News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by shshhdhs on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:12AM (#13810022)
They can only reveal voice data IF the victim said "Alexa" when the crime was taking place. If the victim didn't say "Alexa" that day, then there's nothing to reveal. Your example about encryption doesn't make sense in the context of the Echo.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by npongratz on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @09:10AM (#13810391)
I'm not certain there exists nothing to reveal. Is there a technical limitation of the system that prevents or avoids recording of "non-'Alexa'" audio? Or do I just trust Amazon when they say their alway-on device only records when triggered with the magic word?

As I think about it, I'd ask the same regarding the voice-controllable phone in my pocket.

FWIW, I don't trust the devices, because their operations are out of any consumer's ability to control them, but maybe I'm missing something about their technical limitations that would work in my favor.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by joezydeco on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @09:31AM (#13810549)
From looking at the internals, there's technically nothing that prevents uploading all audio constantly to AWS.

Practically, it would be unwieldy to have 10,000,000 devices sending audio to 10,000,000 audio decoding and processes 24 hours a day nonstop.

You'd also see a huge bandwidth hit at your ISP, which would certainly kill future adoptions if the word got out.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by austenallred on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @09:43AM (#13810640)
So record the audio 24/7 and compress and send once an hour? Once a day? Or eliminate empty space first. The files wouldn't be that big
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by squarefoot on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:02AM (#13811406)
Totally possible. As an example, Codec2 used in ham-radio applications can send pretty decent voice audio at a few kilobit/s or less, and it keeps sounding perfectly understandable even at 1.2 kbit/s like this short sample: http://www.rowetel.com/downloads/codec2/hts1a_1200.wav

More information here: http://www.rowetel.com/?page_id=452

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by kbenson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:11PM (#13812212)
To spell it out, that's < 12.7 megabytes every 24 hours. If there are 10 million Echo devices, that's 127 million megabytes a day, or 127 terabytes a day. That's actually not that hard to handle for the company that runs AWS, so while extremely unlikely, it's not impossible. Just very, very costly.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by squarefoot on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:45PM (#13812666)
You don't need to record 24/7. A well planned spying operation would involve multiple devices and connections, location discovery, proximity with other devices etc. Phones, tablets, Home and laptop PCs, Car PCs, Smart TVs, and pretty much every connected device, can be hijacked into becoming a bug or cooperate with any of them if in proximity. The victim cellphone could establish a secure connection via WiFi or Bluetooth with the Echo o any similar assistant, grab the audio data to transmit, alert the user some important upgrade is needed on the phone then start transmitting the data and fake some random download just to make the downlink act as it's receiving something. That way those 12 megabytes of data would remain totally unnoticed.

This is of course the product of tinfoilhattery at its finest level, until someone does it for real.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by kbenson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:04PM (#13812869)
Sure, I was just providing an upper bound for requirements if they decided to store all audio all the time from every device. Of companies that have the capability to do so under their own resources, Amazon in on the short list. Amazon could possibly pull it off and hide it in the rounding of numbers for their normal business.

Companies that interact (peer) with them would likely see something though, but possibly not as easily as it seems. The average home internet connection probably downloads far more than 12.6 MB of content from AWS hosted services every day. The only question is whether the upload amount would trigger any alarms. I think in most cases not, as it would probably just go a very small amount towards evening those peering connections out, which are likely very heavy in the other direction.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by treebeard901 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @05:24PM (#13815676)
Easy answer. They may not have to send the audio. They could transcribe it locally at the client, encrypt, and send text to store on the server. Consider that almost a decade ago, programs like dragon naturally speaking could be run on a relatively inexpensive laptop. It's entirely possible that a dedicated device like the echo could do this today. EDIT: Original reply sounded too definitive
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ghaff on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:19PM (#13816961)
It's not transcribed locally at the client except for the wake word.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ThrowawayR2 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:21PM (#13812340)
Totally not possible. 1.2kbps * 10M devices is 12Gbps, or greater than the bandwidth of a STM-64 link. Not practical to either receive or store, even for Amazon, and certainly bandwidth consumption on that scale would be extremely noticeable.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by kbenson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:28PM (#13812454)
I'm not sure why you would assume one of the largest computational and datacenter service providers in the world with many datacenters in many regions would require all input to be over a single connection to a single location, and even if it was, why it wouldn't come across the many, many peering agreements they have.

There are many reasons why it doesn't make sense for them to do this, but this isn't one of them.

Edit: To clarify, and put this in perspective, 12 Gbps is 1.5 GB per second, which is less than 127 terabytes a day. Amazon, through AWS in multiple regions, is entirely capable of adding 127 terabytes of storage a day, and already transfers MUCH more than 12 Gbps. This is not impossible, just very improbable.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by dheera on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:20AM (#13811597)
Not to mention that people aren't actually speaking 24/7. In any given space there are probably people talking for less than 10% of the day.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by dpark on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:53AM (#13811302)
Compression over an hour or a day won't do anything meaningful vs compression over, say, a minute. There's just not that much additional redundancy to eliminate. Uploading in a big burst doesn't save on overall bandwidth, either.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by owenversteeg on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:08PM (#13816913)
I see a lot of people in this thread saying that's not possible, so here's the math:

As given by squarefoot, you can record human voice at 1200 bit/sec = 150 bytes/sec. A day is 86400 seconds, assume people are talking (generously) 10% of the day, so 8640 seconds * 150 bytes = 1.3 megabytes per day uploaded to Amazon.

Does anyone doubt that _the company that runs AWS_ is incapable of dealing with barely a megabyte per device per day?

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by njharman on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:11PM (#13812940)
You do realize this is same company running AWS. One of if not the largest network of cloud services. They can probably do that with idle capacity of one region.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by michaelt on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:26AM (#13811003)
Doesn't seem any more unwieldy than Skype or Spotify?
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ynniv on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:42AM (#13811168)
I don't have a link, but the echo doesn't transmit network data until the watchword is detected. It probably has a small local buffer, but not large enough to be useful here. So I expect that an unmodified echo would not provide historical evidence, but there's probably a way for one to be configured to stream audio continuously.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by squarefoot on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:11AM (#13811511)
Unfortunately the only way to check if the above is true would be by examining the device firmware.

Also, the definition of "unmodified" and "configured" is very broad in this context. There's no need for a screwdriver or messing with a JTAG port when a well hidden magic packet coming from the Internet can trigger a watchword=off function.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ynniv on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:28AM (#13811669)
Right, but this is a targeted action that can only be applied to a limited number of people without causing problems for Amazon. It's not useful when something unexpected happened and there was an echo present.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ahallock on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:43AM (#13811184)
If it's true that all audio is being sent to Amazon, I will throw my Echo out today. That's a serious invasion of privacy and breach of trust.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by JetSpiegel on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:46AM (#13811886)
The entire point of the Echo and similar devices is that it's always listening.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by FungalRaincloud on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:19PM (#13812318)
Listening locally for a trigger word != listening, recording and transmitting. The point of the echo is to have an on-demand voice channel to an artificially intelligent assistant.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by Karunamon on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:17PM (#13812289)
The device is always listening (unless you mute the mic), but that doesn't mean it's always sending a stream to Amazon.

The device has to continuously process audio to listen for the wake word (upon which it does start sending everything to amazon) and a few seconds of the buffer before that so you can just bark out commands rather than waiting for it to acknowledge you.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by fossuser on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:43PM (#13813281)
The device does claim to only send voice recordings to Amazon during a query (when you say the wake word).

You can ask Alexa, "Are you always listening?" to get details about it. It's possible that the device doesn't have anything interesting anyway and they were just resisting the disclosure for PR reasons.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by npongratz on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:56PM (#13813405)
> You can ask Alexa, "Are you always listening?" to get details about it.

True, I can ask, but I don't know if I'd always believe the answer.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by tonylemesmer on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:05AM (#13810814)
I happen to have met the hardware engineers who developed the chipset and microphone array PCB inside the Echo and they told me there is no recording unless the trigger word is detected.

I saw no evidence to prove or disprove this and there's nothing to say that the device couldn't be altered after installation.

[edited: grammar]

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by jessaustin on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:46AM (#13811233)
Once upon a time this behavior would have been determined by hardware. For a device developed this decade, however, there's no way that a PCB design would determine this. Rather, this behavior is determined by the firmware loaded onto the microcontroller.

Even if one didn't know that, the fact that the trigger word is easily changed by the user should indicate that everything is in software.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by IncRnd on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:46AM (#13810232)
False Positives.

"I'll Let Some" one else discuss how false positives can affect detection.