Well, not really (see Formula-E). If you want a battery that can sustain high power output (high specific power, e.g. LiFePO4), you have to go to a different chemistry than what Tesla uses (high specific energy, LiNiCoAlO2). Tesla could make a Model S that went fast around a racetrack, but it would mean sacrificing range. Since the 0-60 is mainly a gimmick, it's not worth sacrifising usability for.
> The lack of transmission gives a distinct advantage in surprise-passing a gasoline sports car.
Not sure if the advantage is that great: in the case of a modern >250 hp gasoline sports car with the de rigueur dual-clutch semiautomatic gearbox, the person in the sports car would plant their foot and be in the engine's optimal torque band within ~0.3 seconds. So I doubt there is a disadvantage of the equivalently-powered gasoline sportscar in this situation that is not dwarfed by the noise of human reaction times.
It'd be interesting and fun to see how far you could push the current model with just some software changes and some improved cooling. People have modified air-cooled Porsches to do hill climbs, and so on, so there's certainly some existing expertise in this area. Everything that comes to mind, given the Model S's design, is pretty elaborate however.
EDIT: or diesel
This could actually REDUCE refill times (if the swap out is efficient enough). If temperatures could be controlled to allow it to run in an all out mode, this could be a competitive edge?
Or would this be somehow disallowed? I imagine this would be akin to swapping out the complete fuel tank in a car instead of refueling the tank, and I have no idea about racing rules.
Have you ever watched Formula 1 or NASCAR? They can fill 20 gallons of fuel in ~10 seconds. Do you really think a battery swap system could even come close to competing with that?
And most cars refuel every 14 laps, and races are about 384 laps. Totals over 5000km in 24hrs. That's a lot of batteries...
I still think this is a pipe dream with current battery tech for other reasons (weight, power density, overheating, etc.), but from a logistics standpoint it might actually be possible.
EDIT: thanks for noticing, added metric equivs. The difference was just in the sources I found reporting the units differently.
They replace whole nose assemblies in <30sec in F1. Audi some years ago replaced the entire rear transaxle & suspension assembly at LeMans in < 5 minutes in the middle of the night, because they'd anticipated the potential need for it and done the prior engineering necessary (iirc, that car finished 2nd and their other one won).
Reliability and safety would take some real work, just like the high-speed fuel rigs previously used in F1.
It never took off, I guess because the infrastructure never existed, and because of the aforementioned armor issues. It's too bad. I always thought battery swaps would be an ideal way to deal with the aging of these batteries. Depreciate the value of the battery based on some formula and allow people to get a newer one once their battery passes some usage threshold, seamlessly, and bill them for the upgrade.
There's also the issue of cooling the electric motor.
[1] http://www.pointthepower.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Scre...
As far as practical power, electric is far more useful than gasoline for aggressive city and interstate driving (unless you have a long stretch of open pavement). The lack of transmission gives a distinct advantage in surprise-passing a gasoline sports car. The thrill of instant power cannot be overstated!