News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:54PM (#13769392)
> now nobody can use the videos

The Americans with Disabilities Act came in in 1990. The fact that even after twenty seven years organisations chose to ignore the law shows the contempt that organisations have for people with disabilities.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by SilasX on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:23PM (#13769651)
They were complying with (a reasonable reading of) the ADA: if you were accepted to Berkeley (via an ADA-compliant process), and then enrolled in one of these classes, they would ensure that any required course materials were translated to accommodate any covered disability you had.

What Berkeley was doing afterward was saying "well, we've provided this class in compliance with the law, might as well open up access to the materials to anyone who could benefit from them".

The court's interpretation would be like saying, "If a store gives away unused, edible meat at the end of the day, they must provide an equal amount of vegetarian food."

I can understand "equal access" arguments for "if you sell meals, you must provide a vegetarian option" (which Berkeley did the analog of). But why would they be expected to do the same for "byproduct" giveaways?

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:46PM (#13769884)
>> I can understand "equal access" arguments for "if you sell meals, you must provide a vegetarian option" (which Berkeley did the analog of). But why would they be expected to do the same for "byproduct" giveaways?

To use a hyperbolic example: you can see that "Free meals (NO GAYS)" would be discriminatory.

>The ADA’s nondiscrimination mandate states that no qualified individual with a disability shall, by reason of such disability, be excluded from participation in or be denied the benefits of services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or be subjected to discrimination by a public entity

The "or be subjected to discrimination" is possibly what they're getting at.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by SilasX on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:03PM (#13770013)
>To use a hyperbolic example: you can see that "Free meals (NO GAYS)" would be discriminatory.

Yes, I can. And if that situation modeled the dynamics of the current one, it would change my mind. But I don't see how it does.

They're not denying the free meals/course materials to gays/vegetarians/the deaf. They're giving away byproducts that, by their nature, gays/veg's/the deaf cannot use, which came about as an incidental product of legal, non-discriminatory behavior.

For an analogy that does capture the dynamics: imagine if some factory's production process spewed out a waste product that happened to be perfectly usable as an STD prevention device for hetero sex but not homosexual sex. So the owners shrug and say,

"Hey, anyone who wants these hetero STD prevention devices, feel free to take them away!"

Would you say they're violating the spirit of such anti-discrimination law if they didn't also pay for the manufacture of gay-optimized condoms at a 1:1 ratio?

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by pessimizer on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:09PM (#13770059)
> They're giving away byproducts that, by their nature, gays/veg's/the deaf cannot use

There is nothing in the nature of these videos that makes them unsubtitleable.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by SilasX on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:11PM (#13770090)
Right, I should have said "that they cannot use in the original byproduct form". But the same point applies, that it costs money to convert it, and the effect of requiring the conversion is to end a free giveaway that promotes a social good.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Thursday March 02, 2017 @05:22AM (#13773037)
> that promotes a social good.

It also promotes a social harm. It says it's fine to discriminate against people with disabilities.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by SilasX on Thursday March 02, 2017 @08:17AM (#13773782)
Only if you believe that any free product given away, such that it isn't usable by everyone, "says it's fine to discriminate against people with disabilities".

Do you seriously believe that no one should be able to give away uncaptioned videos, on the grounds that doing so "promotes the idea that it's fine to discriminate"? Khan Academy should have been shut down until their videos were accessible? Personal blogs?

Do you not draw any distinction here between a class for sale vs its free materials?

Accommodation is great, but you also have to appreciate the costs as well as the benefits.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by fellellor on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:08PM (#13770050)
Except they didn't say NO GAYS. Rather some have meat allergy so they can't eat them. There are a lot of people who are hungry and could really use the free meat, except here a few people with meat allergy come in and say, "Since we're unable to partake in these free offerings we'd rather other people starve".
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by 1_2__3 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:11PM (#13769547)
How do you expect this will work? Everything created by humans from here on out must be accessible to every last minuscule quadrant of humanity or it's banned? Nobody's allowed to release audio without texted or text without audio, or video without text explaining what's going on?
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by SwellJoe on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:25PM (#13769670)
We aren't talking about everything created by humans. We are talking about something created by a public university, partly funded by taxes, and with a rather large endowment.

The ADA does not generally apply to individuals.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:33PM (#13769754)
The fact you think "deaf people" are a "miniscule quadrant of humanity" is interesting.

> from here on out

From 1990, which is when the law was introduced. We should have been doing this for nearly thirty years now.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by simcop2387 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:00PM (#13769470)
I'm not sure about contempt, I'd say indifference or apathy instead. I can only hope that efforts like YouTube's automatic captions get better because it'll I.prove the situation just by giving a cheap way to handle 90% of cases.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by zeveb on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:17PM (#13769599)
> The fact that even after twenty seven years organisations chose to ignore the law shows the contempt that organisations have for people with disabilities.

It costs roughly $1 for a professor to prop his camera up at the back of a room and record himself speaking for an hour, then post it online (11GB @ 3¢/GB = 33¢; we'll add double that for bandwidth &c.); it costs $180-$600 to close-caption that video. The ADA turns lecture videos from something anyone can do to something basically no-one will do.

Yes, life sucks when one's deaf. Yes, it'd be awesome for every organisation to have the resources to close-caption every recorded lecture. But requiring every recorded lecture to be close-captioned merely ensures that to a first order of approximation no lecture will be close-captioned.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by occamsrazorwit on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:26PM (#13770178)
> It costs roughly $1 for a professor to prop his camera up at the back of a room and record himself speaking for an hour... it costs $180-$600 to close-caption that video.

No, both of your figures are wrong. I actually worked in UC Berkeley lecture recording and captioning, and the figures are on the order of magnitude of $10/hour for each. The problem lies in the massive backlog of older courses that would need to be captioned for only a few non-students per course.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by zeveb on Thursday March 02, 2017 @10:19AM (#13774584)
I got my figures for close-captioning from http://www.automaticsync.com/captionsync/closed-captioning-c...

And a 10x increase is still large, although perhaps not prohibitively large.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by occamsrazorwit on Thursday March 02, 2017 @04:40PM (#13778490)
I see, but that website is clearly biased as they're trying to sell their product. Also, they don't even use correct math which makes me even more certain they're just making up numbers. They mention that other places cost $1/minute, and they claim that half of that cost is $3.33/hr. ???
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by shkkmo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @04:08PM (#13871026)
I believe you had a lapse in reading comprehension.

> To add it all up, an untrained captioner could easily spend eight to ten times the length of a video to create a timed caption file. Let’s call it 9X on average, meaning that each minute of video takes nine minutes for this beginner to caption.

$1 / min of video * 1/2 = $0.50 / min of video 1 min of video = 9 min of transcription time $0.50 / 9 min of transcription time = $3.33 / hour of transcription time

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:48PM (#13769893)
I agree that it's immensely frustrating that Youtube's auto-captioning isn't good enough for DoJ.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by neilcrj on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:02PM (#13770003)
> it costs $180-$600 to close-caption that video

It's a public university. They could pay a grateful student a federally-subsidized wage to transcribe 5 hours of video per week, and have it count toward the University's community service quota.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by toss1941 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:23PM (#13769646)
Welcome to the unintended consequences of government regulations. This is exactly what many "anti-regulation" people rail against, but examples like this are rarely brought up by "pro-regulation" arguments.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by reddytowns on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:24PM (#13769656)
> But requiring every recorded lecture to be close-captioned merely ensures that to a first order of approximation no lecture will be close-captioned.

Huh? I do not follow

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by gydfi on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:02PM (#13769485)
Or it shows it's a terrible law and total compliance with it results in terrible effects.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by Myrmornis on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:02PM (#13769484)
Releasing video of academic lectures is showing contempt for people with disabilities?
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:14PM (#13769579)
Making the choice to deliberately exclude people with disabilities, even though there's a nearly thirty year old law mandating accessibility is treating people with contempt.
Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by PeterisP on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:28PM (#13769693)
As properly transcribing a video lecture is more expensive than making the lecture in the first place, it's a reasonable choice to gift something to many but not all people at a small fraction of what the cost would be if it had to be more accessible.

Accomodations are reasonable if they require a small adjustment to the product - like automated speech-to-text transcriptions would be, or making navigation so that it's possible to use with screen-readers for blind people. However, if the required adjustment effort overwhelms the original product, then I'd say that "don't look a gift horse in the mouth" applies - yes, the content isn't perfect, and it's not suitable for many uses, but it's a gift; if you don't want it, then don't take it and it shouldn't be anybody's duty to make that gift differently.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by DanBC on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:51PM (#13769918)
...and this is why just about fuck all has been done for accessibility over the last 30 years and we still have major services that are very hard for people with disabilities to use.

People tried asking nicely, and were ignored. Now people are taking action. We can't say we weren't warned. We were warned 30 years ago when the law was passed.

Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public by setr on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:06PM (#13770031)
You could make that claim if they made such a decision, and you could assume they did if they had to go out of their way to disable CC. But of course, they have to go out of their way to include CC (in time, money and effort) so its entirely absurd to name it "contempt". At best, its negligence, and at worst, its reasonable (the video lectures aren't really related to the school's operations, it just happens to be easy to do).

Really, you could turn it around and call it contempt on the disabled's part, for suing with no clear benefit to anyone