To me YC was a largely branding move. It's fashionable to be able to say "yeah we are YC backed".
Too many people in the industry are so caught up with being a "Startup" that they forget that they are just like any other "Businesses" but with far less control over your own destiny and even far less likely to win much money than working at a large company where you have high probability of becoming a millionaire in the same amount of time you spent on your startup.
People are biased and self select their dumb luck as insight that gives them an edge which obviously does not translate or is repeatable-take a look at the graveyard, techcrunch won't get any views reporting anything but hyped up PR pieces.
>To me YC was a largely branding move. It's fashionable to be able to say "yeah we are YC backed".
Reply to the actual comment instead of setting up a strawman. And, you may want to touch on the other point the parent made, namely incentives being misaligned between YC and startups. Indignation isn't doing the brand any good.
Regardless, with every batch that graduates YC, you are effectively splitting the amount of time Partners and Mentors can dedicate to each individual company by an even greater amount. And while YC has added new Partners and Mentors, I'm not convinced that your supply of expertise is growing fast enough to meet the demand that you are creating with each new batch. Then again, maybe you are. I'm sure my perspective isn't the greatest.
I don't want to seem overly-critical, I'm still a fan of YC and I continue to recommend it, but I'm not sure the class of '17 will get the same value that the class of '07 did.
(I have no horse in this race - no affiliation with YC or YC funded companies)
My point is this: for every person added to a network of individuals, the opportunity to create strong bonds with each person in the network is reduced, even while the value and strength of the network itself is increased.
A larger network means more opinions, more expertise and more connections (every person added to the network brings their own network of connections). Thus making the network more valuable to each individual member. However, once networks reach a certain size, that value is often extrapolated indirectly. Someone asks someone else to ask a third person a favor, because the second person knows the third better than the first. Thus, the likelihood or ability for each member to form strong relationships with everyone, or the more VIP members of the network, decreases.
This not a knock on YC or the current cohort. I'm a big fan of YC and I'm fully confident the W17 class is as quality as every other class that's gone through, but network dynamics shift as quantity increases.