Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by tbrooks on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:38AM
(#1357563)
I've been using Spreeder to read online articles and long blog posts for a few years now. I'm amazed at how much information I retain from reading at 300 words/minute.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by steadicat on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:52AM
(#1357627)
300 words/minute looks awfully slow to me. I can speak faster than that. Reading speed can be much faster than speech, especially if you get rid of subvocalization ("speaking" words in your head as you read).
I don't see the advantage of flashing a word at a time. Reading works best when the eye can scan a bunch of words simultaneously. If anything, I'd try flashing a line of text at a time.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by boredguy8 on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:59AM
(#1357652)
300 wpm is average reading. Speaking at 300 wpm with clarity takes a lot of practice, and most listeners require practice to comprehend that rate of speech. Research shows that with compression (i.e. articulate speech sped up, 'contentless' gaps removed), people without training lose comprehension of spoken word at about 210 wpm.
Unless you're talking with former debaters, I'd slow down that speech a little. Even if you live in New York!
Holy cow. I was getting bored and consequently losing focus at 300wpm. No wonder "people" don't like to read, if a huge chunk of "people" can't even go that fast.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by Tekhne on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:29PM
(#1358929)
Unfortunately, I don't have source in front of me, but I've read some research that indicates that subvocalization is actually necessary for full comprehension, and that claims to the contrary are apocryphal. It's probably best to investigate before trying to eliminate subvocalization.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by robinduckett on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:43AM
(#1357587)
That's where I got my inspiration from, but wanted to see if I could code it myself, with the ability to have it "marquee" across, loading different amounts of words at a time, without removing words I may have (or may not have) already read.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by boredguy8 on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:02AM
(#1357662)
The way you're calculating words per minute is wrong. You're calculating the page change without taking into account how many words at a time are being presented. So for instance, the refresh for show 30 / read 1 is the same as the refresh for show 30 / read 30. Yet clearly, if 'read 30' is set, the refresh should be substantially slower than if 'read 1' is set. Refresh in seconds should be (words at a time / words per minute) * 60. Right now you're just doing (60/wpm) and ignoring words at a time.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by boredguy8 on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:13AM
(#1357707)
Set your refresh in seconds to (words at a time / words per minute) * 60. And maybe add a check to make sure the show value is never smaller than the words at a time value? (Though it is a fun, schizophrenic way to experience the start of 1984)
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by Gormo on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:19AM
(#1357737)
Speed reading is great to remember isolated facts and data, but it doesn't work to really understand anything.
If I want to absorb a complex idea and integrate it into my base of knowledge, I need to pause while reading, digest what I've read, figure out its implications, and think about it in relation to what I already know and understand. Speeding up the physical act of reading doesn't add any value here.
When I try to use these techniques, I usually end up mechanically scanning the text word by word without consciously comprehending anything, and having to keep going back to re-read the same paragraphs over and over again.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by boredguy8 on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:27AM
(#1357768)
Obviously there are many ways people process text, but my early efforts at speed reading (and speed listening) were much like yours. With practice, however, I reached a point where I could bifurcate input processing and ideational processing. It was almost as though my eyes were passively accepting information and throwing it at my mind in useful chunks, rather than my mind actively going out to get information and then churning it.
The best analogy I've found is Hofstadter talking about the process of becoming good at Jumbles (where you have to unscramble letters to find the word). Early in the process, he had to actively, at the forefront of his mind, rearrange letters and test them. As he got better, that active task was offloaded to some barely-conscious 'letter combining capacity' that would only toss up fairly plausible combinations. It might not be a real word, but it had a high level of salience, whereas his active thinking-about process would make bizarre, impossible combinations that would include letters not even in the jumble.
Similarly, the 'active' task of reading is, for me, a pretty passive process now, and I actually have more of my mind to devote to thinking about what I read while my eyes do the boring work of getting the input 'inside'.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by brokenmindsets on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @12:31PM
(#1358034)
hi boredguy8, I am really interested in the type of speed reading that you are describing and have started trying to learn to do it myself. I say "your type" since people seem to mean a lot of different things when they say "speed reading". What I specifically want to learn is the ability to rapidly read while maintaining comprehension by making the process less of a conscious activity.
How did you learn this skill? Did you automatically start doing this or was it something you intentionally learned? If you intentionally learned it was there any particular method or book you used? I know there are a lot of books/products about the topic but I don't know which ones actually have value and which don't so I have just been trying them one at a time. I have only met a few people in real life who seem to have this skill and they typically are not able to describe how they are doing it. Any information you can provide would be greatly appreciated, even if it is just a description of the process you went through.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by boredguy8 on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:55PM
(#1359042)
First, I think some of this is just a 'the way we're wired' thing. I picked up the 'reading fast' habit when I was in a program that had me reading hundreds of pages of literature a week with the need to be able to discuss the texts at both a detail-oriented, "What does this line mean?" and a broad-scope, "What is the project of this text?" scale. Many people in my class had painstaking notes: I was able to build up an internal model nearly always. But maybe that's just me.
Second, I think another big component was my involvement with academic competitive debate. This required learning how to process a lot of information, both verbal and written, as quickly as possible, and maintaining an internal map of how various 'nodes' of argumentation interrelated. Having to then organize that into extemporaneous speeches puts it into practice.
Anyway, I don't have a good 'route to get here' because I didn't really catalog the transformation. A few things I do, though. First, I read paragraphs at a time (I also speak in paragraphs at a time: most people speak in sentence fragments at a time). I do this by tracking two points every 2-3 lines: one about 25% of the way in, the other about 75% of the way in. For a long time early on, I was reading with my index finger and pinkie finger touching the page tracing down as I read. I know people talk about "reading down the middle" but that's never really worked for me, but the 'double bounce' does. YMMV. I don't trace now because my hands just get in the way.
Second, I learned to stop "saying" what I was reading. Now, for whatever reason I was never one of those people who said the words out loud while they read. But I was 'saying' them in my head and then translating them. I don't know how to express this clearly: I learned to 'listen' to my eyes, I guess, and I sortof mentally hang out in the 'what does this mean?' zone. So it's still being processed at the word/clause level, but it's 'preprocessed'. I think part of this is because I'm constantly asking "what's going on?" in the text, so there's always a context. The times that doesn't work well, though, is in more rapid dialog. I'll lose track of who is saying what. I also have a tendency to skip names (I'm bad with names in general) and so it becomes, say, "K-lady" instead of "Kahlan". (In my defense, Goodkind ends up making all his characters 'generic good' or 'generic bad' anyway.)
Anyway, hope that helps. Feel free to ask questions: thinking about what I'm doing when I read isn't something I practice much. One thing I learned in high school was to not read where I sleep. I later learned the body gets 'confused' which sortof makes sense to me. I tend to read sitting up with the book at nearly eye level (not in my lap). I also read in the tub a lot (hope that's not TMI).
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by brokenmindsets on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @02:40AM
(#1360304)
Hi boredguy8, thanks for the detailed response. It sounds like you are a "natural" in that you didn't intentionally learn the skill, it just sort of happened by necessity because you were reading a lot. Either way it seems like you are doing a lot of the things I have read other people suggest - ie stop subvocalizing to a large degree, increase the amount of text you are seeing at each fixation (both horizontally and vertically), etc.
Do you find that you have more or less comprehension when you read this way? Is this the only way you read now or do you turn back on the subvocalizing a read slower at times? Do you read using different techniques depending on the material or how well you want to understand it?
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by dlnovell on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:01PM
(#1358146)
Sorry, but that is absolutely not true. Notice that every statement you use to back up your premise contains "I". You may not be an effective speed reader or haven't been able to properly train yourself, but your blanket statement that speed reading "doesn't work to really understand anything" is completely absurd.
The goal of speed reading is to increase the rate at which you can _comprehend_ what you read, not just increasing the number of words your read per minute. My dad practiced speed reading while getting his PhD in business management precisely so that he could read the mountains of dense, academic research he needed to in less time. He can read and comprehend fully around 600 wpm. Try telling him that it doesn't work to really understand anything.
It's not something you can master in a week or even a month. It takes a long period of dedicated practice but it can definitely help anyone willing to commit to the training.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by Gormo on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @12:14PM
(#1361379)
Right, I've explained my opinion of speed reading techniques by describing my experience of having tried them. This is the actual, factual experience I've had attempting to use speed reading - on what basis can you say that this is "absolutely not true"?
Perhaps you're trying to make an implicit point regarding subjectivity vs. objectivity, but if this is the case, I'd point out that (a) the effectiveness of speed reading is an inherently subjective question, and (b) you responded to my anecdote with only your own anecdote, despite explicitly making an absolute claim.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by brokenmindsets on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:16PM
(#1358207)
Hi dlnovell, I am trying to learn this skill. Any advice or book recommendations? Do you speed read well also, or does your comment only pertain to your father? Thanks!
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by dlnovell on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:23PM
(#1358231)
The program my dad used was developed by Evelyn Wood. It's old school, and one of the main techniques is underlining each line of text with your finger or a pen, so it doesn't really work as well for reading on a computer. However, once you train with underlining on paper, your speed without it will still be significantly faster than before. It would probably work normally on a kindle or ipad.
I dabbled with it when I was in high school and had something like a 50% speed up after a week, but I'm not a particularly disciplined student. I'm sure that if I had kept with it I'd have been able to double or triple my reading speed.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by brokenmindsets on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:37PM
(#1358283)
Hi dlnovell, thank's for the response! I have a book on the Evelyn Wood technique named The Evelyn Wood Seven-Day Speed Reading and Learning Program which I believe was written by someone who used to work for Evelyn Wood rather than by Evelyn herself. I haven't been able to get my hands on the original Evelyn Wood training material as of yet. It is really great to hear feedback from someone that this technique has worked for. Thanks again.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by strayrocket on Sunday May 23, 2010 @11:11PM
(#1373678)
You can also use something like QuickReader (http://www.quickreader.net) on the iPhone which implements the guide with a highlight or underline. You can copy and paste text into the app or download books from sites like Feedbooks.com.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by mahipal on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:49AM
(#1357613)
This is a cool idea. I suppose it would need some rudimentary analytics over time to work as an actual training tool?
One suggestion: For me, at least, my reading relies on the shape of the sentence. And I think for everyone they would be looking at the right edge of the sentence as more words are coming in. So it's really jarring to have the right edge jumping around, and it might make more sense to right-align the marquee.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by nhooey on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @09:22PM
(#1359762)
This thing needs to move pixels at a time, rather than words at a time. It's really hard to calibrate your eyes to the next word when the length of the next word is unknown.
You lose the spatial cues of where each word's position is each time a new word is shifted on to the screen. Something like a smooth stock ticker would be much better.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by btilly on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @01:15PM
(#1358199)
Cool idea, but I would prefer it if you calculated words as groups of 5 letters (that's how it was calculated back when I was learning to type), and not as number of logical words. Because right now you're getting variable length chunks of text but my eyes really like to scan in uniform length chunks.
For instance suppose I am reading in 5 word groups. Some groups I read faster than others. So even though my average reading speed is a bit above 700 wpm, at 700 wpm in your application I have noticeable pauses where I've finished the current chunk, and I have chunks I do not finish. It is very frustrating.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by robinduckett on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @12:12PM
(#1357964)
On the second point, how do you suggest I go around doing that?
As for the "blow away the scrolling", I made this to be configurable, sure it's nice to be simple, but I made it so I could tweak it on the fly. You wouldn't have found any chunk size to be ideal if I hadn't made it editable in the first place :P
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by wdewind on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @10:52AM
(#1357626)
Cool
1) It would be cool if the up and down arrow keys would make it faster and slower, or have some kind of gradual slider or something.
2) Doesn't speed reading have less to do with actual linear speed and more to do with effective and efficient scanning of the page? (I've heard people talk about moving from top left to bottom right)
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by conanite on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:00AM
(#1357656)
Cool how sample text comes from the opening pages of 1984 that cover Winston's absolute lack of privacy, describing how the Thought Police can "plug in your wire whenever they wanted to". A topical choice. If only there had been a big social website that would allow him organise a privacy protest group.
Re:Orwell - Improve your speed reading
by bluemetal on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @09:23PM
(#1359766)
that can't be right, but it seems I can do it too
EDIT: it seems to get a whole lot easier to read when i align the text left. when it was aligned right i was wasting time getting my eyes to the always shifting beginning of the new line
http://www.spreeder.com/app.php
I don't see the advantage of flashing a word at a time. Reading works best when the eye can scan a bunch of words simultaneously. If anything, I'd try flashing a line of text at a time.
Unless you're talking with former debaters, I'd slow down that speech a little. Even if you live in New York!
Holy cow. I was getting bored and consequently losing focus at 300wpm. No wonder "people" don't like to read, if a huge chunk of "people" can't even go that fast.
If you know how I can fix that, any advice will promptly be implemented :)
Well, it obviously could, so I guess what I'm asking is are you willing to do it? :) I, for one, would be very, very grateful for it.
And it's updated exactly as you said, and I timed it. "slowly" is exactly once per second as far as I can tell.
http://www.github.com/robinduckett/orwell is the repo, take a look yourself :)
If I want to absorb a complex idea and integrate it into my base of knowledge, I need to pause while reading, digest what I've read, figure out its implications, and think about it in relation to what I already know and understand. Speeding up the physical act of reading doesn't add any value here.
When I try to use these techniques, I usually end up mechanically scanning the text word by word without consciously comprehending anything, and having to keep going back to re-read the same paragraphs over and over again.
The best analogy I've found is Hofstadter talking about the process of becoming good at Jumbles (where you have to unscramble letters to find the word). Early in the process, he had to actively, at the forefront of his mind, rearrange letters and test them. As he got better, that active task was offloaded to some barely-conscious 'letter combining capacity' that would only toss up fairly plausible combinations. It might not be a real word, but it had a high level of salience, whereas his active thinking-about process would make bizarre, impossible combinations that would include letters not even in the jumble.
Similarly, the 'active' task of reading is, for me, a pretty passive process now, and I actually have more of my mind to devote to thinking about what I read while my eyes do the boring work of getting the input 'inside'.
How did you learn this skill? Did you automatically start doing this or was it something you intentionally learned? If you intentionally learned it was there any particular method or book you used? I know there are a lot of books/products about the topic but I don't know which ones actually have value and which don't so I have just been trying them one at a time. I have only met a few people in real life who seem to have this skill and they typically are not able to describe how they are doing it. Any information you can provide would be greatly appreciated, even if it is just a description of the process you went through.
Thanks!
Second, I think another big component was my involvement with academic competitive debate. This required learning how to process a lot of information, both verbal and written, as quickly as possible, and maintaining an internal map of how various 'nodes' of argumentation interrelated. Having to then organize that into extemporaneous speeches puts it into practice.
Anyway, I don't have a good 'route to get here' because I didn't really catalog the transformation. A few things I do, though. First, I read paragraphs at a time (I also speak in paragraphs at a time: most people speak in sentence fragments at a time). I do this by tracking two points every 2-3 lines: one about 25% of the way in, the other about 75% of the way in. For a long time early on, I was reading with my index finger and pinkie finger touching the page tracing down as I read. I know people talk about "reading down the middle" but that's never really worked for me, but the 'double bounce' does. YMMV. I don't trace now because my hands just get in the way.
Second, I learned to stop "saying" what I was reading. Now, for whatever reason I was never one of those people who said the words out loud while they read. But I was 'saying' them in my head and then translating them. I don't know how to express this clearly: I learned to 'listen' to my eyes, I guess, and I sortof mentally hang out in the 'what does this mean?' zone. So it's still being processed at the word/clause level, but it's 'preprocessed'. I think part of this is because I'm constantly asking "what's going on?" in the text, so there's always a context. The times that doesn't work well, though, is in more rapid dialog. I'll lose track of who is saying what. I also have a tendency to skip names (I'm bad with names in general) and so it becomes, say, "K-lady" instead of "Kahlan". (In my defense, Goodkind ends up making all his characters 'generic good' or 'generic bad' anyway.)
Anyway, hope that helps. Feel free to ask questions: thinking about what I'm doing when I read isn't something I practice much. One thing I learned in high school was to not read where I sleep. I later learned the body gets 'confused' which sortof makes sense to me. I tend to read sitting up with the book at nearly eye level (not in my lap). I also read in the tub a lot (hope that's not TMI).
Do you find that you have more or less comprehension when you read this way? Is this the only way you read now or do you turn back on the subvocalizing a read slower at times? Do you read using different techniques depending on the material or how well you want to understand it?
Thanks again for the thoughtful response!
The goal of speed reading is to increase the rate at which you can _comprehend_ what you read, not just increasing the number of words your read per minute. My dad practiced speed reading while getting his PhD in business management precisely so that he could read the mountains of dense, academic research he needed to in less time. He can read and comprehend fully around 600 wpm. Try telling him that it doesn't work to really understand anything.
It's not something you can master in a week or even a month. It takes a long period of dedicated practice but it can definitely help anyone willing to commit to the training.
Perhaps you're trying to make an implicit point regarding subjectivity vs. objectivity, but if this is the case, I'd point out that (a) the effectiveness of speed reading is an inherently subjective question, and (b) you responded to my anecdote with only your own anecdote, despite explicitly making an absolute claim.
I dabbled with it when I was in high school and had something like a 50% speed up after a week, but I'm not a particularly disciplined student. I'm sure that if I had kept with it I'd have been able to double or triple my reading speed.
One suggestion: For me, at least, my reading relies on the shape of the sentence. And I think for everyone they would be looking at the right edge of the sentence as more words are coming in. So it's really jarring to have the right edge jumping around, and it might make more sense to right-align the marquee.
You lose the spatial cues of where each word's position is each time a new word is shifted on to the screen. Something like a smooth stock ticker would be much better.
Although, Spreeder looks much better.
For instance suppose I am reading in 5 word groups. Some groups I read faster than others. So even though my average reading speed is a bit above 700 wpm, at 700 wpm in your application I have noticeable pauses where I've finished the current chunk, and I have chunks I do not finish. It is very frustrating.
- let users play with fonts/colors/spacing to find their optimum setup.
- aggregate user preferences to find good defaults
Then you have an interesting blog post to write.
I think you should blow away the scrolling and have just two controls: chunk size and speed. Personally I found chunk size ~50 to be ideal.
As for the "blow away the scrolling", I made this to be configurable, sure it's nice to be simple, but I made it so I could tweak it on the fly. You wouldn't have found any chunk size to be ideal if I hadn't made it editable in the first place :P
"log in to save your preferences!"
As for "blow away the scrolling", I guess I'm channeling steve jobs: "This is the right way to do it."
People could prefer scrolling text, but from everything I know about reading, they ultimately will read faster if they use chunks.
I would love a "Speedify" button
1) It would be cool if the up and down arrow keys would make it faster and slower, or have some kind of gradual slider or something.
2) Doesn't speed reading have less to do with actual linear speed and more to do with effective and efficient scanning of the page? (I've heard people talk about moving from top left to bottom right)
+1 for right-aligned text.
Edit: I also second mahipal's recommendation to right-align the text.
Does this mean I actually read at 2000 WPM?
EDIT: it seems to get a whole lot easier to read when i align the text left. when it was aligned right i was wasting time getting my eyes to the always shifting beginning of the new line