Re:Android permissions and hypocrisy
by m_eiman on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:48AM
(#13461029)
Can they access this while running in the background?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Android permissions and hypocrisy
by sschueller on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:50AM
(#13461041)
Yes, you can write a background service that will be called when there is a change in the clipboard. You can even close the app and it will be restarted in the background when a clipboard change happens.
I know this because I wrote an app[1] that does precisely this and looks for a specific URL in the clipboard. I was surprised when I found out I don't need to ask for permission to read clipboard changes.
[1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.schueller....
Ouch, that sounds like something that should have a permission. Permission for background or programmatic access, none needed to receive pastes initiated by user seems reasonable IMHO.
That would require reliably deciding whether the action was in fact initiated by user, which is hard in browser environment and probably impossible for android.
The answer to that may actually be quite simple: The keyboard app is the one that should be allowed to read from the clipboard. Now can a keyboard spy on you clipboard contents? Sure. But it can also spy on all your keystrokes, so the trust must already be there.
That assumes that clipboard can only contain text, which I'm not sure whether is so on Android, but on all major desktop UI systems clipboard can not only contain arbitrary data, but even allows for negotiation of supported formats between source and destination.
Re:Android permissions and hypocrisy
by candiodari on Monday January 23, 2017 @05:42AM
(#13461241)
But, that's done on websites as well, and frankly it's annoying. Giving apps the ability to put stuff into the clipboard and extract it out again has been made too hard (and one of the few remaining applications of flash).
I'd even settle for the ability to put stuff in the clipboard programmatically ...
This is a case of overly broad security imho.
Re:Android permissions and hypocrisy
by ploggingdev on Monday January 23, 2017 @06:37AM
(#13461471)
> But, that's done on websites as well
Can websites running in background tabs access the clipboard contents on the Desktop?
Re:Android permissions and hypocrisy
by emodendroket on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:28AM
(#13461707)
In my experience browsers won't let you see the clipboard at all unless the user initiates a paste event.
The spec says no, but there's no guarantee that a browser implementation doesn't "through an implementation-dependent mechanism" give this access by default. https://www.w3.org/TR/clipboard-apis/#event-handlers-that-ar...
This is, incidentally, used by KDE Connect and possibly other apps to do clipboard synchronization with PCs.