As for withdrawal I don't think I have ever felt it with nicotine but it might be because I just don't ever do enough (the most pieces of gum I have had in one day is 40mg of nicotine.. ie 10 pieces). I have had a nicotine hangover with cigars but this is usually because alcohol is involved as well as I believe cigars lower intake of oxygen (just a theory.. probably wrong).
Caffeine withdrawal is awful.. absolutely awful for me. Headaches for days. I usually give up and pound 4 ibuprofen with a large cup of coffee.
Nicotine withdrawal (non-tobacco) is nearly unnoticeable, while nicbacco withdrawal can be a little annoying. Although, while I smoked for years, I never smoked more than a pack or two pipes full a week, so perhaps it scales.
Neither compares to the full on pounding headaches, teeth grinding, and occasional auditory hallucinations that can accompany cold turkey, n pots a day caffeine withdrawal.
I rate caffeine easily on par with opiates in terms of the length and discomfort of their withdrawal.
What do you mean by this? Caffeine withdrawal over nicotine withdrawal seems like a no brainer to me with what I've seen from smokers, but I don't smoke so I can't say first hand.