Nothing like this wretched, tedious subthread ("Angela Merkel has chosen to ethnically cleanse the German people") belongs here. We ban accounts that take HN into circles of internet hell, so please don't post political or ideological rants in the first place. HN comments should become more focused, civil, and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. If ever there were a case for a negative feedback loop it's this one.
All: If you can't discuss something in the spirit of this site—intellectual curiosity—then please don't post until you can.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13786624 and marked it off-topic.
We have a large Turkish community in Germany and it turns out that the new people from e.g. Syria are less violent, theocratic and regressive than the 3rd generation Turkish immigrants we already had.
> I'm not even European
Which means you have no idea whats going on. People here care more about their favorite soccer team than immigrants. Right wing party popularity is falling again after having a short peak. The real problems in Europe are caused by stupid "austerity" politics, not by refugees.
That's not a very high standard. You haven't refuted my point, just said "well, they're not the absolute worst".
> Which means you have no idea whats going on.
You would do well to remember that nowadays we have the internet and international friendships.
Now there's a surprise.
> European leaders have been importing millions
They have not imported millions.
> incredibly violent, theocratic, illiterate, and regressive regions
This is aggressive against millions of people.
> European politicians don't seem to give much of a shit about Europeans
This is hate speech.
The first statement was that 'European leaders have been importing millions'. Your simply deny this without any evidence to the contrary. The facts seem to point to the validity of the original claim, with Germany taking in more than a million migrants and refugees (these are two different categories) all by itself. Maybe it would have been closer to the truth to state 'around 1.5 million in a single year' instead of 'millions', but the original poster did not state that the claim was for a single year. All in all, the original claim has more validity than your flat-out denial.
The second claim was that these migrants and refugees come from 'incredibly violent, theocratic, illiterate, and regressive regions'. You claim this to be 'aggressive against millions of people'. Let's dissect the original claim, starting with 'violent'. This needs no discussion, those regions are violent, this being one of the stated reasons for people to leave them in the first place. The middle-east is riddled with conflict, it is a volatile region. Syria and Iraq in particular stand out but it would be foolhardy to the extreme to try to claim the rest of the region is stable and peaceful. The next part of the statement is 'theocratic'. Taken literally this is only true for part of the region from which the migrants and refugees come. Iran is a theocracy, and Iran is where a large part of those claiming to be Afghans come from. Syria and Iraq are in themselves not theocracies but the regions claimed by IS/Daesh are. The African countries from which a large part of the migrants come are not theocracies, although most of them have an islamic majority.
The claim of illiteracy applies to part of the countries from which migrants arrived to Europe. Literacy in Afghanistan is 28% - that is literacy, so the illiteracy rate is 72% [1]. Other regions fare better but compared to the near 100% literacy rate in western and northern Europe they fall short. Literacy in Africa varies wildly but none of the African countries from which migrants arrive nears 100% [2].
The third part of the original claim was that these countries are 'regressive'. This is a very subjective term and as such can not be dealt with like the other claims. It could be applied to some of the countries from which refugees (Syria, Iraq) and migrants (Somalia, Afghanistan) arrived as those countries did regress from stability into chaos due to the collapse of governmental and societal institutions.
Now to the last part of the original statement, the one which states that 'European politicians don't seem to give much of a shit about Europeans'. You call this 'hate speech', but that is simply wrong and one of the more damaging parts of your claims. Hate speech is one of those labels often used by those who wish to quell discussion (others are 'racism', 'islamophobia', 'xenophobia', 'fascism', etc.). The term 'hate speech' is relatively well-defined as being "speech which attacks a person or group on the basis of attributes such as gender, ethnic origin, religion, race, disability, or sexual orientation" [3]. You apply this term to a claim of politicians not looking out for their constituency. This is a total misapplication of the term, using it in such a way actually devalues it by implying that politicians who follow their own agenda (which many of them do) are no worse than, say, Westboro baptist church supporters toting claims of whatever horror being some gods punishment for homosexuality.
Do you stand by your reaction?
[1] http://www.indexmundi.com/map/?v=39&r=me&l=en [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_literacy_... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech
Germany did not import millions of illiterate people from Afghanistan.
Attributes 'such as'. 'politician' is an attribute such as. Tactics like Goebbels who called them Volksverräter and Volksfeinde.
These are the usual tactics by the right wing propaganda: useless 'semantics' when the intend is clear: a smear campaign against politicians.
Who claimed that Germany 'imported millions of illiterate people from Afghanistan'? I do not see that claim anywhere but in your last message.
Bringing up Goebbels in a politically tainted discussion is counterproductive unless there is a clear cause to do so. In this case there is no such cause.
Making claims of something being 'the usual tactics by the right wing propaganda' is even less helpful as all it does is polarise the discussion. Leave out the labels, the epithets, stop comparing with Nazi tactics. If you don't think you can 'win' without resorting to such means there is a good chance you don't have anything useful to add to the discussion.
Refugees have been fleeing for some time from Syria, especially when the war escalated. People from North Africa increasingly come to Europe, especially because the events of the last decade: war, collapse of order, economic problems, ...
Claiming that all these people come to Germany, because we imported or invite them is just a lie. The wave of refugees coming to Germany from Syria was especially, because no one else helped them, just when the war escalated. Some EU countries don't get enough help dealing with refugees and others simply refuse to provide help. In the past German politics wasn't very helpful either and the problem slowly escalated over time. But one of the root causes are failed politics of regime change in middle east and north africa.
1, 2 or 3 million refugees in Germany is not the biggest problem. The much bigger problem is ending the war in Syria, which is to a large part caused or fueled by countries like the US, Russia, Iran, the Saudis, ... If the war ends, many refugees could return home... which would take years.
You brought up the illiteracy rate of Afghanistan, not me.
Don't whine when you spread right-wing propaganda that you sound like Goebbels. That's all from Nazi propaganda: Überfremdung durch Massen von Untermenschen, Politiker als Volksverräter, ...
> This is aggressive against millions of people.
Not sure how. You can describe it however you like, but that won't change the fact that it's true.
> This is hate speech.
Criticizing European politicians is hate speech? Interesting.
(Side note: this is why people don't like "hate speech" laws. A surprising number of people think "hate speech" means essentially anything they disagree with.)
True, but they have not been 'imported' by politicians. These people fled from the war in Syria. Germany has a right for these people to ask for asylum in its constitution. Unlimited.
> Criticizing European politicians is hate speech
Claiming that European politicians give a shit (his words) about their citizens is not 'criticizing' anything. It's just hate speech against politicians.
I don't agree with Merkel in many things, but I'm pretty sure that she cares a lot about Germans. Practically every German politician does.
This is probably the strongest invocation of Poe's law I've seen in the last few years.
I'm European and German. I feel well supported by politicians like Merkel and Schulz. Both are among the most popular politicians in Germany and there is a reason Merkel is chancellor: people have voted for her politics. After the next election either Merkel or Schulz will be chancellor.
Funny then how Angela Merkel has chosen to ethnically cleanse the German people and replace them with a population whose top geopolitical priority is and has always been the destruction of Israel and the extermination of the Jews.
The new 'refugee' dominated Germany is going to be an interesting place.
A clear case of this is Syria, which is in the shitter because of the Western destruction of Iraq fifteen years ago. Before the US went in, a number of critics were saying that the US had no exit plan and that removing Hussein would massively destabilise the region - both turned out to be true. So when millions of refugees stream out of there, "our side did that to them".
Another thing you're missing is that Europe still has in living memory the scars of what happens when you're divided rather than unified. We don't have the pain of nazi occupation and collaboration here in Anglotown. WWII had not only country against country, but neighbour against neighbour, and we Anglos have absolutely no idea of what that was like. The same thing happened more recently in '90s former Yugoslavia. European unity is about more than free trade.
> European unity is about more than free trade.
You're right again, which is why it's insane to drive a wedge between Europeans with politically and socially untenable forced immigration.
Germany has been accepting much more immigrant refugees than other European countries, out of moral duty but also out of economic interest. Germany has had pro-immigration programs for years before that, especially after the great recession, because the country has a deficit of young working-age people to contribute to their economy.
Some refugees have committed crimes and offenses, as it is likely to happen from any large group of people. I have yet to see any evidence that they do it in higher proportion that european-born population.
You can take any anecdote and turn it into fear-mongering. Before we had refugees, romani people were the target of choice, before that, south-europeans. Nationalists have always found a convenient scapegoat.
And by the way, there is no evidence that immigration, even mass choc-wave immigration, has adverse effects on the economy of a country.
Just because you say it's "socially untenable forced immigration"
does not make it so. You have no evidence that it is, indeed, untenable.
Have a look around the suburbs of [Sweden] Stockholm, the city of Malmö, some of the suburbs of Göteborg or [France] the banlieux of Paris to get a view on what the original poster meant. There is no need for 'rants from "expat friends"' to form an opinion on the situation which has developed due to untenable migration.Also, what do you mean by 'immigrant refugees'? There is no such thing as an 'immigrant refugee', people either come as refugee or as immigrant. You can claim that refugees are by definition immigrants. Objectively speaking this is true as they migrated from another country, but in the context of the discussion on migration it only serves to muddle the view as refugees have a special status, guaranteed by international conventions, whereas immigrants do not have this claim. This is an important distinction due to the fact that many immigrants (without valid claims of refuge) came along with the refugees from the war in Syria and Iraq. In some countries - Sweden being a good example - the majority of those claiming asylum fall under this category and as such did not have valid reasons for asylum. The insistence on grouping these different categories together only serves to erode the public support for true asylum seekers as the number of people 'hitching a ride' on the crisis quickly strains the capacity of a country to take up (true) refugees to the breaking point (viz. Sweden, again). Sweden has now 'closed its borders' (in theory, at least, in practice it still takes up around 50.000 per year).
I have yet to see any evidence that they do it in higher
proportion that european-born population.
Evidence is available in abundance for those willing to look for it. Here is an often-discussed publication from the Swedish "Crime-prevention council" on the subject:https://www.bra.se/bra/publikationer/arkiv/publikationer/200...
https://www.bra.se/download/18.cba82f7130f475a2f1800012697/1...
Similar publications are available from other countries, eg. The Netherlands:
https://www.cbs.nl/NR/rdonlyres/FA26E32C-250B-4D1D-B3B9-3508...
I'm a migrant myself (from the Netherlands to Sweden) so this thing is interesting to me. If you read these reports you'll soon find out that it is not simply the fact that someone migrates from country A to country B which makes him or her more likely to commit crimes. A simple look at the statistics shows that immigrants from certain regions to both Sweden and the Netherlands are actually underrepresented in crime statistics, this goes for people from eg. China and Japan. People who come from eg. north-African and middle-eastern countries are over-represented. Over- or under-representation in crime statistics is more a factor of culture and cultural differences than it is a simple factor of origin.
> they're being punished for it?
This is such a childish view. Recognising that you've benefitted from the suffering of others and wanting to share back some of those benefits is not "punishment".
I honestly can't imagine how you could avoid exposure to any of the incredible amount of discontent in Europe right now.
European leaders have been importing millions(!) of people from incredibly violent, theocratic, illiterate, and regressive regions, to the detriment of peaceful, secular, educated, and liberal Europeans who are not socially or memetically equipped to handle such an influx of radically different and heavily indoctrinated people. European news media emphatically denies that anything bad is happening; "No, rape rates have only gone up a little bit! No, we're not putting a wall around the Eiffel Tower, it's an aesthetic perimeter! No, Sweden isn't banning christmas lights in public for Muslims; it's because we all of a sudden realize that street lights can't structurally support christmas lights!" Most people in Europe are not dumb enough to fall for this.
For decades, the sentiment in the European political system has been "us last". Here's a great quote from the President of the EU Parliament until earlier this year, Martin Schulz: (and yes, it's a real quote): "For me, the new Germany exists only in order to ensure the existence of the State of Israel and the Jewish people."
The conclusion that any impartial observer would make is that European politicians don't seem to give much of a shit about Europeans, and instead see them as more of a resource to be used up for the sake of various political causes (mass immigration is a big one, and as Mr. Schulz demonstrated, Zionism is another).
It should come as exactly zero surprise that, at some point, Europeans are going to get fed up with being treated like shit by their own political system.
I'm not even European, but this sentiment is very obvious to me from my European expat friends. A large number of them are in support of leaving the EU in favor of increased national sovereignty (because then at least their own interests might come into play), and those that want to stay in the EU mostly feel that way because they falsely conflate free movement and free trade with the existence of the EU.
The result of this discontent with (forced) social globalism is that countries are becoming more isolationist. This led to Brexit, will possibly lead to France leaving the EU as well (although the EU parliament is currently trying to attack Le Pen), and who knows what next.
To be clear, I'm not happy about any of this, but I honestly don't know how people didn't see it coming.