Compensating for the fact that only the upper reservoir provides power, storage cost is around $180,000/MWh for Bath vs $475,000/MWh for Tesla.
Still significant but at least in the same order of magnitude, and this technology is still improving more rapidly than pumps and turbines. And, the batteries I could put close (or in) cities, potentially saving another 5-20% on transmission losses.
I'm now wondering how the operational cost of this will look. Rotating equipment will show wear and I'm assuming Bath has quite some cost on that side. However, that thing has been in operation for over 30 years, and tesla only gives guarantee for 5000 cycles on the powerwall, or about 15 years (assuming 333 cycles a year). If you would actually need to replace the batteries after 15 years then I don't see them beating pumped hydro in the short term, if you can use them for 10'000 cycles with just a loss of capacity, then I think the finances can make a lot of sense.
1: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=100+USD+in+1977+conver...
This battery project can be built in small increments and does not require local land in a proper geometry that can be flooded. Most good pumped storage possibilities in the US are built out already. Pumped storage also wastes more of the stored energy.
It took 7 years to build the hydro facility? Wow.
Batteries can be installed much faster: it's been 4 months since the announcement of Tesla's selection making it ~ 24 times faster to implement than that pumped storage station.
Because they don't have to rely on natural features and since they're smaller so they can be scattered more, they can be placed nearer to the population they serve or their power sources.
But these two generators don't deliver the equivalent power, 72,000 MWH versus 80 MWH so 900 times difference. Are we going to say that to generate the equivalent power the battery plant would need to be 900 times bigger and therefore take up to 900 times longer to build? 900 x 4 months = 3,600 months = 300 years.
> they're smaller
Again, these two generators don't deliver the equivalent power, 72,000 MWH versus 80 MWH so 900 times difference. Are we going to say that to generate the equivalent power the battery plant would need to be 900 times bigger or that we'd need 900 of them, each with their own facilities and connectors and security placed near the population they serve?
You're off by at least a factor of 5 on the $/MWH for this pumped storage plant, even without the longevity and O&M. A factor of 2.2 on the cost, and a factor of 2.4 on the capacity. The $1.6B cost is in 1985 dollars[1]. In 2016 dollars, the cost is $3.5B [2]. The capacity at 3GW is only 10 hours, not 24 hours [3].
The solution is to look at Lazard's analysis of the levelized cost of energy storage. [4]
For the purposes of the transmission system:
Pumped Hydro: $152 -- $198 / MWH
Lithium Ion: $276 -------- $561 / MWH
Note that these costs are per MWH delivered to the grid, accounting for all the costs over time of that system.When lithium ion battery prices fall by 50%, they now match the most cost effective storage out there. This will happen within 10 years.
It's amazing how fast the technology is changing. Pilot projects like this one should be happening all over the country right now, because within 10 years, it will be the only cost-effective way to do these things.
[1] http://www.crcnetbase.com/doi/pdf/10.1201/b10778-1
[2] http://www.in2013dollars.com/1985-dollars-in-2016
[3] http://www.energystorageexchange.org/projects/4
[4] PDF: https://www.lazard.com/media/438042/lazard-levelized-cost-of...
You can put a Tesla station anywhere in whatever size you need.
We need to build these industries, as they are our future. And if we're not building them, we'll just be buying from somebody else.
Re-read the description of Bath County and you will find that they pump from the upper reservoir into the lower reservoir. Therefore, adding the capacity of the two reservoirs and dividing by the flow rate is a bad assumption.
That's pretty damn good actually.
The max flow rate is 51,000 cubic meters per minute (not per second) according to the article you link to. That changes the math quite a bit.
It has a listed cost of 1.6 billion USD built in 1977-1985, a capacity of 70,000,000 cubic meters of water (the sum of the lower and upper reservoirs on the wikipedia page) which at the max flow rate of 51,000 cubic meters per second is ~24 hours of generation at capacity. The page lists the generation capacity as 3000MW and so you can calculate a storage capacity of 72,000 MWH.
These numbers give $533,333/MW of generation capacity and $22,222/MWH of storage.
The article seems to show the cost for the Tesla station at $38 million. This gives $475,000/MWH of storage capacity and $1,900,000/MW generation capacity.