Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession'
by WalterBright on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:57PM
(#13647588)
If the universities had fewer grad students in English, they'd need even fewer English professors.
I think you have it backwards. If they had fewer grad students that supplied almost-free labor, they would have to employ more English teachers to fulfill those tasks, and raise the teacher to student ratio for English classes.
English teachers don't just teach grad students, they teach English majors and just about every other student, as English is a core general education class for graduation in most cases.
English being a core general education class is actually strange, possibly excepting international students. English is properly an admissions requirement.
This may apply to high school as well.
Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession'
by kbenson on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @11:42AM
(#13653285)
At least for the California State University program, the written communication general education requirement[1] one one of multiple English classes, or a Journalism class. The suggested additional general education pathways are littered with additional English classes.
> It gets worse. From 2008 to 2014, tenure-track English-department jobs declined 43 percent. This year there are, by my count, only 173 entry-level tenure-track job openings — fewer than half of the opportunities just two years ago. If history is any guide, there will be about nine times as many new Ph.D.s this year as there are jobs. One might think that the years-long plunge in employment would compel doctoral programs to reduce their numbers of candidates, but the opposite is happening. From the Great Recession to 2014, U.S. universities awarded 10 percent more English Ph.D.s. In the humanities as a whole, doctorates are up 12 percent.
> Why? Why are professional humanists so indifferent to these people? Why do our nation’s English departments consistently accept several times as many graduate students as their bespoke job market can sustain? English departments are the only employers demanding the credentials that English doctoral programs produce. So why do we invite young scholars to spend an average of nearly 10 years grading papers, teaching classes, writing dissertations, and training for jobs that don’t actually exist? English departments do this because graduate students are the most important element of the academy’s polarized labor market. They confer departmental prestige. They justify the continuation of tenure lines, and they guarantee a labor surplus that provides the cheap, flexible labor that universities want.