News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by neotek on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:37PM (#13770248)
Isn't a 5 - 8 degree rise catastrophic though? Genuine question.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by lisper on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:49PM (#13770332)
Depends on what you consider catastrophic. 5-8C means you lose both the Greenland and Antarctic ice caps, so you get 60m (200 ft) sea-level rise, so you totally lose all the coastal cities, and the current round of civilization is almost certainly done for. But homo sapiens will probably survive, and so civilization will probably eventually be rebuilt. It won't be the end of life on earth under any circumstances.

Actually, the biggest danger is that political instability brought on by climate change will lead to nuclear war. That would be much worse than losing civilization to climate change because it would happen much faster, essentially instantaneously. That is not at all unlikely even under much more modest warming scenarios.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by riffic on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:42PM (#13771484)

  But homo sapiens will probably survive, and so civilization will probably eventually be rebuilt
This is a very arrogant assumption. Our species is one component of a little-understood web of interconnected dependencies. Just because humans are slightly more clever than past dominant species doesn't make us any less extinction-proof.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by lisper on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:23AM (#13771947)
I'm guess you meant that cleverness doesn't make us any more extinction-proof. But actually it does. Cleverness is a huge advantage in the survival game.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by riffic on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:40PM (#13778492)
Thanks for the correction re: more versus less. But I'll still posit that this is an arrogant line of thinking:

  Cleverness is a huge advantage in the survival game.
Cleverness won't be much help when underlying dependencies disappear.

Edit: one way humans will extinctionize our species:

https://phys.org/news/2017-02-scientists-categorize-earth-to...

We're basically driving this car full speed towards the cliff. No amount of cleverness will stop this.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by parhurs on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:23AM (#13772227)
The relation might not be linear though.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by scarmig on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:43AM (#13771749)

  Just because humans are slightly more clever than past dominant species doesn't make us any less extinction-proof.
Homo sapiens: the Dunning-Kruger hominid.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by dredmorbius on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:49AM (#13774307)
I've suggested: the anti-ant.

Ants, individually, are stupid. Collectively, they're intelligent, and solve complex problems.

Humans, individually, are brilliant (by animal standards). Collectively, not so much.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by mirimir on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:43PM (#13771234)
Right, you get 5-8 C (9-14 F) increase in global mean temperature. That mostly translates, I think, to temperature increases during winter, and at higher latitudes. Biomes will both be shifted poleward and warped, and that will happen faster than some component species can adapt.

The good news is that runaway greenhouse warming won't evaporate oceans and bake out CO2 from surface rocks :)

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by hueving on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:17PM (#13770513)
Why would civilization be over? The sea rise wouldn't happen over night and people would move or build walls.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by drdrey on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:09PM (#13770804)
We already have tremendous political instability in the US and Europe right now caused in part by a not-so-great-but-not-devastating economy and the Syrian refugee crisis. Imagine a worldwide crisis with tens or hundreds of millions of people losing their homes and livelihood, how is that going to play out?
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by taneliv on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:14AM (#13771600)
40% of global population lives in coastal areas of lesser elevation than 50m.[1] That is more like 3 billion people. Syrian refugee crisis seems quite insignificant in comparison. Of course, only one of those is currently underway, and we don't really know how fast sea levels will rise.

[1] http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/natlinfo/indicators/methodolog...

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by hueving on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:23AM (#13773811)
>We already have tremendous political instability in the US and Europe right now

This is definitely not true for the US. At least not by any global notion of political instability. The US government isn't near collapse, there is a very limited likelihood of any kind of coup, the economy is doing very well, and riots have been very rare.

There is a lot of political bickering, but it doesn't seem to be any more-so than during the last party-in-the-office changes (Clinton to Bush, Bush to Obama).

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by kurthr on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:36PM (#13770940)
Florida is porous. You can build walls but they don't do much. The water will rise to cover the entire peninsula. Long before that tides and storm surge will destroy all of the surface roads to coastal cities. I wouldn't lend money there for longer than 30years.

http://geology.com/sea-level-rise/florida.shtml

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:38PM (#13770957)
Because a 60 meter high seawall around pretty much all of the country would be a bit problematic material wise alone (you'd have to chop down a couple of major mountains, assuming you have those), coupled with the slight problem of then having to get rid of all the water landing in your nice new bathtub by precipitation.

A seawall isn't just a wall, it's more like a dike if it is to survive and that means it has a width many times larger than it's height.

And then there is seepage to contend with. This is anything but a trivial problem and we have never done engineering on that scale before.

The easiest solution would be to move to higher ground.

[dead]
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by Karunamon on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:46PM (#13771249)
Please don't do this here.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by idlewords on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:20AM (#13771627)
I've been banned from everywhere else
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by mgbmtl on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:28PM (#13770587)
That's a lot of people to move and things to rebuild. Op did say "the current round of civilization". I also agree that lots of things changing at once are likely to create instability, with negative economic and social impacts (unless governments massively intervene, which I suspect many in the US would not appreciate).

I'm sure walls are an option, but they will be expensive to maintain and it doesn't take much to have big consequences. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drainage_in_New_Orleans

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:41PM (#13770976)
And that was just on a city scale. Doing this country or continent wide is engineering on an entirely different level. NL has something like this but it's only 30 feet high and extrapolating from that experience to something able to withstand 60 meters of ocean (which is dynamic, an an average of 60 meters does not include storm surges and tides) is making me think this is infeasible.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by hueving on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:31AM (#13773841)
>That's a lot of people to move and things to rebuild. Op did say "the current round of civilization".

If that's the bar for civilization ending, then civilization ended when people came to the US, ended again when they expanded out to the West, etc.

Just because people on the US coasts move means little to the 60 percent of citizens that don't live near the ocean.

And again, it's not going to happen overnight. A wall of water isn't coming in that will force everyone to put their things in a car and go. It will be slow build-up that slowly forces people out as they decide it's to expensive to mitigate.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 02, 2017 @09:58AM (#13774403)
"If that's the bar for civilization ending, then civilization ended when people came to the US, ended again when they expanded out to the West, etc."

Interesting that your example is literally true both times for the people who where there earlier.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by shripadk on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:18AM (#13771616)
> Actually, the biggest danger is that political instability brought on by climate change will lead to nuclear war

Can you please elaborate on this point?

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by lisper on Thursday March 02, 2017 @01:24AM (#13771954)
Elaborate how?
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by sheeshkebab on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:32AM (#13773844)
The dipshits in Russia, China and US will push buttons in their briefcases and we are all going to burn (or die of starvation soon after).
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by gravelc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:26PM (#13770579)
5-8C would lead to mass starvation. Our agricultural systems are built on extremely well adapted crop varieties for the regions they grow in. The lead-in time for generation of new crop varieties is very long (even with genetic modification). Rapid catastrophic climate change, with major associated changes in pest and disease prevelence, would simply overwhelm our ability to generate adapted crop varieties to maintain yield. Add to that more extreme weather events. Then on top of all this, investment on agricultural science has been declining for years, precisely at the time when plant breeders should be focusing on what is happening 20-30 years from now.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by drpgq on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:51PM (#13770712)
Don't we pretty much already have a massive oversupply of calories?
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by gravelc on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:33PM (#13770924)
In a perfect world where food distribution isn't affected by things like spoilage, lack of transport infrastructure, politics, trade barriers, diversion of food crops to biofuels, monopolies, war etc. etc., we may have an oversupply. In reality, it's not even close, given that yield increases in staple crops like wheat are beginning to flat-line, and population growth marches ever onwards (and millions are lifted out of poverty to the middle class).

The Green Revolution was through picking all the low-hanging fruit - hybrid crops and synthetic fertilizers. Increasing yield to match demand is already looking like an issue without the effect of catastrophic climate change. Other issues occurring in the next 20-30 years include encroachment of cities into prime arable land, land degradation, and increased cost/reduced availability of phosphorous fertilizers.

It's a massive issue that barely registers on the public conscience, and we may hit the perfect storm soon, particularly if a new nasty rust or plant virus pops up on the scene at the same time.

Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by Mizza on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:48PM (#13770326)
For any Americans paying attention, please keep in mind that that's 8C, not 8F.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by vtange on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:03PM (#13770429)
8C ~= 14.4F for reference
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:43PM (#13770983)
Yes, it's not the temperature (though that would already cause lots of problems) it's the secondary effects such as oceans rising, likely a change in the gulfstream and so on.
Re:Massive permafrost thaw documented in Canada, portending ... by xyzzy4 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:49PM (#13770333)
I don't think they had coastal cities or farming back then.