News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by crystalmeph on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:07PM (#13647678)
I'm not sure why you think it should be a priority for the nation (meaning the taxpayers) to support those who devote their lives to the study of literature. Do those pursuits pay off in some tangible or intangible form down the line that justifies the upfront, and very tangible, expenditure you want taken out of my paycheck?

I'll agree that military spending is out of control, and that the welfare system in general needs to do better than cut people off past a certain point, but that doesn't mean we should pay for apartments for English majors with the money we're currently spending on bombs.

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by wishinghand on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:26PM (#13647847)
> the welfare system in general needs to do better than cut people off past a certain point

Is the welfare system the opposite right now with that problematic gap? Make too little and you're on welfare. Get a job, make too much for welfare, and welfare cuts off, leaving this precarious middle area that many can't make, losing their job again, and then falling back into welfare?

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by crystalmeph on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:34PM (#13647914)
We're venturing a little off-topic here, but I'll walk with you a bit:

I'm not sure if you're agreeing or disagreeing with me here.

My understanding of the current welfare system is that you get $Y from welfare as long as you make less than $X dollars from a "real" job, but as soon as you make $X dollars at your job, you lose the entire $Y from welfare.

That's a bad system. A better system would keep paying welfare once you make more than $X at your job, it would just start reducing the amount of welfare you receive, e.g. for every $1 you make above $X, your welfare payment reduces by $0.50. This ensures that as you make more money at your real job, you aren't actually suddenly reducing your take home pay.

Basically a negative income tax for those making less than some threshold.

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by lelandbatey on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:36PM (#13648709)
It's interesting that you mention that particular welfare structure, since that's actually already used in a huge way in the United States, in the form of the "Earned Income Tax Credit"[0], which while I don't hear it talked about publicly very often, is a huge program that sounds like it does a lot of good.

To quote Wikipedia:

    At a cost of $56 billion in 2013, the EITC is the third-largest social welfare
    program in the United States after Medicaid ($275 billion federal and $127
    billion state expenditures) and food stamps ($78 billion).
And this is an example, also taken from Wikipedia, of the way the EITC might work in the real world:

    For example, a married couple with two qualifying children and yearly income
    of seven thousand dollars will receive EITC of $2,810 (going up the hill).
    At fifteen thousand dollars, this couple will receive EITC of $5,036
    (plateau). And at twenty-five and thirty-five thousand dollars, this same
    couple with their two children will receive EITC of $4,285 and $2,179,
    respectively.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit#House...
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by krakensden on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @09:12PM (#13649157)
You're right, and most programs try to do some sort of gradation instead of a sharp cutoff. Unfortunately, all the programs are different, with cutoffs at different points, with differing coarseness. A lot of this is related to the problem of making taxes doable by hand, which, several years after the invention of the pocket calculator, could be considered a little outmoded. A lot is also related to the general difficulty of making any changes at all to welfare programs.
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by rhizome on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:36PM (#13647928)
I think that in-between area is generally called, "the working poor."
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by dukeluke on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:16PM (#13647754)
It really depends on what we want to prioritize in our culture and country. If we want to prioritize profits and perpetual exponential growth, then it should be obvious that literature should not be prioritized. But if quality of life should be the focus of our country, then it should at least be considered.
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by maverick_iceman on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:31PM (#13648329)
You can prioritize whatever you want. What you can't do is impose your priorities on everyone else. Remember that country/culture is not a moral agent which has goals/priorities separate from individuals.
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by dukeluke on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:46PM (#13648425)
Of course. A culture is made of a bunch of individuals with a common method of communication. I disagree, though, that I can't impose my priorities on others. What makes you say I can't?
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by 6stringmerc on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:55PM (#13665039)
Culture is completely a Moral Agent of Society, and to argue otherwise is ridiculous. Nearly all Art is in close proximity to or a direct result of an internal belief system font of inspiration. How that comes to be expressed by default entails a Message, thus enter twining Morality and Art in ways that can not be separated from Individuals as members of Society.

That's why arguments about separating Great Art from Shithead Artists is a constant conversation of "Is it okay..." among adults who care about such things.

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by iak8god on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @10:29PM (#13649444)
> but that doesn't mean we should pay for apartments for English majors with the money we're currently spending on bombs.

If we took half the money we now spend on bombs and spent it on apartments for English majors instead would the result be a better or worse society than we have now?

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by crystalmeph on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:00PM (#13649579)
I am questioning the premise that making the taxpayers pay for English majors' apartments is worth the money you take from the taxpayers.

Just because the money isn't being spent on bad idea "A" doesn't mean bad idea "B" should get funded.

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' by iak8god on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:09PM (#13649615)
I know. We probably just disagree about the ordering of these possibilities:

* Keep spending $B/2 on bombs

* Give $B/2 back to the taxpayers instead

* Use the $B/2 to support cultural activities that are not profitable enough to support themselves