This is definitely something Tesla needs to fix and soon. It shouldn't be hard, so either I'm missing something or they're doing as you describe in (2) and prioritizing new production over spares.
A few of the challenges: - which parts to produce and when - how many - how to ensure there is stock everywhere (shipping is not an option on a large market, as it is too costly) - how to make sure everybody knows how to mount the part - how to guarantee that your official spare parts are used
Saying it is "hard to keep up with the demand" is a marketing way of saying "we are not good at manufacturing".
Like software, it is easier to design the right car than fixing it after. But fixing defects or accidents is a necessity that no good design can prevent.
And at least with mechanical parts, there is always the option of third parties making parts. Its quite a different story when talking custom chips and firmware.
Consider the humble window wiper. More often than not these days it is not mechanical, but a electric motor driven by a chip hooked up to the CAN bus.
Similarly the central door locking and electric windows are likely to be on a single card pr door hooked up to CAN and an electric wire (the one in the driver side door being a bit more elaborate as it has controls for all the doors).
Ensuring that people get competent service and a good experience one step removed, remotely, is hard. That could be helped by fostering a customer culture of "do it yourself" then super-enabling customers and local service providers with great access to information, along with good logistics/fulfillment.
I'd be really nervous about letting someone work near 400V/1500A that wasn't trained to understand how to safely operate in that type of environment.
Reliably getting parts to a shop in days could be tough. Reliably doing it in weeks shouldn't be. That these repairs take so long tells me that they have no stock, and sit on their hands for a long time before making any.
But aren't there laws that protect and allow for aftermarket parts to be manufactured and sold by others? If there are alternatives to OEM parts, consumers aren't trapped my OEM production decisions, as long as there's enough demand.
I'm a fan of the right to repair my own gadgets and cars, but that wasn't the underlying cause of this delay (unless, of course, you are a skilled sheet aluminum worker who could produce the appropriate pieces).
Large industries with well-established lobbying efforts will always find a way to exempt themselves from even sensible sounding legislation (possibly because of unintended consequences that could cripple their business model).
2. A friend is a huge Telsa fan, and the body repair service use written-off Telsas for spares to fix damaged cars regularly. The parts required for the OPs repair would almost certainly have to be pulled from a new chassis on the line, or a written off chassis.
3. The stock price is volatile, and the "market" reacts to negative stories all the time.
"I want to sign up for the waiting list for a car. How long is it?" / "Precisely ten years from today." / "Morning or evening?" / "Why, what difference does it make?" / "The plumber's due in the morning".
The easiest way to get spare parts was simply to steal them. Cars were frequently stolen off the street and stripped. Factory workers would smuggle in old parts, fit them to cars on the production line and smuggle out the new parts. The spares that were available invariably ended up being funnelled off into the black market.
See also the Soviet black market for blown light bulbs:
http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/02/mar...
Also, a friend of mine from Moscow IRL 90's once said the electricity went out because the power lines were stolen.
This some times all messes up the power for trains
"So my neighbor, who's from a former Soviet Bloc country is a great guy who helps me out when my car breaks down. One time my battery is dead, so he offers to jump start my car. While I look on baffled, then shocked, he unscrews his car's battery from the mounting, then flips it over and presses the contacts directly to my car's battery. It started though! So is that safe?"
To further paraphrase the guys' responses... "Oh god no!!!" They further went on to point out though, that at some point when your life is dangerous and hard as a kind of background state, the little things stop even grabbing your notice.
The degree of black marketeering in the USSR was just... staggering. Systemic. Understood to be "how the system works". Sometimes though you get tragedies like Vladimir Komarov.
The space vehicle is shoddily constructed, running dangerously low on fuel; its parachutes — though no one knows this — won't work and the cosmonaut, Vladimir Komarov, is about to, literally, crash full speed into Earth, his body turning molten on impact. As he heads to his doom, U.S. listening posts in Turkey hear him crying in rage, "cursing the people who had put him inside a botched spaceship."
http://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2011/05/02/134597833/co...
he unscrews his car's battery from the mounting, then flips it
over and presses the contacts directly to my car's battery.
is that safe?
Electrically, it's not all that different from using jump leads - there's the same risk of sparks, the same voltage and load involved.There is a risk of battery acid leakage from flipping the source battery, but that depends on the type of battery - a sealed unit is unlikely to leak.
There's also a risk of injury from being so close to the engine bay when it's started - say, if your hand came into contact with a moving part like a belt or a fan - but again, that's dependent on the layout of the engine bay, and those risks are generally clearly visible and obvious.
It's certainly not "normal" practice for the western world, but there isn't really all that much risk in it. And it turns out Americans do it too! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcYjJcEZuOA
Also, the risk of battery acid leaking is probably a good bit better than you might think. If you just grab a run of the mill car battery there's a very good chance that it's just a regular old wet cell battery with an open vent so it'll leak acid if you turn it upside down.
Going further off-topic, the fact that Korolev died because he spent years in a work camp due to the dumbest of political spitefulness is just depressing. From what I can tell, Korolev could have single-handedly won the space race for the Soviet Union - too bad they killed him.
As for the lack of initial secrecy, that may have just been a practical consequence of why we won. NASA and JPL opened subcomponent development to private industry. At least in propellant development, this meant both research contracts and a general understanding that someone coming up with particularly good products could expect a massive government payout.
It produced great results and even got private investors to foot a large research bill. It also had the consequence that the work was rather less secret than it might have been - especially the failures, which were generally shopped around to other buyers if they had any interesting properties. But it worked out pretty well overall: even with Russia getting info about US efforts, the rate of new research was still impressive enough to be thoroughly competitive.
Anyone looking for an internal account of the (propellant) story might enjoy Ignition. It's free here, though Chrome can't handle the pdf: https://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pd...
This is one of the handier arguments to use against moon-landing deniers. If the Russians had the slightest reason to believe that we weren't doing exactly what we said we were doing, they'd still be laughing at us.
The entire Soviet space program was an unsustainable exercise in political showmanship, and 'Me first!' moments.
Consider the visiting cosmonaut program, the first woman in space (Who was also the... last woman in space, for the subsequent two decades.)
Consider the secrecy surrounding launches (To avoid getting egg on your face, if the mission fails/is aborted...)
Fortunately (Or unfortunately), if it weren't for political showmanship, neither country would have had a space program.
I've only ever bought "maintenance free" sealed lead-acid car batteries. Presumably it would be okay to use one of these upside down for a brief couple of minutes.
I've bought two gel-acid sealed batteries that claimed they could be mounted and used upside down.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93acid_battery#Risk...
This because Marx envisioned the transition happening after capitalism hit a crisis, where upon the workers would take over and continue to operate the factories within the existing supply network (more coops, less central planning).
In the USSR however it seemed one got more akin to the old Ford factory, where raw iron and coal came in at one end, and finished Model Ts rolled out the other.
Thus there were no independent sub-suppliers of parts, everything was made internally as needed, and nothing more.
In retrospect this can be seen as a turning point in the process by which communism, a philosophy devoted to letting the masses rule themselves, turned into Soviet communism, a system in which the masses were bossed by party elites as hard or harder as they had been by the old czars and capitalists.
What i am referring to in each instance is the French revolution, the Bolshevik revolution, and the various fundamentalist groups around the middle east that follow some interpretation of Sayyid Qutb's philosophy.
This meant that people would pre-order vehicles years in advance - and had to get extremely 'creative' when it came to keeping them running. (As jdietrich alluded to.)
The other problem with cars is that given 10 broken vehicles, there is high likelihood that 4 of them have the same broken part.
I hope you get the idea.
1. This is precisely why it's important to legislate right-to-repair. This is why auto manufacturers are required, by law, to continue to manufacture replacement parts for their cars, long after they have stopped being sold. Hopefully, Tesla can get this figured out.
2. Soviet auto manufacturers had this exact same problem. They were incentivized to sell cars, not spare parts - so finding parts for repairing your broken Lada (Which was just as likely as not to be broken as it rolled off the assembly line) took a breads-and-fishes miracle.
3. What does this have to do with stock picks... Oh.