Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by jsz0 on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:19PM
(#1368896)
Maybe AT&T noticed that Verizon got away with a dramatic ETF increase earlier this year and figured why not? Who's gonna stop us? As the article mentions it's still $25 cheaper than Verizon's ETF. Previously it was $175 cheaper. I can't think of any good reason AT&T would want to undercut Verizon on ETF. I suspect this has more to do with the economy than the day-to-day dynamics of the SmartPhone market. Both AT&T and Verizon are probably seeing a lot of customers not fulfilling their 2 year contracts.
The FCC (or congress if needed) really need to examine this situation. I understand the need for the ETF in the context of a 2 year contract a customer signs but I'm deeply opposed to the lack of transparency on the real value of hardware subsidies and the way the cellular industry punishes people with lack of choice if you don't want to sign a contract. Why does an unsubsidized customer typically pay the same (or more) as a subsidized customer? That's just not fair.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by Retric on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:27PM
(#1368934)
Also IMO, the ETF should be reduced based on the time remaining in the contract. If you have been a customer for 18 months on a 2 year contract they should have recovered 75% of their phone subsidy. Yet they still charge more than that.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by Retric on Friday May 21, 2010 @07:14PM
(#1369274)
They now reduce it by 10$ per month, but still if you compare the discount to the total they still keep 95$ if you break it a month early. (325 - 10 * 23 = 95$)
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by callmeed on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:47PM
(#1369009)
BTW, you can avoid the ETF by simply "moving" to a region that only offers "partner coverage" or none at all ... you may have to give proof but that's fairly easy to do.
I don't normally condone hacking out of a contract like this, but AT&T is probably my least favorite big company on the planet. When we moved our company to Oregon, I actually had my account suspended because of "excessive use of partner coverage" ... despite the fact my wife and our staff all had iPhones but were never suspended.
AT&T offered to let me out of my contract (despite me pleading). So, I unlocked my iPhone and put it on T-Mobile.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by smokey_the_bear on Friday May 21, 2010 @06:44PM
(#1369187)
I moved somewhere where I get 0 bars on either of my AT&T phones anywhere within a half mile of my house. I called them, but they claimed that their map showed that I had coverage, so I couldn't get out of the contract. They also said they would be adding another tower soon. A year later I got an email that they'd added a tower, but the service quality did not improve.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by noelchurchill on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:33PM
(#1368746)
Maybe they're offering Apple even more cash up front for extending the exclusivity agreement, and they're ensuring they're going to earn that money back by raising the ETF.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by bradleyland on Friday May 21, 2010 @06:12PM
(#1369098)
Or maybe someone at ATT realized that their ETF was almost half as much as Verizon's and adjusted it accordingly.
Also, I think it would be fair to speculate that as your "average consumer" starts buying more smartphones, carriers will see more early terminations. Businesses are typically better able to pay their bills and are more apt to fulfill a multi-year agreement.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by Gimpson on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:39PM
(#1368983)
Any chance that this increased ETF might be a sign they'll offer larger subsidies when the new iPhones are released? With several very nice looking Android alternatives out I wonder if AT&T wants the new iPhones to be priced much more aggressively.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by wmf on Friday May 21, 2010 @06:14PM
(#1369107)
The low end iPhone is $99; if they increase the subsidy by $150 they'd be paying you $50. OTOH if the cost of the iPhone 4 increases and they want to offer it for "zero down" then the new ETF makes sense.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by jqueryin on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:15PM
(#1368662)
Sounds to me like Google IO got them a little scared and they don't want customers dropping their plan for another carrier that has a better selection of Android phones.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by tptacek on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:46PM
(#1368798)
You seriously think AT&T can change their ETFs inside of a couple days? I don't think it's possible a company as big as AT&T could finish planning the meetings that it would take to plan contractual changes in that time period.
Beware the tech-colored glasses. Most people don't care what Google does.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by blehn on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:49PM
(#1368808)
Or they might be anticipating an iPhone release on Verizon, in which case about half their iPhone customers would jump ship, and would probably be happy to spend $175 to do so.
Edit: the article says the change doesn't apply to existing contracts, so this theory probably doesn't make sense.
Edit 2: Then again, maybe ATT will have a brief exclusive on the 4G iPhone, and they want to lock those new contracts in before the phone hits Verizon. Ok, I'm going with that.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by pkulak on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:35PM
(#1368756)
Well, it's not for existing contracts. So, it's really having the opposite effect on me. I was strongly considering leaving AT&T for Sprint or T-Mobile and getting an Android phone before this: now it's become a near certainty unless the new iPhone just absolutely blows everything else out of the water.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by bshep on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:58PM
(#1368836)
Exactly, usually cellphone contracts have a clause that allows you to terminate early with no fees if the terms are changed and you do not agree with them.
I've actually done this before, I don't remember the carrier but they raised texting from $0.10 to $0.15 and I called them up and said that I wanted to terminate early since I did not agree to the change in terms. I didn't really use texting, but I wanted to go to a different carrier.
My guess is this is why they are not changing current contracts as that would allow people to leave even faster.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by tjarratt on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:01PM
(#1368846)
I'm just going to hope that this means Apple is releasing an iphone with Verizon, or Sprint. This is a really nasty way to fight customers going to Android phones.
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by cwilson on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:31PM
(#1368947)
Normally when cell carriers make a big change like this (see text message rate hikes in the past for an example) you are actually able to leave your contract free of charge, which is ironic in this specific case.
Anyone know if this applies? If so, bye-bye AT&T when Verizon announces iPhone support (which is probably one of the reasons they are doing this in the first place)!
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by andreyf on Friday May 21, 2010 @04:55PM
(#1368824)
From the article: "If you are on existing AT&T contract this won't affect you until renewal time. If you’re considering an iPhone this must be a consideration before signing up with AT&T now."
Re:AT&T increasing early termination fee to $325
by tjarratt on Friday May 21, 2010 @05:03PM
(#1368851)
I don't follow, how is increasing the cost to terminate your service going to solve the problem of there already being too many people on your network? At best this will keep the problem from getting worse, but not solve it in the least.
The FCC (or congress if needed) really need to examine this situation. I understand the need for the ETF in the context of a 2 year contract a customer signs but I'm deeply opposed to the lack of transparency on the real value of hardware subsidies and the way the cellular industry punishes people with lack of choice if you don't want to sign a contract. Why does an unsubsidized customer typically pay the same (or more) as a subsidized customer? That's just not fair.
I don't normally condone hacking out of a contract like this, but AT&T is probably my least favorite big company on the planet. When we moved our company to Oregon, I actually had my account suspended because of "excessive use of partner coverage" ... despite the fact my wife and our staff all had iPhones but were never suspended.
AT&T offered to let me out of my contract (despite me pleading). So, I unlocked my iPhone and put it on T-Mobile.
I'll never give them another dime.
I think I'll make a web app that generates a fake one for people that want to get out of their AT&T contract.
Lying is wrong. AT&T's charges may be a lot, but two wrongs don't make a write. The ends don't justify the means.
I'd say this is "cracking" out of a contract, not "hacking."
Also, I think it would be fair to speculate that as your "average consumer" starts buying more smartphones, carriers will see more early terminations. Businesses are typically better able to pay their bills and are more apt to fulfill a multi-year agreement.
Beware the tech-colored glasses. Most people don't care what Google does.
Edit: the article says the change doesn't apply to existing contracts, so this theory probably doesn't make sense.
Edit 2: Then again, maybe ATT will have a brief exclusive on the 4G iPhone, and they want to lock those new contracts in before the phone hits Verizon. Ok, I'm going with that.
I've actually done this before, I don't remember the carrier but they raised texting from $0.10 to $0.15 and I called them up and said that I wanted to terminate early since I did not agree to the change in terms. I didn't really use texting, but I wanted to go to a different carrier.
My guess is this is why they are not changing current contracts as that would allow people to leave even faster.
Anyone know if this applies? If so, bye-bye AT&T when Verizon announces iPhone support (which is probably one of the reasons they are doing this in the first place)!
At least until contracts start expiring...