News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:03PM (#13599844)
As far as I can tell -- there's some evidence of false flag operations regarding the "stand down and go home" resolution.

There seems to be plenty of voices from the Standing Rock Sioux tribe leadership calling for continued peaceful protest.

[dead]
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:11PM (#13599947)
I personally know people who went to the Standing Rock camp that were not paid protesters.

Interestingly enough, I trust their words more than yours.

For the sake of clarity -- who are the outside donors that are funding the protest and bringing the state government to its knees?

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by forgetsusername on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:17PM (#13600008)
>I personally know people who went to the Standing Rock camp that were not paid protesters.

I didn't see OP claim that there weren't "real" protesters, only that some were paid.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:25PM (#13600090)
Given that (paid) journalists covering the event have been charged as protesters, implying that at least law enforcement lumps the journalists in with the protesters -- there is no doubt a way to support the claim that "at least one 'protester' is paid".

The suggestion that a significant number of the 10s of thousands are being paid is just propaganda though and deserves to be challenged.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jessaustin on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:47PM (#13600310)
Sure, but don't we hear the same "propaganda" every time any group gathers anywhere? If it's not Soros, it's the Kochs; if it's not unions, it's the Russians: whatever boogieman gets you going. In future, can't we just take it as read that some percentage of any group is paid to be there and some higher percentage is accused by someone else of being paid to be there? Is it something we have to worry about?
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:01PM (#13600441)
Unfortunately yes we do have to worry about propaganda.

An example: In Colorado where I live a large number of people contacted their republican senator Cory Gardner to express their disapproval of Betsy Davos for Secretary of Education.

Gardner publicly ignored these voices with the claim that they were "paid protesters". Widespread claims that protesters can be ignored because of a claimed "paid protester" taint should be challenged when false because these claims spread and make it easier to normalize this kind of democracy eroding response from representatives.

http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_58937d6ee4b07595d05a5087

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jessaustin on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:31PM (#13600709)
Frankly I would have expected most R's to vote for the confirmation of R cabinet nominations. One needn't invoke complicated rhetorical scenarios to explain such an action.

Some reportage of confirmation hearings might have left the impression that this particular nominee is some unhappy amalgamation of Satan, Brandine Spuckler, and Richie Rich as interpreted by Robot Chicken. That seems pretty unlikely! Probably this is a simple political disagreement, filtered through whatever media process maximizes those clicks and eyeballs.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:44PM (#13600840)
I brought up this situation because it's an example of a "paid protesters" claim being falsely used in other contexts as a reason to ignore actual human interactions.

I think you are trying to invalidate the notion that there can be a reason for people to disagree other than media manipulation.

I disagree with that argument and I will not attempt to engage with you on the basis of fact until and unless you walk it back.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jessaustin on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @03:34PM (#13601779)
Uhhh... I'm not sure how to proceed here. I don't intend to upset anyone. My point was that R's will vote for R's. If that weren't the intention of the electorate, they would have elected a D. (Isn't the "two-party system" fun!) I don't why we'd need to invoke a conspiracy theory, even one offered up by the R in question, to understand why an R would vote for an R. That is, don't believe everything that politicians tell you, even (especially?) about their motivations for the actions they take.

Perhaps mistakenly, I anticipated an objection to this simple scenario along the lines of "this person is really extra super bad, so normal Congress-critters even from the same party would never have voted for her without being fooled by evil memes, and that's why we should believe that this Congress-critter really does believe in the evil meme of the Soros Army". If you wouldn't have objected thus, I apologize for making an uncharitable assumption.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @05:02PM (#13602586)
I definitely will agree with you about the existence of horrible flaws in the "two-party system" - I don't want to put words in your mouth but if you have it, then I share the belief that large improvements to our voting processes are possible. For my part, I'd like to see innovations like instant run-off voting, mathematically fair drawing procedures for the regional boundaries that determine the shape of geographic voting precincts, strict campaign finance regulations, and deployment of an automatic methodology to turn certain flavors of congressional deadlock into public referendum rather than the baroque set of tie-breaker rules/conventions dominating the strategy behind congressional procedures (in my opinion, the possibility of injecting a little bit of stochastic noise from the electorate into the law-making process would provide a much better incentive structure for how congress critters should think about their differences than the overly deterministic incentives currently in place).

But back to the point - I brought it up not to argue that this particular appointee was any better or worse than some standard, but to support the notion that it is correct to object to propaganda that attempts to discredit voices due to false accusations that those voices are only the voices of paid protesters with a corrupt financial agenda rather than the opinions of actual people who formed those opinions based on their real-life experiences. Deploying this strategy falsely to discredit legitimate opposition groups is inherently anti-democratic, corrupt, polarizing, and very dangerous (in my opinion).

You responded to this expression with a claim that I interpreted as expressing that the only possible disagreement about a particular appointee is a product of partisan media manipulation and therefore its fair game to insinuate that any opposition voices are entirely partisan in nature. Within the context of the thread, I understand you attempted to establish that point in order to suggest that it is 'OK' to spread false caricatures of the opposition voices to the portion of the electorate that is prepared to receive that message regardless of veracity.

I understand the desire to be jaded about politics -- I typically try to ignore as much of politics as I can and tend to think that's the best possible strategy for me. It appears to me though that you take your cynicism further by asserting that there is basically no role in the political process for decision making beyond the level of team sports. All disagreement between members of A and members of B is inherently only about media manipulation rather than the possibility that such disagreement could express something rational about the real world.

I think that world-view (as understood by me) is inherently anti-rational-discourse and is worth disagreeing with.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jessaustin on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @06:25PM (#13603198)
Your "team sports" caricature isn't completely inaccurate, if only because my perception of D-vs-R is that of two ants contending furiously over a postage stamp, while a whole continent of political possibility languishes unnoticed. Sure, if we look close enough, there's probably a difference between one SecEd and another. She'll open a few more charter schools, so a few hundred kids will get a slightly better education and a few dozen teachers will be replaced by their essentially indistinguishable equivalents. That's probably an improvement, on balance, but not one to celebrate in the context of all the rest of the crap that rolls downhill from our rulers.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by kristopolous on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:56PM (#13600389)
The paid protestor story is bait and switch as if to imply no, it's not the for profit corporation doing the pipeline that's in it for the money, it's the protestors - they are the ones in it for the money here!

One side is trying to make billions and someone is falsely claiming the other side is trying to make hundreds and That becomes the story. What immoral, outrageous, reprehensible nonsense.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by protomyth on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:15PM (#13599987)
I know people on both sides. I have relatives on both sides. I was pretty neutral until the latest round of reporting and looking at what's going to happen this spring with the flooding. The long term business impact on all reservations is problematic.

Interestingly enough, I trust my relatives and friends words more than yours.

Soros is the biggest, and yes, the money spent here is a major drag on the state.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by tallanvor on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:21PM (#13600050)
Can you point to any legitimate source that says George Soros is funding the protests? Or are you suggesting real news outlets are purposefully not reporting this?
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by untog on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:20PM (#13600041)
To be clear: do you have evidence that George Soros is funding protests? If you do, you should tell someone in the media about it, as it would be a huge story.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by logfromblammo on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:43PM (#13600291)
Forget about the media. I would love to get into the paid protest game. Not for me, personally, but I know a few people with reasonably flexible work/school schedules and some sign-painting skills, who could really use another source of income.

So how exactly does one get paid for attending a protest? What's the going rate? Is there a bonus for being shown on television or getting arrested? Will any chant phrases be provided beforehand, or are they ad hoc? Will they get a 1099, or is it cash under the table?

If the hypothesis is that some protesters are paid, wouldn't it be prudent to at least test that hypothesis by trying to get paid for doing one yourself?

[Edit:] I have seen multiple instances, from multiple sources, where people are claiming that protesters are literally being paid with actual dollars--not in warm fuzzies or in social justice scrip, but actual spendable cash. They will respond to a crowd photo by saying, "That must have cost [Soros|The Koch Bros.|Murdoch|Redstone|The Illuminati] a few million." I am aware that organizing events costs money, but they seem to think that every individual in the photograph actually got a check for showing up.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by mindslight on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:17PM (#13600582)
You're caricaturing the actual dynamic of astroturfing. The individual protesters only ever get paid in mere goodfeels. If you want actual cash, you'd have to either work your way up the organizing chain or independently consult and convert dollars into "outreach" more efficiently than your colleagues.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by protomyth on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:24PM (#13600084)
What huge story? KFYR has had it on daily for months. Just look at the organizers here and what groups pay them. I don't get why you think this would be huge?
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by untog on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:28PM (#13600128)
> Just look at the organizers here and what groups pay them

That is the information I am asking for. A Google search for "soros site:www.kfyrtv.com" returns nothing.

The reason I ask is that "George Soros is funding protests" has become something of a meme in right-wing circles to dismiss anything from the Women's March, the airport protests to Standing Rock as being little more than some kind of left-wing conspiracy. To date, I have not seen any evidence backing up those assertions. It is entirely possible I have missed it, though, so I'd like to be filled in.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by protomyth on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:01PM (#13600442)
http://kfyr.iheart.com is the radio - they don't have transcripts as far as I can see - I will look when I have time and after I decide if I really want to spend more time on it. At this point we have a flood coming, and the likelihood that no one will want to do business on any of the reservations.

Frankly, when you know people and have relatives on both sides and get told a lot but keep getting called and voted as a liar really doesn't make me want to bother anymore. People forget the problems we are having with rail transport and one of the other tribes being dragged out of poverty because of the oil. I still love my relatives doing the protesting, but they would have been better served if the tribe had bother to do its paperwork years ago.

I don't know about those other things.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by untog on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @05:59PM (#13603016)
> and get told a lot but keep getting called and voted as a liar

I'm sorry, but that's what happens when you make accusations without any evidence. If your relatives are telling you that George Soros is funding protests, ask them why they think that. Or don't - I know what relatives can be like - but don't blankly repeat their claims when you know you do not possess any evidence to back up the assertion.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by kristopolous on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:03PM (#13600453)
That's a sham to discredit legitimate dissent. People are doing immense and terrible sacrifices. The constant propaganda technique is to trivialize the nobility of the actors as if they're paid shills. No evidence needed - just a slander and move on. Such PR hoodwink tactics by big energy are disgraceful. Stop falling for it.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by mindslight on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:05PM (#13600473)
I know you're getting downvoted to #FFF, but you would you mind expanding on the purported business motives behind this?

I'm more than sympathetic to the idea that advocacy campaigns are useful idiots being steered by business interests (and that if you don't see who's doing the steering, then you're likely being steered). But I am also sympathetic to the neoliberal idea that financial alchemists can be on the side of good, profiting from pushing then riding the market into a better local optimum.

And so tossing out "Soros" just triggers my redgroupthink detector - his funding itself wouldn't invalidate the protest (if this were the case, then neither side has any moral authority), but the actual cui bono could.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by MK999 on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:44PM (#13600835)
If oil doesn't move by pipeline it will move by rail.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:47PM (#13600865)
If the pipeline makes the end-to-end cost more effective (which is the only reason pipelines get built; they aren't gratuitous or altruistic ventures by the forms building them), it decreases the minimum market price at which oil will even be extracted from the field it serves.

So it is absolutely not the case, that "if oil doesn't move by pipeline it will move by rail", since, depending on market conditions, if oil doesn't move by pipeline it will sit in the ground.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by mindslight on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @02:04PM (#13601024)
Giving GP the benefit of the doubt means interpreting the comment as "Much oil that currently moves by rail will move by the pipeline", which is valid.

Still that seems like a relatively small business interest, relative to the overwhelming behemoth implied by "astroturfing". The presence of some amount of self-interested business funding cannot invalidate the legitimacy of a point of view, or there would be no such thing as a legitimate point of view. So what I look for is a severe power disparity between the two sides which would swamp the smaller side's point of view.

In this situation, that seems like the oil companies and the legible-business-interest preference of state and federal governments. Railroads being on the opposing side doesn't really alter my appraisal of that balance. But I'd be interested in hearing the involvement of a larger entity that I've missed.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by geofft on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:16PM (#13600003)
Are you saying you have friends and relatives being paid by Soros?
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by beat on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:17PM (#13600007)
Friends of mine have been up there on their own, or donating money and goods. Blaming "paid protesters" is self-deception. What does it benefit you to believe that people aren't doing this because they believe in it?
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by protomyth on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:20PM (#13600044)
Oh, I believe some of them believe in it, as I said I have relatives there. On the other hand, there are paid organizers from various groups here. One doesn't change the other. Plus, I'm just sick of articles like this that just lie and don't check facts. I expect better of the BBC.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by adamsea on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:05PM (#13600474)
The rightness of the cause can be discussed independently of the funding behind those taking action.

Plus, "paid organizers from various groups" sounds weird, you mean, like, maybe the Sierra Club sent someone there to help the protests because the Sierra Club cares about the environment?

Or do you mean, like, the evil George Soros sent his UN minions there to help advance the New World Order?

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by knowaveragejoe on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:40PM (#13600798)
I'd love to hear more from this person, but it appears upon receiving any real skepticism of their claims they've gone silent.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by knowaveragejoe on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:34PM (#13600190)
I've heard a lot of rumblings from the right about Soros etc being behind any real protest activity on the left. In particular with the DAPL, I'm left wondering what he would have to gain from supporting said protest at all, let alone the suggestion that the protest is entirely manufactured to begin with to further his interests.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by euyyn on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:07PM (#13600498)
"Paid organizers from various groups" sounds to me like "people that work full time for NGOs that protect the environment". Which is very different from "people who don't care about the issue at all, and wouldn't be protesting there if not for the paycheck".
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by rgbrgb on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:24PM (#13600079)
Do you have any independent evidence suggesting that protesters were paid? Citing the North Dakota government page is kind of like citing Sean Spicer on inauguration crowd sizes.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by WillyOnWheels on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:20PM (#13600038)
I have never heard of people being paid to protest at Standing Rock under the table. "paid protestors at Standing Rock not filing their taxes" is a theme I have not heard of before. Congratulations.

From the Standing Rock protestors that I am personally acquainted with, the Indian tribes in the area recognize that the only reason the world cares about their problems is because a thousand white people showed up. I am being flippant of course and I realize that it's just not white people.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by geofft on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:15PM (#13599991)
An easy way to demonstrate the truth of the "paid protesters" claim is to show any way one can sign up to be a paid protestor. I have been doing some unpaid protesting and wouldn't mind a check, to be honest.

Until then: FAKE NEWS!

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by Natsu on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:55PM (#13600380)
There was a place to sign up, but it was totally fake and it got exposed in this hilarious interview:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGxwizzUbfw

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by zo1 on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:53PM (#13600362)
I don't think it's the same as getting paid to do it like a job. It's more along the lines of your group or committee or activism organization gets sponsorship from someone. The assumption being that now you(the group) are getting money, you're 'funded' therefore you need to 'do something' that your group advocates or represents. If you are a pro environmental rights organization you would have to send someone to protest a pipeline for example.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by geofft on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:14PM (#13600554)
That's not what's being claimed:

> paid protestors who are going to get in trouble for working in North Dakota and not filing their taxes

The only way you'd be liable to state taxes in ND is if you are literally paid to do it like a job.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by zo1 on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:24PM (#13600637)
Isn't it more likely that that individual was just being a bit facetious rather than seriously claiming these people are getting a "paycheck" for protesting? That is how I took it, and was more trying to expound on how "paid protesting" could at the very least work hypothetically.
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by geofft on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:38PM (#13600774)
No, I don't think that's more likely. The accusations of "paid protesting" have been very consistent that they literally mean getting an individual paycheck to go and protest.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/jan/30/north-dakota...

The Washington Times (note that the Times is a Unification Church-run paper, not the Post) quotes the North Dakota Tax Commissioner as saying he's "looking at the entities that have potential paid contractors here on their behalf doing work," and writes that he's "keeping an eye out for tax forms from environmental groups that may have hired protesters to agitate against" the pipeline.

http://heatst.com/politics/north-dakota-may-take-tax-action-...

Heat Street also quotes a spokeswoman for the tax commissioner as saying, "Since the protesters earned income in North Dakota, they would owe income tax to the state on that income tax per North Dakota tax law. If they do not file for tax year 2016, they would be subject to penalties and interest."

https://twitter.com/foxandfriends/status/828570204670091264

Sean Spicer says that protesting is "a profession" and it's become an "astroturf-type movement", and specifically contrasts it with the Tea Party protests (which consisted of funded organizations, like you suggest—enough funded organizations that the IRS could flag them).

https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/79690018395509555...

The president refers to "professional protestors".

http://abcnews.com.co/donald-trump-protester-speaks-out-i-wa...

Literal fake news website "abcnews.com.co" (i.e., not "abcnews.go.com") has a story about a protestor receiving a $3,500 check.

I appreciate that you're trying to extend good faith, but the way to do that is to believe they mean what they say. If the mechanics of "paid protesting" don't make sense to you, that's because the people you're arguing with are wrong, not because you're misunderstanding them.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jonknee on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:34PM (#13600183)
You're 100% correct, but even if there are "paid protestors" I really don't get why that's a bad thing. Everyone working for the pipeline is getting paid!
Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by geofft on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:22PM (#13600611)
It discredits the protests: it implies that opposition isn't coming from a large number of intrinsically motivated people, but from a small number of people with money.

It's the same philosophy behind paid votes being a bad thing. Even in our capitalist society, we believe that one-person-one-vote leads to a better society than one-dollar-one-vote. You can imagine systems that aren't one-person-one-vote (and they exist; see e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_constituency_(Hong_... in which one real estate chairperson has equivalent voting power to fifteen thousand private citizens), but for whatever reason, America's ideal is one-person-one-vote.

In particular, when the opposition holds adherence to one-person-one-political-voice as one of its own principles, the opposition can't say "So what" without appearing hypocritical. They have to actually address that criticism directly.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by zo1 on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @12:56PM (#13600390)
Would you say the same if said "paid" action was driving/directing public policy? There is a reason there are strict laws regulating money in regulations and public service. This is of course not quite the same but it essentially boils down to "money buys votes". The assumption being that who sends more money wins. That is why I would argue it bothers people.

Edit: grammar.

Re:Dakota Access Pipeline to win US Army permit for completion by jonknee on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @01:22PM (#13600613)
Paid action drives public policy every day, it's the normal way things work. Do you think the people who are fighting for the pipeline are doing it for fun? Like these guys:

https://daplpipelinefacts.com/

Business interests have a huge leg up here because there is money to be made, anti-business interests like not building a pipeline are the ones that have to rely on volunteers. I sure hope there are some paid organizers helping out because they're up against a machine.