News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by mikeash on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @12:32PM (#13821797)
As far as I can tell, it's a myth that manufacturers are required to continue making replacement parts for any particular period of time. A manufacturer needs to be able to fulfill its warranty obligations, which they usually do by manufacturing spare parts for at least as long as their customers have warranties, but that's it.

This is definitely something Tesla needs to fix and soon. It shouldn't be hard, so either I'm missing something or they're doing as you describe in (2) and prioritizing new production over spares.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by batmansmk on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @02:21PM (#13822843)
Having worked for several European manufacturers, I can tell you the R&D division producing cars is small compared to the the aftermarket.

A few of the challenges: - which parts to produce and when - how many - how to ensure there is stock everywhere (shipping is not an option on a large market, as it is too costly) - how to make sure everybody knows how to mount the part - how to guarantee that your official spare parts are used

Saying it is "hard to keep up with the demand" is a marketing way of saying "we are not good at manufacturing".

Like software, it is easier to design the right car than fixing it after. But fixing defects or accidents is a necessity that no good design can prevent.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by digi_owl on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @01:27PM (#13822350)
Then again manufacturers drive down costs by reusing parts across models, so often you can find the part even though the model you are driving is no longer being sold (never mind warranty).

And at least with mechanical parts, there is always the option of third parties making parts. Its quite a different story when talking custom chips and firmware.

Consider the humble window wiper. More often than not these days it is not mechanical, but a electric motor driven by a chip hooked up to the CAN bus.

Similarly the central door locking and electric windows are likely to be on a single card pr door hooked up to CAN and an electric wire (the one in the driver side door being a bit more elaborate as it has controls for all the doors).

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by stcredzero on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @02:04PM (#13822669)
This is definitely something Tesla needs to fix and soon. It shouldn't be hard...

Ensuring that people get competent service and a good experience one step removed, remotely, is hard. That could be helped by fostering a customer culture of "do it yourself" then super-enabling customers and local service providers with great access to information, along with good logistics/fulfillment.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by vvanders on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @02:09PM (#13822707)
There was a Tesla battery teardown posted a while back where they weren't using properly isolated tools/equipment. This was from people who supposedly work on EVs for a living.

I'd be really nervous about letting someone work near 400V/1500A that wasn't trained to understand how to safely operate in that type of environment.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by stcredzero on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @07:54PM (#13825692)
I don't mean "do it yourself" in terms of the actual working near 400 volts. I mean "do it yourself" in terms of diagnosis and "supervising" the logistics of a repair. If you need bodywork, Tesla could easily facilitate tracking down the parts and the bodywork/assembly procedures on their website. If your local mechanic isn't so search savvy, then the owner could have access to the same site to act as a facilitator. Heck, they could build a stripped-down project management for the repair project into such a site.
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by e12e on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @02:37PM (#13823007)
Isn't that the kind of problem that tends to short[sic] itself ;-)
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by mdpopescu on Thursday March 09, 2017 @04:58AM (#13828275)
1500 Amps???
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by mikeash on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:25AM (#13829847)
Indeed. There's a crazy amount of current going through these things. Apparently the limit used to be 1200A, and beyond that, traditional fuses don't work well because the metal vaporizes and starts conducting electricity even after the fuse wire has melted. To get to 1500A they created a computer-controlled pyrotechnic fuse. That's what enabled the "ludicrous mode" that you can get on their high-end cars.
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by mikeash on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @02:12PM (#13822747)
Good service overall is a tough problem, but ensuring adequate parts availability doesn't seem like a particularly difficult thing. Keep a small stock of every part at a warehouse somewhere, ship it out to shops that need them when they ask.

Reliably getting parts to a shop in days could be tough. Reliably doing it in weeks shouldn't be. That these repairs take so long tells me that they have no stock, and sit on their hands for a long time before making any.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by DashRattlesnake on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @01:55PM (#13822585)
> As far as I can tell, it's a myth that manufacturers are required to continue making replacement parts for any particular period of time.

But aren't there laws that protect and allow for aftermarket parts to be manufactured and sold by others? If there are alternatives to OEM parts, consumers aren't trapped my OEM production decisions, as long as there's enough demand.

Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by revelation on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @12:50PM (#13821964)
A particular problem for Tesla seems to be that basically every quarter now they desperately focus on producing new cars to hit their production targets, which then just grow exponentially for next quarter..
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by mikeash on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @12:57PM (#13822046)
They seem to have been doing this since they started, or at least since the Model S came out. They don't seem to have much trouble generating orders, so they're running flat out all the time. Seems like they ought to reserve a few percent of their production capacity for repair parts, even if it hurts the delivery numbers a bit.
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by greenhatman on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @01:25PM (#13822326)
I guess when demand way outstrips supply, they don't have much incentive to, unfortunately.
Re:Repairing My Tesla Model S Has Been a Nightmare by sangnoir on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:02AM (#13827340)
Their attitude towards repairs will lead to a drop in demand when Tesla's get a reputation of getting stuck in the shop for long spells. By then, it will be far too late to do anything - (see Jaguar)