Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by kbenson on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:44PM
(#13768743)
That's a good question. Given that Everytown refused to comment now, to me that either points to them valuing their relationship with Snapchat over the perceived benefit from speaking out, or this not being a very accurate portrayal of the events, and they know enough to know that it's not clear that Snapchat was in the wrong and they don't want to be embroiled in the circus that would result.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by hluska on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:01PM
(#13770000)
Everytown did not refuse to comment; they did not respond to multiple requests for comment. There is a huge difference between the two.
Several years ago, I became embroiled in a local controversy. A journalist reached out to me via Facebook messages. As she was not one of my friends, the message went into the abyss. When the story hit her publication it contained the same "Greg Hluska did not respond to a request for comment."
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by subpixel on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:24PM
(#13769658)
I'm not sure Snapchat would have egg on its face in the scenario you propose.
Maybe there shouldn't be ad space in these types of campaigns, but if they have do have ad slots, anyone can buy them, and I can totally see the NRA doing that.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by jlarocco on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:58PM
(#13769977)
"anyone can buy them"
That doesn't make any sense. The only reason "anyone" can buy the ads is that Snapchat is letting them.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by DannyBee on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:40PM
(#13770271)
Not letting certain people buy them would likely result in some interesting run ins with regulators.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by mynameisvlad on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:55PM
(#13770728)
There's regulations for selling ads in the US? This is news to me.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by kbenson on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:40PM
(#13770967)
I'm almost positive there are regulations of some sort for ads on over-the-air (broadcast) networks (ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox, The CW), as their are specific rules applies for their use of public frequencies. I have no idea exactly how that applies to advertising for broadcast networks. I doubt it affects Snapchat in any way.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by HillRat on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:44PM
(#13771239)
Only in regards to political candidates, who must be given reasonable commercial access; otherwise, nets are free to refuse to sell ad space to other entities, including political groups (e.g., CBS v DNC).
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by DannyBee on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:21PM
(#13771154)
Try being a huge platform and performing viewpoint discrimination against popular viewpoints, and see what happens :)
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by mynameisvlad on Thursday March 02, 2017 @02:17AM
(#13772197)
Legally? Absolutely nothing. Hence why I question your regulations.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by jlarocco on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:59PM
(#13771542)
I think that's probably bullshit. Snapchat can restrict the ads they show as much as they want, as long as they're not discriminating against any protected classes of people.
They have a whole page covering the limitations and what types of things aren't allowed: https://www.snap.com/en-US/ad-policies/
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by lawless123 on Thursday March 02, 2017 @06:35AM
(#13773353)
Are dudes open carry dudes in camo gear not a protected class? :-)
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by the_watcher on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:33PM
(#13770615)
Yea, I probably would have leaned toward calling the bluff. Organizations like Everytown use the NRA as a boogeyman in enough of their campaigns that it's almost assured that they'd get a ton of earned media out of this.
1. Snapchat tries to advise Everytown that ad slots are open and the NRA is likely to capture some of them
2. Everytown can't afford to buy up all the slots at the quoted price
(So far, I think both Everytown and Snapchat are still ok here. No harm done.)
3. Snapchat representative, Saliterman, ends the running email conversation with an email saying this: "To be clear, the story has the potential to be bought by any advertiser, including the NRA, which will enable the advertiser to run three 10-sec video ads within the story."
(At this point, if I were in Everytown's shoes, I would now fully believe Snapchat was acting against my interests. They're not even trying to work with me any more.)
Why didn't Everytown call Snapchat's bluff? Run the campaign, not buy the ad slots, let Snapchat do what they may.
They could have screen-grabbed the resulting campaign and used it to generate _massive_ publicity.
Snapchat would have had huge egg on their face.
I can think of Everytown not wanting to make a spectacle of the families who had suffered such loss. But with advance notice maybe they could have gone to the families and asked politely? It seems likely some would have agreed to let this happen and then fight the NRA on the outcome.
(If I were the NRA, as well, I would be _furious_ at Snapchat for ill-using my ad spend in this way.)
But it's all hypothetical, apparently.