News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by emdowling on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @02:55AM (#13703953)
The biggest issue facing the wearable market is that, despite having all the data, I still don't know what to do with it. We need to correlate cause and effect. It differs dramatically between individuals, so what's true for me is probably not true for you. We have a battle between privacy and usefulness, in that we'd ideally feed data from millions of people into a machine learning algorithm to start helping people actually use and benefit from the data. However, most people don't want to share their intimate health data to the cloud.

Another huge issue is that we haven't nailed the input problem: wearables can measure our energy expenditure, but not our energy intake. Until we can measure that as accurately as heart rate (and not just calories, but the nutrient breakdown too) then we only have one side of the equation.

We still have a long way to go before wearables are truly indispensable, and that's before we start considering the emerging research on gut bacteria and the role it plays.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by jib on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:47AM (#13704371)
Newtonian level of insight into fitness is super easy. (With Newtonian I mean enough true to get the work done, even if there is a higher level of truth underneath, i.e Einsteinian physics, quantum physics)

Weight delta = calories in - calories out

Health preservation requires adequate levels of protein (muscles) and fat (hormones)

Muscle growth requires caloric surplus, adequate protein availability and muscle breaks

Muscle breaking requires progressive overloading of muscles (i.e. do more/harder of the thing you want to get better at over time)

Micronutrients is a thing, so eat a balanced diet or take supplements.

With those five things, 99% of people can do anything they need around fitness.

Wearable fitness does very little for those five things.

Gathering data to further the development of Einsteinian level of insights is interesting - fitness certainly lags behind there, but I dont think any big breakthroughs in fitness will come from that, in the same way that Einsteinian physics didnt change how we build bridges or pipes.

The less sexy but much more interesting point is on changing behaviours around those five things. How do you design technology to change habits?

It is possible to change habits with technology. The obvious example is how mobile phones changed habits, for instance in how we make appointments, navigate and a multitude of other ways. Cracking how wearable fitness can change those is a much more valuable challenge in my view. Can we design wearable fitness that lets you exercise wherever you are?

Tap your fitness device and you're sent to the nearest gym, with a change of clothes and towels etc ready in a locker for you, and the device reading off your exercise plan? Tap it to get your personalized meal prepared for you at your nearest participating restaurant, or a shopping bag sent home to you.

That's where I see the future being for fitness technology - we know the right things to do, they are just awkward to do, so lower the barrier to doing the right things.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by RugnirViking on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:40AM (#13704541)
Issue with this is of course that calories out is not something we understand very well at all. some people burn more, some less. Sometimes it spikes for no reason while sitting in a chair. Sometimes it spikes when people are stressed. Sometimes it doesn't. These are only some of the pitfalls
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by TeMPOraL on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:55AM (#13705082)
You can treat all those spikes as random noise. They don't cancel out the overall trend.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by jib on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:15AM (#13704910)
Right, but you can control two of the parts of the equation fairly well - weight delta (scales, over time) and calories in (nutritional information).
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by joshvm on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:16AM (#13704676)
Unless you have a chronic problem like anaemia, if you eat well, you (probably) don't need supplements. The industry is largely built on profiteering rather than tangible health benefits.

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/07/the-vitam...

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by DanBC on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:25AM (#13705250)
In the UK people are recommended to take a vitamin D supplement, especially in winter, and children under 5 are recommended to take a vitamin supplement of A, C, and D. (Poor parents can get free vitamins for their children.)

And there's women who want to become pregnant (or who are pregnant) who should be taking folic acid.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by Retric on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:23AM (#13705241)
Digestive issues are more common than you might think and tend to get worse with age. Taking a 'daily' multivitamin 1-3 days a week is likely plenty and very cheap. They also become more important with calorie restriction or unusually poor diets.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by bsder on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:00AM (#13704185)
> Another huge issue is that we haven't nailed the input problem: wearables can measure our energy expenditure, but not our energy intake. Until we can measure that as accurately as heart rate (and not just calories, but the nutrient breakdown too) then we only have one side of the equation.

It's worse than you think. Humans expend almost exactly the same amount of calories until they get to extreme amounts of activity. The body simply shunts the available calories to different systems.

So, it's almost all about caloric intake.

See the latest Scientific American (dead tree edition) for a nice article about it.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by iopq on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:32AM (#13704301)
Also, when you eat less your body temperature drops, so caloric intake has to ALSO be adjusted by a lot.
Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by revelation on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @04:36AM (#13704320)
Wearables can't measure energy expenditure, at most they give you an overblown estimate that is only weakly correlated with actual expenditure.

The closest thing to measuring expenditure is a power meter on a bike or ergo, and then you still technically have to do a lab test measuring expired gases from your breathing to estimate efficiency.

Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit by throwanem on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @06:47AM (#13704801)
Even a weak correlation is better than nothing, especially when increasing accuracy seems to require a very well equipped gym and a sports medicine lab.