News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dilution by pdog on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:00PM (#13768275)
> Most founders' instincts seem to be to give too much equity to investors and not enough to employees.

Is this wrong? Investors don't receive anything for their capital but equity. Employees receive income, benefits, etc. that have to be factored into the equation.

Re:Dilution by nostrademons on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:13PM (#13768424)
I think this is saying that founders often underestimate the variance that employees bring to their company's success, and overestimate the variance that an investment round brings.

If you assume that employees are basically fungible and that $100K in salary will buy the same output regardless of who works for you and how motivated they are, then it makes sense to raise $10M rather than $2M, so you can hire 100 person-years of work rather than 20 person-years. VCs become the limiting factor.

If you assume that there are wide varieties in employee output that stem from a.) hiring the right employees b.) into the right roles and c.) compensating them so that they're incentivized to do their best, then it becomes absolutely critical to attract those employees and motivate them. It is unlikely that you will attract these types of employees for a $100K/year salary. It is far more likely that you will attract them with a percent or two of equity that could be worth several million dollars.

In my experience, the latter is a much closer description of reality than the former is.

From the entrepreneur's perspective, what investors or employees "deserve" is irrelevant, what matters is how much of an effect they have on the ability to deliver a good product to a big market. Early employees are in the trenches with you every day; the difference between high effort and low effort from them can make or break the company. Investors give you money and often advice/introductions, but you are one of many investments in their portfolio; they are not going to give you high effort.

Re:Dilution by tyre on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:06PM (#13768341)
It's absolutely wrong! Employees are the ones who put in the work to actually build the company.

As you said, investors only put in capital (and sometimes advice and/or intros.) Employees work full-time on the company, oftentimes for below-market rates (what they could reasonably assume to make in salary + benefits at larger companies.)

A company at any size is far, far, far more likely to succeed or fail based on its employees than its investors.

Re:Dilution by maxxxxx on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:25PM (#13768571)
Employees also take more risk. Investors just lose money but employees lose years of their career if things go wrong.
Re:Dilution by kinkrtyavimoodh on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#13768647)
Why would employees lose years of their career? While it's true that early work-ex in a company that eventually becomes Google is great to have, it's not exactly a black mark on your resume if you have worked in a company that didn't do well. You still got plenty of engineering experience.
Re:Dilution by maxxxxx on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:39PM (#13768688)
I was at a failing startup during the .COM bubble. I lost my job in 2002 and was unemployed for almost a year due to the terrible job market back then. Definitely a very existential problem compared to the investors who either lost a small percentage of a large fortune or lost other people's money.
Re:Dilution by 100k on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:39PM (#13768696)
Sadly, four years of "heroic effort at failing startup" doesn't look as good on the resume as "worked at Google".
Re:Dilution by maxxxxx on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:45PM (#13768749)
A lot of startups aren't even technically very advanced so the only thing you may have learned is to work 80 hours per week without complaining
Re:Dilution by g10r on Thursday March 02, 2017 @03:54AM (#13772669)
That experience is invaluable to anyone who can adapt and apply the learned mistakes to future work. Especially so if being applied to a startup environment. You have to be laser focused, gritty, willing fight 24/7/365 for years. This doesn't just apply to the founder/CEO it applies to anyone involved early stage, every day is just too mission critical and the entire team needs to be aware of the consequences. For the most part or most teams, you don't learn that at Google. That's who i'd want on my team at least.
Re:Dilution by sharkweek on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:57PM (#13768858)
Disagree - not saying that a failed startup is better than Google, but honestly there is a lot of appeal to hiring someone who took a shot on something less established. Both have their merits.
Re:Dilution by catshirt on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:40PM (#13769268)
i've had the opportunity to hire a decent number of people at a couple of startups. i hope you can find comfort in the fact i disagree with you. :)
Re:Dilution by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:27PM (#13768585)
Depending on how the investors got their money it could translate into years of their careers as well.
Re:Dilution by edblarney on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:45PM (#13768753)
"Investors just lose money but employees lose years "

Comparative value.

Most employees are fairly well paid, and don't 'lose years' unless they are working for free, or 'very cheap' which usually isn't the case.

Re:Dilution by Gibbon1 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:12PM (#13769021)
How many two year sprints at 150% can you do during your career? One? Two? Three? Yeah you can totally do it again until you can't.

Burnout is a real thing.

Re:Dilution by edblarney on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:54PM (#13769390)
I've worked at a few startups, and with many more - and most of them did not require 150%. The two most successful were unicorns (networking, back in the day), and there we were barely past 100%. We worked mostly 9 to 5. Sometimes there was a push.

The extra bit past 100% is what you get equity for.

Moreover - it's definitely a choice on the part of the employee.

Software developers are generally in high demand, wages are high, and there's no reason to go '150%' unless you feel the 'total package' is right for you.

If service workers were required to put in 70 hours a week for 'no extra comp' then this would be a different story.

Re:Dilution by idiot_stick on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:13PM (#13768429)
>Employees are the ones who put in the work to actually build the company.

Company and work that, in most cases, wouldn't exist without a capital investment.

Re:Dilution by nostrademons on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:29PM (#13768599)
I'd question that, actually. The vast majority of huge tech companies that you've heard of today - Microsoft, Apple, Google, Facebook, Amazon, EBay, AirBnB, Whatsapp, Snapchat, GitHub - managed to construct a working product without taking investment. Several others - DropBox, Stripe, Instagram, Slack - had only a relatively small seed or angel round before launching a product. Meanwhile the track record for companies that take a huge amount of investment before delivering a product - Theranos, Webvan, Go, Magic Leap, etc. - is pretty abysmal.

YC and several other top-tier VCs recommend that you keep the startup as small as possible, oftentimes just the founding team, until you've built a product that's popular enough that you're swamped with demand. Then you can go and raise working capital to fund expansion and fuel growth, but not before. It's not true that the company wouldn't exist without the capital investment, though - it's actually pretty critical that the company does exist before raising capital.

Re:Dilution by mianos on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:21PM (#13768526)
It may be the chicken or the egg, but, if you have some employee that can achieve something that others can't, he can go somewhere else and achieve the same. The money could be equally applied and it will not bring success. No money means failure but no employee means no chance of success, money or not.
Re:Dilution by aanm1988 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:15PM (#13770497)
You can bootstrap a company without VC investment. Good luck trying to build anything without hiring some people.
Re:Dilution by anandkulkarni on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:05PM (#13768326)
In the final calculation, employees are the ones who are toiling day-in and day-out for the company's well being – in a real way, the company's future depends on them more than the investors. It can be more valuable to have them invested long-term in the company's success, point for point, than an investor.

Another way to think about it is like this: if an investor told you tomorrow they'd no longer contribute to the company, versus your first engineer, which would be more damaging? The investor's money is already in the bank, whereas the engineer will cost time and money to replace, as well as disrupting the ongoing development.

Re:Dilution by jimmykennedy on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:09PM (#13768381)
"It's more valuable to have them invested long-term in the company's success." Why? A cash bonus of "If we meet this deadline you will receive $X" is going to increase my productivity much more than "you own 0.01% of an illiquid, unprofitable company". Startup equity is way too abstract for employees to affect their motivation. Peer pressure, mission, pride in work, cash bonuses / raises / promotions are infinitely more impactful.
Re:Dilution by firloop on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:12PM (#13768416)
Sure, the argument isn't that equity is the end-all to employee compensation. But early-stage startups often aren't able to to give (significant) cash bonuses, and more importantly, compensating an employee with equity means that 5 years down the line, you're more likely to have someone on the cap table that both contributed to past efforts that made the company successful and also cares about the company's future.

I think in practice this preference makes more sense when you consider that most of the (non capital based) value that early-stage investors can provide applies mostly to early-stage companies.

Re:Dilution by Retric on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:44PM (#13768740)
It's not about having equity now.

If you have a seed company that fails in two years then the equity equation is meaningless. However, if in two years things are going good, but it's not clear you are the next google then you really don't want to lose key employees and it's going to take more equity to keep them interested. On the other hand if in two years it looks like you will be the next google then getting more capital is easy and you really don't want to lose a key person.

Re:Dilution by rqebmm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:21PM (#13768522)
I'd argue the better analogy is "If you have a great idea, what's more important to get it to market: your first engineer or your first investor?"

The next is always going to be "well, do I have enough money to pay my engineer?" This is why the investor holds all the cards and therefore gets the best deal up front. Without that up-front money there is no eventual business.

Re:Dilution by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:29PM (#13768601)
That's not true.

You have the option to give that engineer a real slice of the cake instead of the misers share that's common. I've seen co-founders be labeled 'engineer #1' because they sat down 15 minutes after the first meeting where a company's founding was discussed.

Non technical founders can - and do - use investors money to try to limit the number of co-founders so they get a larger share themselves. Technical founders are less likely to do this to non-technical co-founders. (But it does happen.)

Re:Dilution by softawre on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:12PM (#13769023)
> Technical founders are less likely to do this to non-technical co-founders. (But it does happen.)

Technical people are so great, aren't they! No bias here.

Re:Dilution by jacquesm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:32PM (#13769212)
It's not that they're 'so great' it's just that they are usually less business savvy and doing less 'jockeying for position'. They tend to not be in it for the money as much as they're in for the challenge which makes it relatively easy to take advantage of them. (Been there, done that, have several t-shirts to go with it and I promise it won't happen again but if I had known 20 years ago what I know now... never mind, hindsight is always perfect.)
Re:Dilution by bbcbasic on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:03PM (#13768915)
My understanding is that employees will be paid less than what they could earn elsewhere, so need to be compensated with some upside for that shortfall.

If I were to cut your pay by $100k to join my company, would you say, ah OK but I am still receiving income & benefits, don't worry about it?

If you have to leave your 9-5 to work for my 10-"late" for the same salary, would you want something extra for that, even if it is just a high-EV lotto ticket?

Another argument, made in the article is that if you want to attract the best talent you need to make an attractive offer.

Otherwise why wouldn't the people you want just go work for Google or another startup, or start their own?

Re:Dilution by CalChris on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:16PM (#13769074)
Employees take a risk. First, they don't have to work for your startup. They could go to work for BigCo and have a secure paycheck. Second, they get options for common stock which vest over years. Generally that first year is at will.