News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by jakobegger on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:32AM (#13558559)
Distraction works really well in general; even without VR.

The dentist discovered that my 3 year old son has a bit of caries; but she said that filling a cavity for small kids like him is only possible under anaesthesia. I thought this sounded ridiculous.

My girlfriend found a different dentist who specialized on treating kids. She performed the procedure without any anaesthesia or sedatives by using lots of distractions, including a magic wand and elaborate stories about dwarves wandering in the forest of teeths.

I wish my dentist distracted me like that :)

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by Aaargh20318 on Friday February 03, 2017 @07:31AM (#13559321)
As a kid, I had a dentist who refused to use local anaesthesia, he thought it was 'bullshit' and I shouldn't be able to feel anything. The pain was indescribable. I'm still traumatised by it and haven't been to the dentist in years. I would literally shit my pants out of fear (not exaggerating here, I would have to wear a diaper to undergo regular treatment even with local anaesthetics).

Just the though of being operated on while fully conscious gives me the shivers. The only thing I can image being scarier is when they have to do brain surgery and they wake you up halfway through while your skull is open.

I'm currently on a waiting list for a specialist at the local hospital where they can treat you under general anaesthesia. It's the only way I can be treated after my childhood experiences. unfortunately the waiting list is long. I just hope it's my turn before something starts to really hurt.

I had one treatment under GA before, about 8 years ago, and it was the first and only non-traumatic dentist experience in my life. It was such a huge difference with the 'regular' experience that I simply can't understand why dentists insist on letting people experience the torture. I think they are all secretly sadists that get off on hurting people.

I'm not trying to scare you, just make sure your kid is okay with it because it could fuck him up for life.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by LordKano on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:32AM (#13559999)
I had a cavity filled last year and the dentist told me about how when he was a child, he went to a dentist who didn't use local anesthetics and he felt everything.

He didn't say it but I suspect that he went into dentistry to save other people from what he experienced.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by jakobegger on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:46PM (#13561607)
Ok, it looks like I wasn't clear enough: when I wrote anaesthesia, I meant general anaestesia (narcosis). (English is not my primary language.)

Narcosis for filling a minor cavity seems like something that should only be necessary as a last resort.

I wouldn't have a problem with local anaesthesia, but it just wasn't necessary in this case.

He came home from the dentist and told me how he turned on the tap with his magic wand. No sign of trauma anywhere.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by gozur88 on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:12PM (#13562887)
What you wrote was clear to me.

It seems a bit unlikely a dentist would be able to distract a kid from excruciating pain.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by pavel_lishin on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:03AM (#13560714)
Soviet dentists didn't use anesthesia either. I experienced quite a few visits that would probably be considered war crimes if they were done to captured combatants. It took a long time for me to be able to visit the dentist regularly.

I'm sorry what you went through, and I agree - let the kids have anaesthesia.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by SamReidHughes on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:41PM (#13563119)
People often wake up dumber after general anesthesia.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by BigJono on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:20AM (#13559586)
My guess would be that GA is an order of magnitude more dangerous than most routine dentist procedures like root canals or teeth extraction. Most people would rather suffer through the pain than add extra risk to the operation.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by Aaargh20318 on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:10AM (#13560254)
That is only looking at the physical part though. It doesn't take into account the psychological damage that is done. I'm pretty sure I've got a form of PTSD as a result of my childhood dentist experience and I suspect my anxiety issues are at least somewhat related to it.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:33PM (#13561494)
GA may be "an order of magnitude" more dangerous if you are already very sick or have it administered by a non-specialist. In the hands of someone who knows what he is doing, the risks are orders of magnitude lower than even crossing the street to go to work every day.

There are two main real reasons why a dentist prefers to go without GA:

- no need: most dental procedures are minor, and well-conducted local anesthesia is sufficient. Unfortunately, dentists often underestimate the pain and anxiety generated by some of their actions.

- not alone anymore: if you want anesthesia, you have no other alternative than getting a specialist, who will have to be paid. Furthermore, the anesthesia provider will interfere in care decisions if required, making him a pain for the dentist.

So yeah, mainly money...

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by SamReidHughes on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:07PM (#13563765)
Are you saying this with awareness of claims like this?

http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/294966.php

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by credit_guy on Saturday February 04, 2017 @02:25AM (#13566068)
Is that difference statistically significant? For those who don't have time to click the link, they looked at 53 kids who received GA and 53 who didn't. The average IQ of the first group was 5-6 points below the second. Now the stdev of one IQ is 15, so the stdev of the average of 53 is 15/sqrt(53)=2.06. The stdev of the difference of two such averages is then 2.06*sqrt(2)=2.91. A 5-point difference is then a 1.72 sigma event and a 6-point move a 2.06 sigma event, and the probabilities of more extreme events are 4.3% and 2%. I guess that's statistically significant, but not by much.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by SamReidHughes on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:44AM (#13567605)
Look, I didn't read the paper, and it's not the only one.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by detaro on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:51AM (#13559732)
Is avoiding pain really a good reason for GA? At least in my dental procedures (and I've had quite a few for my age), the operations itself where uncomfortable, but the painful part was afterwards, when the anesthetics wore off.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by Aaargh20318 on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:09AM (#13560244)
Depends on the type of pain. The pain afterwards I can manage, the pain during is of a completely different magnitude.

But even if they could guarantee it would be 100% painless, I would opt for GA every time. The problem is being operated upon while fully aware of what is happening. We don't even treat animals that badly. If you bring your dog to the vet to have tooth fixed they put him under, but a human has to suffer through the experience ?

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by blktiger on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:41PM (#13561560)
GA can be extremely dangerous for some people. I know someone who has had several knee surgeries without GA because they don't handle GA well enough to make it worth the risks (death, for example). There are very good reasons why a lot of procedures are done without GA.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:57PM (#13561697)
It is highly likely that even if your relative is very sick, the odds of him/her dying due to general anesthesia are pretty low. The amount of people for whom GA itself is "extremely dangerous" is extremely small. Anesthesiologists optimize. Their job is to counsel you on what they think is best, to lower the odds of complication. We often have to put people under who are very, very sick due to surgical constraints. A crushing majority of the time, nothing bad happens. It's all a question of lowering the probability.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by TeMPOraL on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:50AM (#13560113)
Motivations vary wildly. My mother actually had root canal treatments with no anesthetics whatsoever, solely to save money on anesthetics. OTOH my SO now saves money to get all her teeth fixed under GA, because of her fear of dentists.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by willismichael on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:40AM (#13559685)
I'm with you, in that I avoid anaesthesia when possible, but be careful making sweeping statements about "most people" without having some data to back it up. My off-hand guess is that "most people" would prefer GA.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by justin66 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:44AM (#13559706)
> Most people would rather suffer through the pain than add extra risk to the operation.

That might be true when people are making decisions about their kids. I question whether it's true of people making decisions for themselves.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by LordKano on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:37AM (#13560027)
I suspect the opposite.

A few years ago I had to have a gastroscopy and the doctor was baffled that I refused GA.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by pc86 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:03AM (#13559487)
Go to the dentist, you do not want bad teeth. Brushing and flossing 2x/day is not always enough (and 1x almost never is).
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by derefr on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:32PM (#13561483)
No matter what you do (or your dentist does), if you have bad lymphatic circulation, any sinus infection has potential to turn into a root-pulp infection necessitating a root canal. I've had five of those—and no cavities—in the last four years.

I finally decided to research the problem, and ended up taking diosmin (not for any of its on-label uses, but simply by the logic of its pharmacodynamics: it increases lymphatic flow rate, like blood thinners increase blood flow rate.) Eliminated a bunch of other circulation problems I never really realized I had at the same time.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by redirectleft on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:14AM (#13559551)
Can confirm. 23 years old, 5 years no dentist, aggressive paradontosis with 2 teeth already dead and a lot of gum recession. Can't eat apples or steaks any more. Go to your god damn dentist.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by notheguyouthink on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:18AM (#13559914)
I feel your pain, i'm in a similar boat with less excuse. Any recommendations for choosing a dentist? I've got a lot of work to be done, so i want someone competent, friendly, etc. I fear price gouging for something that is already more expensive than i can afford.

I've got so much work to be done i need to construct a long term "game plan" with this to-be dentist. So, yea.

edit: I should add a bit of "dentist phobia" as well, i suppose. I don't claim it normally, but my heart is racing just reading this thread -_-

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by redirectleft on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:47AM (#13560095)
I live in Europe so I unfortunately cannot recommend ways to find the best dentist in the states. Dentists here choose depending on need first because a lot is covered by insurance anyway. However you should definitely see more than one dentist and ask all of them for a care plan. It's called therapy and cost plan here, there surely is something similar everywhere.

By the way, don't be scared. I have no excuse also, and thats very liberating. Distance yourself from the story in the head - for it is root of all suffering in this world. Underneath, everything is and is okay like that.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by was_boring on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:11PM (#13561318)
30, haven't been to a dentist in 9 years. Scared to go, but no pain or bleeding. I brush every other day...

That being said, I've had a lot of work done -- the front to half of most of my teeth is fake. The fake enamel saved my molars. I know this because my last dentist was a preventative and let's fixa problem when it is a problem type, not an aggressive one.

I do not understand why fake enamel is not standard. It works -- I'm proof. It's almost like dentist want you to suffer and use their services.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by bjelkeman-again on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:40AM (#13559688)
I suspect it depends on your diet as well. I am less good at brushing/flossing than I used to be, but have a healthier diet (less processed foods) and go sometimes for years without needing anything beyond plack removal.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by wil421 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:03AM (#13559484)
My friend was in the Marines and had to get is wisdom teeth removed. Lucky for him they were training Marine dentist at his base.

He said they wiped some type of numbing gel and proceeded to grab his wisdom teeeth out with pliers. The trainee couldn't get them out so the instructor climbed on his chest and yanked them out.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by thearn4 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:26AM (#13559619)
My wisdom teeth happened to come in pretty straight and level. When I was in the Army, the dentist there suggested having them taken out during AIT (primary MOS training school), but it wasn't an order. I nope'd right out of that because I had heard about a dozen stories like yours.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by wmblaettler on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:12AM (#13559538)
I can confirm. I had the same experience minus the trainee. Had my wisdom teeth extracted while in the Marines. It was over in less than 30 seconds - no time for anesthesia to kick in nor do I remember him administering any. Crack, crack, yank - done.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by sandworm101 on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:19AM (#13560839)
Much depends on the position of the teeth. Pulling some with pliers would cause so much bleeding that choking could kill the patient (teeth still well below gum line).
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by derefr on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:37PM (#13561526)
You could just do the operation with the patient laying face-down on a massage table (the kind with a head-hole), so that the blood runs out of their mouth instead of down their throat. Might be a lot of blood loss, though; you'd want to wear goggles while doing the yanking. :)
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by TallGuyShort on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:22AM (#13559932)
My wisdom tooth extraction was a minor disaster. I have an extremely sensitive gag reflex, and the surgeon just couldn't do his job. Had to knock me out.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:47PM (#13561612)
I don't know how old you are, but old medical theory stated that babies, and by extension small children, did not feel pain due to their nervous system being immature. By "old theory", I mean no more than 30-40 years... Needless to say, the attitude towards that has completely changed since then, and dental care for children is now commonly done under general anesthesia when necessary.

As for children being potentially struck for life by that, you are absolutely correct. It is also valid in adults, as I have been unfortunate enough to witness first hand during my younger years.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by maxerickson on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:17AM (#13559569)
A big part of it is that going under general anesthesia is more dangerous than not going under general anesthesia.

It's also more expensive than a vial of lidocaine and takes longer.

I had a filling put in last year. Local anesthetic only. No pain. Took about 20 minutes.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by falcolas on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:23AM (#13560346)
Counter anecdote - I've had a few root canals and fillings in the last few years. The first one was with a doctor who refused to re-apply the local. I was all but climbing out of the chair from the pain.

Went to another dentist a few years later to let the experience dull in my mind - this one would re-apply the local, which made the experience tolerable, but hardly pain free. And that doesn't cover for the feeling/sound of the drill. And the smell. Gods below, the smell of burning tooth, root, and plastic... That's me you're burning up there!

Seriously thinking about GA next time.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by pavel_lishin on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:00AM (#13560689)
When you say local, you do mean a novocaine injection, right? Not just the numbing gel they smear on your gums first?

Tell your next dentist that you're very sensitive to pain, and they'll up the amount of novocaine, and the locations they inject it. I suffered for awhile before telling the dentist, and making them take me seriously, and they started injecting more, making the procedure bearable.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by falcolas on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:32PM (#13561489)
> a novocaine injection, right

Indeed.

> Tell your next dentist that you're very sensitive to pain

That's what I did. Still wasn't pain free, apparently I have deep roots, and Novocain wears off faster. Bad luck, I guess.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by maxerickson on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:48AM (#13560570)
Many dentists use water cooled drills. Shop around?

I do have the good fortune of having seen the same dentists for 20 years.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by dkersten on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:37AM (#13559674)
I've had a few procedures done over the past year (root canal, extraction, wisdom-tooth extraction) all under local anaesthetic. Quick and painless, just like your experience.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by Aaargh20318 on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:03AM (#13560191)
The pain is not the issue, being stuck in the chair is. I get really anxious just getting a haircut.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by maxerickson on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:10AM (#13560258)
I was not trying to tell you how you should experience dental treatment.

I did feel it was useful to respond to It was such a huge difference with the 'regular' experience that I simply can't understand why dentists insist on letting people experience the torture. I think they are all secretly sadists that get off on hurting people. with my contrasting experience.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by pavel_lishin on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:05AM (#13560734)
Do you mean general anesthesia, or local, or just the nitrous oxide?

If the cavity doesn't reach the nerve, it's probably painless. But if any serious dental work needs to be done that's going to hurt, telling jokes isn't going to do it.

Signed, someone who grew up under the soviet dental system that didn't use anesthesia, and consequently suffered what would amounts to torture during several visits.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by coldtea on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:20AM (#13559587)
So you risk a kids excruciating pain on the mere promise of a doctor being good with distractions?

And for what?

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by olalonde on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:10AM (#13558860)
Complete medical newbie here... What is wrong with anaesthesia?
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:27AM (#13558910)
The classic risk in dental procedures is the dentist using a lidocaine-adrenalin mix, which when injected into a vessel (by mistake), will make your heart race, your blood pressure skyrocket, and provoke a general sense of unease/impending doom. It is also the main reason why many people say they are "allergic" to anesthesia. In fact, the complication profile of amide-class local anesthetics is very safe. As for the interaction of anesthesia with development, scientific evidence is scarce and anesthesia alone does not seem to have such a great impact on the long term. Anyway, I would be far more worried about hypnotic drugs than local anesthetics in that regard.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by throwanem on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:34AM (#13559097)
> a lidocaine-adrenalin mix, which when injected into a vessel (by mistake), will make your heart race, your blood pressure skyrocket, and provoke a general sense of unease/impending doom

Wait, that's not supposed to happen? I pretty much just figured oh well, it's epi, what are you gonna do.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by viewer5 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:17AM (#13559571)
> and provoke a general sense of unease/impending doom

Oh shit I thought I was just weird. Do you have any more information on that? I felt that when I was getting a crown put in, it was horrifying, "impending doom" is the perfect description.

It also happened the (one) time I donated blood, though I don't remember being given any injections or anything though; but I felt that EXACT same "impending doom" sensation; at the time I thought basically "well this is the end, they accidentally took too much blood and I'm going to die now". I felt cold to the core and started sweating horribly and spontaneously, just like the time at the dentist.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rubber_duck on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:39AM (#13559682)
>I felt cold to the core and started sweating horribly and spontaneously

Isn't that low blood pressure ? I felt that once when I had food poisoning, collapsed to the ground after having insane stomach pain for an hour trying to get to the phone to call ambulance, fortunately by the time I got up it cleared up.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by viewer5 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:42AM (#13559696)
I don't know; at the time, I generally had high blood pressure, and I don't know anything about what might cause it to raise/lower in the short-term (obviously losing blood would, but I dunno if a controlled, intentional blood-drawing for a donation would be enough)
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by masklinn on Friday February 03, 2017 @07:33AM (#13559325)
> The classic risk in dental procedures is the dentist using a lidocaine-adrenalin mix, which when injected into a vessel (by mistake), will make your heart race, your blood pressure skyrocket, and provoke a general sense of unease/impending doom.

And there's a fun side-effect, or at least I had that: body learns to completely blow up under stress. Before I went through that I had very low stress impact (psychological stress had no physical impact), since then stressful situations almost lock me up (heart racing, muscles contracting, …). It's really quite annoying.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by d33 on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:13AM (#13558869)
The risk of any side effects, especially in a yet-to-fully-develop human? I wouldn't be surprised if the list included coma because someone got the dosage wrong. It's just not worth the risk at that point.

(Disclaimer: I have nothing to do with medicine)

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by pc86 on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:05AM (#13559501)
> I have nothing to do with medicine

And yet your response is just supposition ("I wouldn't be surprised if...").

Anesthesia is fine.

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by saiya-jin on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:27AM (#13558909)
You are mixing local anesthesia with complete pass-out by using NO2 or similar for surgeries (which has 1:10000 mortality ratio if I recall correctly) and side effects.

Local anesthesia can be even in form of spray instead of injection, depends on severity. Heck, once I tried to chew coca leaves and that got me pretty numb in my mouth for quite some time, couldn't articulate properly etc.

It's still chemistry put into the body messing up with pain signaling, but I wouldn't worry that much about it (or you'll go crazy with all possible things that could harm a kid one way or the other)

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:34AM (#13558929)
PLEASE do not state fear-mongering numbers without source, especially about medicine! Anesthesia is safer than traveling by plane, nowadays. According to a 10 sec googling, the mortality is now sub 10/million/year, and that's including high-risk populations. source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2697561/
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by dagw on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:23AM (#13559602)
But even those numbers show that the death rate for kids aged 0-4 is significantly higher[1] than for older kids and young adults. I know that doctors on the whole really try to avoid having to put kids under for just this reason.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2697561/figure/...

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:39PM (#13561545)
The common guideline is 6 mo and 2 yo. Those ages are commonly viewed as cutoffs for risk levels. In our hospital for example, the presence of an attending will be required for induction/waking up of anesthesia under 2 years old. Under 6 months, the risk of respiratory complication is far greater, which is why surgery is withheld until that age, except in emergencies.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by maxerickson on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:22AM (#13559594)
US commercial airlines haven't had a fatal accident since 2009. I think that's a better apple than 'traveling by plane'.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by saiya-jin on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:56AM (#13560656)
PLEASE understand the meaning of "if I recall correctly". I was wrong.

Not everybody is attempting to write a post in an online forum about in form or article for Nature or Science, backchecking every statement in every sentence. Jeez

Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by rscho on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:42PM (#13561563)
I do understand. It's not a problem for me. But look at all the terrorized people commenting on this story. They already think anesthesia means death to the kids, or something. You are not helping them.
Re:A surgeon is giving patients VR instead of sedatives by westmeal on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:00AM (#13559000)
I definitely agree that it works wonders. When I was a child I had a dentist work on my teeth using the same technique, albeit it was jokes instead of story-telling.