News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas?

My own habit is to just quickly write down the idea in one sentence and plan to come back to it later. But the problem I am facing is I never really get back to them.

How do you manage things?

( 19 comments | 15 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by mahmud on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:37AM (#1356856)
I had a good idea last week. Today it accepts credit card payments.

Do it immediately, even if to the detriment of you social life and sleeping patterns.

I can't put ideas down. Moment I have one I collect keywords and setup some Google Alerts. Cheapest way to taste a market. Second I would look for clients and email the directly, posing as a "consultant" or specialist, or a seller/buyer in the field. If things look warm, I get the domain name and whip out a brochure site in 2 days. Google apps for email. EveryDNS for DNS hosting. Everything on one $20 VPS.

1 idea every 2-3 months. If you do it twice you will have all the boiler-plate stuff ready to go. ~12 hours of work for a complete image.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by bvi on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:54AM (#1356880)
I'd be very interested if you could go into further detail (on the product development front), just to have an insight into your thought/workflow process on how you move from concept to reality.
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by mahmud on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:21AM (#1356923)
Sure. But I do services, not products.

I have been a freelance software developer for 5 years now; whenever I get a spec for a project, I have this lingering fear in the back of my head that the client might turn out to be sour and not pay me. So I take a deep breath, evaluate the idea with the intention that I might be able to sell my code, iff they don't pay me. During those hours of fear I stalk the company and learn everything I can about them, trying to imagine an entire self-sustaining business.

If it's not something new and exciting, or something challenging, or something I could easily resell, I wont take it with a cash deposit.

Fortunately, things always go well and I take on the project, but as we get to know each other better and talk for weeks, my business side comes out and I become some sort of trusted advisor to them. I ponder the possibility of me consulting with them as a firm, and reach to my contacts for previous clients and other acquaintances for similar interest, and this is when I start researching as well.

I go back to the client with my brochure website, I write down everything I remember about their business needs, and we arrange casual lunches/meetings to see what they're up to and I inform them of my new venture. I try not to explain too much, and let them tell me exactly what services they might think they need from me (I work in marketing and advertising, so the needs are almost all the same; problems customizing COTS and SaaS packages); it's important to shutup and let your client tell you how they think you might be able to help them.

So, by now I have 1day/week gig that pays for the rent. I put together the token automated billing, receipt templates, email notifications, etc. I always have a PDF "Guide Book" document. Something that explains where they can find everything; support email, API keys, setup email accounts, etc.

Then I move on to the next project.

I almost always start something by talking out of my ass first. When I meet someone powerful and influential, I have this knack of opening my mouth and offering to help them.

In the consulting business, it's more important to be reachable, warm, communicative, etc. than to be technically competent. Most people hire me as a programmer but I always end up hiring programmers for them. If you can help someone sketch out the high-level designs and put together a prototype, they're more than happy to spend more money assemble a virtual team to iron out the kinks.

It's very important that you get business. The quickest way to establish your authority is to address the problems one might face in a certain industry/market-segment. When someone tells you they're a brand-manager, or M&A attorney, or VP of sales for telecom equipment, it helps to know a little about their industry and location to say something negative about its current climate. Amateurs are always enthusiastic about business, they think it's all flights, hotels and golf courses. So be weary of anything who tries to hype you into a project or industry. The real veterans are almost always weary.

[Edit:

Once a month I go through my contacts and shoot emails to people or catch them on Skype, just to touch base. I find it fascinating to listen to them talk about their work. And sometimes it reignites our partnership.]

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by oscarduignan on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:25AM (#1356828)
http://orgmode.org/ is a brilliant tool for this kind of thing. And you don't need to know emacs to get started. If you're unfamiliar with emacs then getting it setup does require some persistent effort, however once your over that hill, it's really easy to work with. And I have mine set up so that I can hit a key binding wherever I am and a window will pop up so that I can enter a note or todo item.
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by pierrefar on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @07:03AM (#1357105)
Here is how NOT to do it: keep the tabs open in your browser.

My 2009 new year's resolution was to never have more than 10 tabs open in Firefox. It took a few months (April IIRC), but when I hit the goal, it was the best thing I ever did for my productivity. Sadly I lost the habit and now I'm on 50+ tabs again and trying to lose them.

Scrapbook (a FF addon) is the top candidate for my tool of choice, especially as I have its storage folder in Dropbox and thus syncs with all my machines.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by Zakuzaa on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @07:20AM (#1357127)
Thanks for the Scrapbook+Dropbox tip. :)
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by jacquesm on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @02:33AM (#1356739)
Register a domain for them. That way when I get the renewal bill I am reminded to go and do something about it.

A pretty good sign that it was a bad idea is when I don't remember on the renewal date a year later what I registered the domain for ;)

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by mogston on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:40AM (#1356956)
- Evernote - iPhone Notes - Keeping far too many windows open in Chrome and FireFox as a reminder, - pen and notebook (x 2), - Things for Mac, - Things for iPhone.

All of the above help me to document and organise ideas as i get them.

Sound like a mess?, well yes it probably is to someone else....but documenting ideas as I get them, in the most timely method possible ensures that I capture everything and i'm not left carrying these crazy ideas in my head every night.

Don't worry about not coming back to every idea, but do force a habit of reviewing your list at least once a month, you'll be surprised by what you find in there after just a few weeks!

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by Zakuzaa on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:49AM (#1356970)
>Keeping far too many windows open in Chrome and FireFox as a reminder

I do this. At any time I have more than 70 tabs opened. Last week I abused it; took it to 250. Crashed.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by ecaradec on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:37AM (#1356948)
I think most comments are missing a point. His issue is not on the capture side of his ideas. It's on the execution side.

Read the "4 hour workweek", it give good tips about starting a business on the side. It's a bit over the top sometimes, but it motivate me working on this : http://grownsoftware.com/swiffout (just a project, not really a business, but that book help me anyway ) I think the book is great at convincing you that it's easier than you think.

Beyond that take any idea (ideas are not that important ), work on it everyday for a while and see what happens.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by gtani on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @11:29AM (#1357774)
I put them into a spreadsheet that shows a 4-level hierarchy of concept, sub-concept, sub-sub. Then i roll up the spreadsheet into strings, LOAD DATA INFILE to a mysql db, and index using Sphinx and SOLR/lucene.

All this is pretty easy using rails (or Django, PHP, or grails, I imageine)

(or write some memo's, use Google desktop to index them).

The important thing is describe your business plan/Cconcept in a way that you can find it using your search terms.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by pook on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:26AM (#1356830)
I'm trying to fix the same problem.

My attempted solution is to blog at least a paragraph on it. This way I have a public record of it, the opportunity for feedback, and some sense of progression.

It hasn't worked very well so far, though, because I'm still much more likely to pop open an idea.org buffer and append it into a category where it will gather dust.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by mogston on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @04:41AM (#1356961)
I got a personal demo of Tinderbox from Mark Bernstein at LeanCamp - looks very good for rapid brainstorming and documenting multiple streams of thought:

http://www.eastgate.com/Tinderbox/index.html

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by csomar on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @06:44AM (#1357086)
The question is: Why don't you get back to them? You probably have better ideas or more interesting/priority things to do.

IMO, writing them down is good. It worked well with me if you keep them all in one place. The nearest opportunity/free time take a look and do one.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by Zakuzaa on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @06:53AM (#1357095)
Yes. I never sit idle. But not being able to materialize most of the ideas make me feel like I am losing something everyday.

I do go through them once in a while, that hasn't helped much though.

Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by eande on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @12:35PM (#1358047)
Ideas often spark at a situation where you have little time to take care of it. I use Evernote on my iPhone and PC. After making a short not I usually later on go back and evaluate it. 
Over the years I found this to be the best sorting and capturing mechanism.
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by Concours on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:22AM (#1356824)
I have a google chrome extension for quick plugs, I just open it and write down the idea. I'm into mobile apps these days, so it works really well for me. When I'm done with one App, I go to the next in my ideAa Box
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by pshirishreddy on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @03:08AM (#1356807)
If you think the idea is worth it, spend the time at the first go. :)
Re:Ask HN: How do you manage and organize Ideas? by ahoyhere on Tuesday May 18, 2010 @05:01AM (#1356983)
If you never go back to them, that suggests a failure of motivation and/or structure in your life. After all, if they're exciting ideas, WHY don't you get back to them?

Maybe you should solve that problem first. A tool may help you "go back to them" but it won't help you make them.