News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by veli_joza on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:45AM (#13762990)
Are you claiming that Unreal still needs a lot of work to achieve parity with Unity?? No.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WC6Xx_jLXmg

Edit: BTW there's a very insightful feature comparison from UE developer here: https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/5wouuw/2017_featur...

Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by pjmlp on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:12AM (#13763087)
No, if you read properly you will see I am claiming these community engines have a lot of road to travel and tires to burn, before they can compete with Unity,Unreal,CryEngine and Cocos2D-x features and tooling.
Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by mikulas_florek on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:32AM (#13763164)
I consider that an advantage, simple things have their appeal. Unity without any 3rd party plugins is very basic, and a lot of these community engines are at the same level.
Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by pjmlp on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:36AM (#13763182)
I was arguing from the point of view of those that think "engine == code" and disregard these engines without everything else that surrounds the eco-system or understanding of how many studios work, which is quite common in the HN Web & FOSS culture.

Good luck with your project.

Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by vvanders on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:20AM (#13764330)
Yup, back when I was in games our ~70 person team was about 10 developers and the rest were artists/animators/designers.

Tooling cannot be understated and most of our goal was to be a force multiplier on the majority of the team who actually do the creative work. That's what these engines bring and while hobby engines are nifty they're not going to be making strides into that space until they have a compelling tooling story.

Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by mikulas_florek on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:37AM (#13764486)
It is said that restrictions boost creativity and I've seen artists do amazing things even though their tools were complete crap. Question is how important tools really are. I would argue that vanilla Unity tools are nothing special and yet it's the most used engine in the world and people make amazing games with it.
Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by talmand on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:30AM (#13765113)
With my former career as a creative in games dev, I say that's complete crap. I had access to good and bad tools. With the good tools I could experiment and test ideas quickly. With the bad tools I spent too much time just trying to get stuff to work. I would want tools that boost my creativity by giving me freedom, not boosting creativity to be able to finish my tasks.

Maybe you are thinking boosting creativity to work within the limits of the hardware? That's a different topic.

In my experience, vanilla Unity has better tools for creative out-of-the-box then many engines before it.

Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by vvanders on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:04AM (#13764777)
Oh please, that's the lamest excuse I've seen to skimp on tooling. Abusing your users with poor tools doesn't win you anything.

Self imposed constraints can (and has in many cases) achieved the same thing.

From a technical perspective unity's tools are nothing special, however they work well for non technical users. In the same way UI/UxD for Linux has been a disaster understanding production needs is a complete different space that few engines get right.

Re:Show HN: Lumix Engine – Open source C++ 3D game engine by mikulas_florek on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @11:50AM (#13765399)
It's all just subjective, nothing of this is proven by any research. From my experience from several game studios (I admit the sample is too small to be relevant) quality of their games was inverse to quality of the tools. Stuff like http://www.geek.com/games/a-train-you-ride-in-fallout-3-is-a... is extremely common.

> From a technical perspective unity's tools are nothing special, however they work well for non technical users.

They are nothing special even from non-technical perspective. I'm not saying they are complete crap or that they do not work reasonably, in fact I think they are so successful because they are so simple/average. Of course constantly crashing tool is not boosting your productivity. But simple tools are.

Look at old Unity UI - it was even worse than most open source UI. The new UI is a bit better but still there are open source projects at least equally good. Or animation graphs in Unity. They are quite simple and they have many issues, yet they enable users to do more creative stuff than UE.