News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by tptacek on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:36PM (#13825058)
Attacking the subject of an argument on account of their skin color is not an ad hominem argument. It's a dumb argument to be sure, but it's not ad hominem.

An ad hominem argument is one in which you attempt to dismiss someone else's argument (or their standing to rebut your own argument) based not on any attribute of the argument itself, but on an attribute of the person making the argument.

If we're arguing about whether Donald Trump is crazy, and you say he's not, and I say, "you wouldn't know whether he's crazy or not because you're crazy", that's an ad hominem.

Re:White House Echoes Tech: ‘Move Fast and Break Things’ by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @06:54PM (#13825171)
Attacking the argument on the basis of skin colour, or any other irrellevant basis: gender, religion, sexuality, are classic ad homs.

And, if I do happen to be crazy and that's a legitimate basis for my not being able to assess another's insanity, that's a valid impeachment of my credibility.

If I'm not crazy, it's an untruthful assertion on your part.