you from being an outsider in an institution; that's one of the reasons that purges happen: to recast institutions in which the leader is an outsider into ones in which he is not.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by nostrademons on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:16PM (#13825320)
No major disagreement there.

What I'm trying to highlight is the distinction between the struggle for power and the exercise of power. Campaigning for election is a struggle for power. So is purging your political opponents within the government. So is founding a startup.

Governing is the exercise of power. Deporting all immigrants and closing the borders is the exercise of power. "Grab 'em by the pussy" is the exercise of power. Leveraging a monopoly is the exercise of power.

Power struggles are usually looked at favorably by those whose interests align with the ascendant power structure, and unfavorably by those whose interests are entrenched. The naked exercise of power is usually looked at with distrust by everyone, on the theory that if they bully someone else, they could bully you next. There's a fairly wide grey area in-between; for example, I've categorized Trump's immigration orders as the exercise of power (which probably both you and tptacek would agree with), but someone who just lost his job to an immigrant would probably categorize it as a power struggle where Trump is fighting the immigrants oppressing him. And similarly, not everyone would buy your claim that a dictator committing a purge is an "outsider" in his government. The key point though is the relative power differential between parties: it's a struggle for power when the active party is the underdog, and the exercise of power when the active party is dominant.

The way I read Altman's quote, he's casting Trump's campaign in the same terms as the struggle for power that all startups have to go through. He's specifically not endorsing what Trump has done with that power once he attained it.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:20PM (#13825348)
> What I'm trying to highlight is the distinction between the struggle for power and the exercise of power.

I'm not sure there is the kind of distinction here you are trying to draw; a struggle for (future) power is one context in which (present) power is exercised, they aren't opposing or conflicting concepts.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:45PM (#13825113)
> An outsider who disregards the rules is the polar opposite of an authoritarian

Revolutionary authoritarians are, almost without exception, outsiders who disregard the pre-existing rules, both formal rules and merely conventional ones. The very few exceptions are insiders who disregard rules in the same way. Lenin, Hitler, and Napoleon, among others, were many things, but followers-of-rules-set-by-others wasn't high on the list for any of them.

I think you are confusing being the opposite of a willing subject of authoritarianism with being the opposite of an authoritarian.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by lobotryas on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:27PM (#13824998)
Pretty sure you already crossed that line.

What is interesting about Trunp's canpaign is that he was able to win while spending significantly less than his opponent[1]. Given this, I would say that sama's on point with his quote.

BTW, calling the Trump administration "crazy" is kind of a lazy ad hominem, don't you think?

[1] - http://fortune.com/2016/12/09/donald-trump-campaign-spending...

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:28PM (#13825002)
"Ad hominem" doesn't mean "argument that hurts someone's feelings".
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by lobotryas on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:59PM (#13825204)
You're right. It means: "Rather than [criticizing] a person’s premises or reasoning, one asserts something about the person’s character, ... mental health, likes or dislikes."

I'm just surprised the first rhetorical tools you decided to use are emotional appeals and being dismissive of anyone who appears like they're remotely not toeing the party line.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:55PM (#13825182)
> BTW, calling the Trump administration "crazy" is kind of a lazy ad hominem, don't you think?

It's not ad hominem, but it may be missing that much of the apparent craziness of the Administration is deliberate propaganda strategy (even if that strategy has been chosen as a key one for the Trump camp because Trump himself is actually crazy, and so there is an incentive to find an approach that works with that fact rather than foundering on it.)

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:33PM (#13825041)
You're misusing ad hominem.

Attacking, hypothetically, a president on account of his skin colour is an ad hom. It has no bearing on his governing capability.

Noting that a president is not in full possession of his mental capacities is a statement of fact. It bears directly on his governing ability.

http://www.skepdic.com/adhominem.html

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:36PM (#13825058)
Attacking the subject of an argument on account of their skin color is not an ad hominem argument. It's a dumb argument to be sure, but it's not ad hominem.

An ad hominem argument is one in which you attempt to dismiss someone else's argument (or their standing to rebut your own argument) based not on any attribute of the argument itself, but on an attribute of the person making the argument.

If we're arguing about whether Donald Trump is crazy, and you say he's not, and I say, "you wouldn't know whether he's crazy or not because you're crazy", that's an ad hominem.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:54PM (#13825171)
Attacking the argument on the basis of skin colour, or any other irrellevant basis: gender, religion, sexuality, are classic ad homs.

And, if I do happen to be crazy and that's a legitimate basis for my not being able to assess another's insanity, that's a valid impeachment of my credibility.

If I'm not crazy, it's an untruthful assertion on your part.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by jdoliner on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:28PM (#13825005)
This idea of not "normalizing" Trump is ridiculous. When 63 million people vote for you you're normalized. Sama talking to a reporter about him doesn't do anything those 63 million voters didn't. The only way to see it as abnormal is to believe that those 63 million voter's opinions shouldn't count in terms of what's normal and what's not.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by michaelchisari on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:17PM (#13825327)
There's a difference between normalizing the election results, and normalizing his specific behavior.

I don't think we should normalize a President accusing, without any evidence, the previous president of wiretapping him... over Twitter.

That's one example of something that should never be normalized.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:33PM (#13825037)
I wonder if that's what people thought about Nixon during Watergate.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by nostrademons on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:34PM (#13825501)
This is now a complete tangent, but I find it fascinating that Nixon could've won the largest popular vote margin in history [1] both before [2] and after [3] committing treason against the American people. Similarly, other terrible presidents [4][5][6] have been widely popular during their term, with people only turning against them several years later, once it becomes clear what went on.

It should be comforting, though, that so far they have always turned eventually - as the evidence for Watergate became overwhelming, the public made it clear there were some lines that could not be crossed. I suspect we will see something similar with Trump once it becomes clear that things are not going to get materially better for the people who voted for him, but it may take several years and possibly a second term. In the meantime, those of us see just how shitty & insane the Trump administration is will have to be content to be Cassandra.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_ele...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watergate_scandal

[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/31/opinion/sunday/nixons-vie...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_G._Harding

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_W._Bush

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_Pierce

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by devinhelton on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @09:43PM (#13826464)
It should be comforting, though, that so far they have always turned eventually - as the evidence for Watergate became overwhelming, the public made it clear there were some lines that could not be crossed.

Nixon did not really do anything that previous presidents hadn't done. Those lines had already been crossed plenty of times. See It Didn't Start With Watergate -- https://archive.org/details/LaskyVictorItDidntStartWithWater... Or read Robert Caro's biography of Lyndon Johson and read about all the blatantly illegal things Johnson did. Also -- the flip side of the Nixon story is that the FBI and perhaps CIA almost certainly got away with breaking the law and illegal wire taps -- https://www.stratfor.com/weekly/death-deep-throat-and-crisis... Should we be comforted if the unelected branches of government can break the law to expose the elected branches?

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by yellowapple on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:28AM (#13828370)
Americans didn't vote for Nixon in the specific hope that Watergate would happen (last I checked at least; I wasn't around back then). Americans did vote for Trump in the specific hope that Trump's craziness and antics would happen. That's probably the key difference here.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by LyndsySimon on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:19PM (#13825342)
Yes, it is. A large part of the country supported Nixon throughout the scandal and the aftermath.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by LyndsySimon on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:23PM (#13825378)
As others have said, the idea that "normalizing" has any meaning whatsoever for a man who ran as a presidential candidate for a major party and won the office is absurd.

Supporting Donald Trump and his policies is normal. You may not agree with the man or his policies and that's perfectly fine - and also normal - but to hold the position that they are not "normal" makes no logical sense.