News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by pierrefar on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:13AM (#1374025)
A couple of things:

1. I don't want to gamble again that Facebook will "do better". They've shown many times they actually want to share my personal information in unexpected ways under the cover of ever increasingly-confusing settings pages. Thanks, but I'm done with this crap.

2. From the post: I do not believe that the tech elites who are publicly leaving Facebook will affect on the company’s numbers

Us alone will not affect the numbers but we take people with us. We tell our friends and family to close their accounts.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by lkozma on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:45AM (#1374208)
I'd argue that using FB is pointless, not quiting it. Not using it is the default state of things, so the burden of proof should be on the other side. It's a bit like with smoking.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @12:46PM (#1377879)
The problem is, several of my acquaintances told me that "everyone is on Facebook". When talking to them, the burden of proof is on my side.

But I have a good case.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by credo on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:30AM (#1373947)
Quitting Facebook is an effective way of challenging Facebook to do better. I think Danah Boyd is mistaken in assuming that one precludes the other
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by scorpion032 on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:46AM (#1374505)
If one is quitting, why would it matter to him that they do better, as he cannot gain any benefit out of it.

I would rather join a group "Join this group to emphasize facebook to add simpler privacy controls" than quit facebook. I don't want to lose it. I care.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by humbledrone on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:20AM (#1373933)
Quitting Facebook is not pointless if one wants to maintain a certain level of personal privacy.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by rimantas on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:53AM (#1374150)
You can maintain it without any quitting: just think before you post anything.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by Natsu on Monday May 24, 2010 @07:00AM (#1374298)
That's good advice everywhere, but one of the problems is that Facebook, via your friends, links together all sorts of things that would otherwise be scattered about the internet and nearly untraceable (unless someone had a lot of time to devote to hunting them down). Also, you can't readily control what your friends post about you. And you can't hide who your friends are.

All said, I don't regret not having a Facebook account. And even so, they do still have data on me, thanks to family members and friends (who have sent invitations to join, etc.).

Unfortunately, I don't think most people will care until they're made aware of exactly how much information is being (and can be) collected and what people can do with it.

Google is the same, actually, in terms of potential for misuse, except that I trust the current leaders more. The worry, though, is how long that will last?

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by slantyyz on Monday May 24, 2010 @12:44PM (#1375039)
privacy != you and/or your circle of friends oversharing

Quitting Facebook doesn't stop your friends from sharing pictures that include you that you may not want out there.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by kordless on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:08AM (#1374013)
That's one long blog post! It could be summarized by saying the general public doesn't know or care about the Facebook issues, so we technorati should stick around to help them understand better how the are getting screwed.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Monday May 24, 2010 @10:47AM (#1374732)
I think this post get at least 2 things wrong:

(1) Even if decentralization is not a panacea, it remains the only solution for a host of problems. Including privacy on the internet. Also, personal server as easy to use as Facebook itself are definitely possible. When such servers actually ship, they will be worth the hassle.

(2) Everyone should quit every centralized services on this planet, including Facebook, provided there is an alternative. The logs they gather are just too scarily comprehensive.

That, and 2 most disturbing points:

(1) This post actually encourages us to stay dependent on a big corporation, in the hope that we could influence it for our own good. No, we can't. If we are dependant, they can screw us, and will do so as soon as it yields money.

(2) It fears that more free systems could be used to do child pornography, among other crimes. To me that's FUD: even if she's right, that doesn't mean that the criminality will rise, nor that the criminals will be harder to catch. And we already have Freenet.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by adolph on Monday May 24, 2010 @09:43AM (#1374627)
Right on. Another thing to try is "speaking truth to power." It is probably equally effective.

Sarcasm aside, as long as the service's users are not directly providing all of the revenue to provide that service, there will always be a conflict between the interests of the users (i.e. do not want info shared) and the payers (i.e. want to know how best to advertise).

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by nandemo on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:04AM (#1374006)
I quit Facebook before they were uncool.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by jimfl on Monday May 24, 2010 @09:38AM (#1374613)
Quixotic at best. Facebook provides value to two classes of user. There is no question that the individual users derive value from Facebook, but the idea that they're getting it for free is naïve.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by apphacker on Monday May 24, 2010 @01:57AM (#1373904)
I don't care if they do better. It's not pointless quitting, I now no longer have Facebook in my life. That was the point. "Challenging them to do better" has a strange assumption that somehow we all stand to gain if we can just make sure they get it right next time, or maybe the time after. They're not our friends, they're not an Oxfam, they're a business with a shitty product. I don't challenge Johnson & Johnson to get them to make a better band-aid, because frankly, I don't give a shit. Same with Facebook.

>"I think that we owe it to the users to challenge Facebook to live up to a higher standard, regardless of what we as individuals may gain or lose from their choices."

People need to learn to think for themselves and live with the consequences of their choices. It's not rocket science.

Just a weird article.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bitdiddle on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:12AM (#1374250)
+1 -- a crappy product that is nothing but a thin veneer over an enormous database of private information that they are selling for profit.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by Charuru on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:16AM (#1374446)
I think the product has already proven itself to be valuable...
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by takrupp on Monday May 24, 2010 @09:40AM (#1374621)
In what way? So you can be lazier while maintaining a larger social network? I think Facebook depersonalizes relationships even more so than the email/twitter/IM communication methods.

I dont miss it. There are a few email addresses on there that I wish I had written down, so I guess there is some value, but is that value worth the wasted time getting sucked up in a live status stream (or worse: Your data in such stream)? Looking and commenting on peoples wall? Gossiping? Its a trashy medium, just like the tabloid medium before it, only with different recognizable people and with your life on display as well.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by saturdayplace on Monday May 24, 2010 @10:21AM (#1374686)
Facebook isn't the product. You are. Advertisers are the customers.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bootload on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:17AM (#1374112)
"... I don't care if they do better. It's not pointless quitting, I now no longer have Facebook in my life. ..."

But your friends might and that is the problem.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bad_user on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:03AM (#1374235)
The most powerful thing you can do regarding any service or product is to vote with your wallet ... or in the case of Facebook, with your subscription.

When Facebook loses one user, the quality of their network drops ... insignificantly from a single user, but when speaking about multiple users quiting, then you've got a network effect.

So ironically (thinking about TFA) if you care about the quality of their service the most effective thing you can do is to just quit using it. That will send a message more powerful than bitching and moaning about it in blog posts.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bootload on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @07:43PM (#1379033)
"... The most powerful thing you can do regarding any service or product is to vote with your wallet ..."

It is a big mistake to overlay a monetary system on your friends. This is one aspect users are really getting riled-up with, "monetising friends".

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mike-cardwell on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:51AM (#1374147)
If I quit, Facebook immediately becomes less valuable to my friends. The only value Facebook has to the vast vast majority of its users, is it's ubiquity.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mooism2 on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:26AM (#1374468)
I did quit Facebook.

My friends did not switch en masse to some other service I was using; they still organise parties on Facebook.

A few people quitting Facebook only makes it less ubiquitous at the margins.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bootload on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @07:39PM (#1379026)
"... My friends did not switch en masse to some other service I was using; they still organise parties on Facebook. ..."

That's the scenario I'm thinking would happen. You are but one leaf on the social tree of your friends.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mooism2 on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:23AM (#1374464)
Facebook isn't like a band-aid though, it's more like your local cable company. You don't have to pay for cable, but then you don't get to see all those tv shows that are only on cable. Maybe you can buy them on dvd when everyone's stopped talking about them.

Similarly, you can quit Facebook (and I have). Now I have friends I can't interact with online, because we don't have any websites in common any more.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Monday May 24, 2010 @10:12AM (#1374668)
Why do you need to go through a web site to communicate with your friends online? Don't you have an e-mail?
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mooism2 on Monday May 24, 2010 @12:08PM (#1374944)
My friends don't use e-mail socially.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:10PM (#1375419)
What do you mean by "socially"?

You don't have their e-mail address? Or they don't look at their inbox? Or certain specific activities are done via Facebook, while others may be done via e-mail? And most of all, why? Why did they chose Facebook over e-mail?

More generally, I'd like to know what they use Facebook for, and why.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mooism2 on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @06:02AM (#1376957)
We all use e-mail for password reset e-mails, order confirmations e-mails, etc. For communicating with friends, we just use it for one-on-one communication that wouldn't fit into a text message.

We tend not to share e-mail addresses. Different people use different services (LiveJournal/DreamWidth, Facebook, Twitter, Monochrome, etc) to different extents. Parties get organised on LiveJournal, Facebook or Monochrome.

I don't use e-mail socially because it's a terrible medium for group conversation.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @12:41PM (#1377865)
OK, I understand better. Just a point left:

> [e-mail sucks at] group conversation.

Maybe you actually meant that web based mail sucks at group conversation? Or that e-mail sucks at live group conversation? If so, I agree.

Now, if you actually meant what you wrote, I disagree for 2 reasons: (1) in my experience, forums and mailing lists are basically the same, once filters are set up. (2) centralizing most of my communications to one gateway is far more manageable than having to check several web sites. 2 inboxes is one too many. E-mail notifications help, but at this point, I'd rather use e-mail directly.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by mooism2 on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @07:07AM (#1380010)
Two reasons why I think e-mail sucks at group conversation --- not just web-based e-mail, not just live group conversation:

1. You can't edit past e-mails. This means that if you change the date or venue of your party, I have to discard the original e-mail and preserve the new one instead.

Whereas if it's a Facebook event, you update the details, I get notified about the change automatically, and the original, now incorrect details don't exist anywhere any more; I can't refer to them by mistake.

2. Most e-mail clients suck. Most of my friends are not IT geeks, so most of my friends use an e-mail client that sucks. Which means many of my friends use an e-mail client that doesn't have decent threading support, or makes it too easy to reply-to-sender when they meant reply-to-all, or doesn't properly elide quoted text, or etc.

Which means most of my friends suck at group e-mail conversation. And therefore it sucks for them and me.

I realise that group social e-mail conversations work for you, but they don't work for me.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by loup-vaillant on Thursday May 27, 2010 @03:38AM (#1382991)
Your reasons sound valid. Thanks.
Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bad_user on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:10AM (#1374246)
Personally I love Facebook as a developer ... because Facebook continually fucks their users, I can take advantage of their profiles without feeling guilty about it :-)

Zuckerberg does have a point ... most users just authorize whatever app wants permissions to their data with whatever permissions are asked for. This I know from experiencing the integration of my app with Facebook.

Re:Quitting Facebook is pointless; challenging them to do be... by bad_user on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:48AM (#1374283)
I know I have a cynical view on this, but it's consistent with the way many app developers using Facebook think ... sorry about it, but that won't change with a HN downvote ;)

For app developers Facebook is basically a "whois" for users ... with a single and painless authorization you get access to their name, photo, email and list of friends. If you want to change that, then provide a better alternative.