They also indicate they have been a "team player" during prior incidents: "As early investors in Uber, starting in 2010, we have tried for years to work behind the scenes to exert a constructive influence on company culture. When Uber has come under public criticism, we have been available to make suggestions, and have been publicly supportive, in the hope that the leadership would take the necessary steps to make the changes needed to bring about real change."
So it's hard for me to fault them here.
For the sake of more thought provocation, what do you think about YC's "Founder Ethics" rules, and how would you want YC to respond if Uber were a YC company? http://www.ycombinator.com/ethics/
It's a particularly principled stance.
I don't think being a founder should mean that once the check clears your free to do whatever you want and answer to nobody. I don't think that's a very common arrangement.
These investors are looking for actionable steps that Uber is taking to improve. Not a one-size fits all band-aid PR statement or middle-management meeting.
Not only that, Uber wouldn't even give investors their revenue numbers:
http://www.businessinsider.com/morgan-stanley-didnt-give-bas...
I agree with you here, but I'm drawing a different conclusion. I think investors publicly taking their company to task should be an absolute last resort, but that it's justified in this case, because Uber's behavior is just that egregious.
Up to certain limits, and respecting certain ethical norms. Apparently the Kapors came to the conclusion that those limits had been reached, and that Uber's behavior ultimately failed to meet those norms. Or in their own words: "We are speaking up now because we are disappointed and frustrated; we feel we have hit a dead end in trying to influence the company quietly from the inside."
And so they felt it was time to act by other means.
Founders don't get unconditional support from investors. They aren't therapists or doctors or lawyers. When you take money from someone, you're giving them a promise in return. Yes financial gains are part of that promise, but so is conducting yourself ethically and ensuring that the "business" is just as successful as the "product". Treating your people right is part of the contract.
We're hardly in early rounds for Uber at this point. July 2016 was round 15 and Kapor's been invested in Uber since 2010 as angel investors (essentially round 1)[0].
[0]: https://www.crunchbase.com/funding-round/c76f942969286763614...
> who will trust management to make decisions in the best interest of the company.
And how is letting a culture like this go rampant "in the best interest of the company"?
> EVEN if they don't agree with those decisions, it's expected that they'll be a team player and provide support in whatever way possible.
I don't agree with you there either. It's not the investors responsibility or job to blindly follow the CEO. It's their job to advise them, to be asked for advise and to help correct course. But that also means you need to listen to them and when that's not happening investors need to ensure they're heard.
Therefore, I would hope that people with way bigger wallets than me would be held to the same standard.
From the sounds of things, management has anything but "a full picture". Which is apparently part of the problem.
It's just that the full picture turns out to be a giant dumpster fire, and they don't want to admit that publicly.
Because at this point there's a good chance principals are going to be telling a jury what did they know, and when did they know it.
Uber is facing a catastrophic crisis. This could kill the company, or at least cause massive attrition. If Uber isn't willing to take advice on how to get out of this terrible situation that it has created, it may well die.
And in situations like this, I find it a general rule to never give management the "benefit of the doubt".
Of course, I'm not trying to give you money, but I'd hope other founders don't learn from your behavior.
https://twitter.com/physicsNcoffee/status/834566962998960128
Blind app is anonymous, so obviously this is yet to be substantiated. If this attrition is actually taking place, we'll know very shortly.
They might have been safer if they were a snowflake. But the ride-hailing market has competition. Both from Lyft and just regular cab companies that are (slowly) starting to up their game.
I'm curious about the breach of trust you feel -- surely investors in a company don't relinquish their values or place unconditional trust in the company? The Kapors are not a PE firm, and their ethical stands have been known for decades.
You can't on the one hand benefit from the brand value of investors like Mitch & Freida and not also expect such stakeholders to also expect a certain caliber of behavior by the company.
I think investors in a startup are forgiving of early missteps. Uber is way, way past that stage.
And by "early rounds" you mean $2B, correct?
The way I read it, it sounds like they tried that and found the approach didn't work. So they moved on to "tough love" and are trying an intervention.
To turn that around, is there any situation in which you believe early-round investors can ethically discuss problems in public?
In early rounds, founders are looking for investors who will trust management to make decisions in the best interest of the company. EVEN if they don't agree with those decisions, it's expected that they'll be a team player and provide support in whatever way possible.
I'm sure Mitch thinks what he's doing is in the best interest of the company (and it probabily is!). But, he surely doesn't have perfect information on what's going on (only management has a full picture).