I'll agree that military spending is out of control, and that the welfare system in general needs to do better than cut people off past a certain point, but that doesn't mean we should pay for apartments for English majors with the money we're currently spending on bombs.
Is the welfare system the opposite right now with that problematic gap? Make too little and you're on welfare. Get a job, make too much for welfare, and welfare cuts off, leaving this precarious middle area that many can't make, losing their job again, and then falling back into welfare?
I'm not sure if you're agreeing or disagreeing with me here.
My understanding of the current welfare system is that you get $Y from welfare as long as you make less than $X dollars from a "real" job, but as soon as you make $X dollars at your job, you lose the entire $Y from welfare.
That's a bad system. A better system would keep paying welfare once you make more than $X at your job, it would just start reducing the amount of welfare you receive, e.g. for every $1 you make above $X, your welfare payment reduces by $0.50. This ensures that as you make more money at your real job, you aren't actually suddenly reducing your take home pay.
Basically a negative income tax for those making less than some threshold.
To quote Wikipedia:
At a cost of $56 billion in 2013, the EITC is the third-largest social welfare
program in the United States after Medicaid ($275 billion federal and $127
billion state expenditures) and food stamps ($78 billion).
And this is an example, also taken from Wikipedia, of the way the EITC might work in the real world: For example, a married couple with two qualifying children and yearly income
of seven thousand dollars will receive EITC of $2,810 (going up the hill).
At fifteen thousand dollars, this couple will receive EITC of $5,036
(plateau). And at twenty-five and thirty-five thousand dollars, this same
couple with their two children will receive EITC of $4,285 and $2,179,
respectively.
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit#House...That's why arguments about separating Great Art from Shithead Artists is a constant conversation of "Is it okay..." among adults who care about such things.
If we took half the money we now spend on bombs and spent it on apartments for English majors instead would the result be a better or worse society than we have now?
Just because the money isn't being spent on bad idea "A" doesn't mean bad idea "B" should get funded.
* Keep spending $B/2 on bombs
* Give $B/2 back to the taxpayers instead
* Use the $B/2 to support cultural activities that are not profitable enough to support themselves
> It gets worse. From 2008 to 2014, tenure-track English-department jobs declined 43 percent. This year there are, by my count, only 173 entry-level tenure-track job openings — fewer than half of the opportunities just two years ago. If history is any guide, there will be about nine times as many new Ph.D.s this year as there are jobs. One might think that the years-long plunge in employment would compel doctoral programs to reduce their numbers of candidates, but the opposite is happening. From the Great Recession to 2014, U.S. universities awarded 10 percent more English Ph.D.s. In the humanities as a whole, doctorates are up 12 percent.
> Why? Why are professional humanists so indifferent to these people? Why do our nation’s English departments consistently accept several times as many graduate students as their bespoke job market can sustain? English departments are the only employers demanding the credentials that English doctoral programs produce. So why do we invite young scholars to spend an average of nearly 10 years grading papers, teaching classes, writing dissertations, and training for jobs that don’t actually exist? English departments do this because graduate students are the most important element of the academy’s polarized labor market. They confer departmental prestige. They justify the continuation of tenure lines, and they guarantee a labor surplus that provides the cheap, flexible labor that universities want.
English teachers don't just teach grad students, they teach English majors and just about every other student, as English is a core general education class for graduation in most cases.
This may apply to high school as well.
It should be kept in mind that there are other jobs for PhD besides faculty. (Although I don't know about English; maybe editor, etc?)
I have mostly made my peace with the fact that by going into academia you are trading money for some intangibles, like doing what you enjoy, flexible hours, etc. Anyone who gets a PhD without knowing the risks is...not very smart.
I work in medical research. Trust me, it's not pleasant that total government spending on medical research for a year amounts to the cost of a few dozen bombers. Or that the Iraq War's cost could have funded all our research spending for something like 50 years. But at this point, pointing out how our societal decisions are irrational is like pointing out the sky is blue.
English departments don't normally prepare their graduates teach English as a 2nd language. That's usually done by Applied Linguistics. Applied linguistics also doesn't have the employment problem English programs do. The job market is much better.
You have to wonder how many of those jobs only exist to accomodate the current number of PHD's. The "real" number of job openings could be far lower.
I've taught at a university and felt the pressure to assign higher grades even though I felt I was being fair. The whole concept of aiming to give the same percentage of As, Bs, etc in each group of students is antithetical to the idea of a degree, and is one factor that led to my deciding to never teach again.
Well, that ratio is based on tenure track openings. One wonders how that number changes if you factor in adjunct lecturers somehow. Obviously there's a not a 1:1, but in service departments like that with little research budget, it'd be at least a feasible calculation.
The article also makes the argument that there are only 361 tenure track job openings because universities are temporary workers at beer low pay. That's a strong case for the conclusion of the previous paragraph.
>According to the most recent MLA jobs report, there were only 361 assistant professor tenure-track job openings in all fields of English literature in 2014-15. The number of Ph.D. recipients in English that year was 1,183. Many rejected candidates return to the job market year after year and compound the surplus.
Now, this begs a much deeper, more heady discussion regarding priorities and values within the US Higher Education system. The question to consider is Does this out-of-whack-ratio mean we have too many English graduates or not enough English jobs? And - while you'd probably knee jerk to the former rather than the latter, I think I could make a compelling case to disagree.
It's not that it's wrong to pursue a lifetime in English or Music, it's just very tough to realize that as a nation, the US has its priorities terribly fucked up and refuses to support even a decent standard of living and healthcare for those who would devote their lives to such pursuits. This should be in bold text on every student loan application in the Liberal Arts, and perhaps others as well. We don't need room after room of high minded PhDs talking Milton, but we do need PhDs to be taxpayers, and there are plenty of immigrants year after year that if English was a priority, it would get funding and infrastructure to support both the Educators and Students. Which, as we can see, isn't the case for now.