News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:18PM (#13453218)
Its actually pretty easy to enforce if you still need a trade partner. We'll just embargo your goods at the dock and charge you daily storage fees. (We as in countries exacting their pound of flesh).

If you don't want an activity to occur, you must disincentivize it financially.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by Mikeb85 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:24PM (#13453243)
And how do you ensure compliance when half the Eurozone wants to exit? Yes, you can exact revenge against one rogue member, but several at the same time?

Not to mention, ruining their economy also ensures you won't get paid. Will private creditors stand for that?

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by NetStrikeForce on Sunday January 22, 2017 @07:32AM (#13454906)
> And how do you ensure compliance when half the Eurozone wants to exit?

Half the Eurozone? Last time I've checked, Britain wasn't half the Eurozone. Even better, Britain has never been part of the Eurozone, so what exactly are you thinking about Mike?

Do you really know the topic at hand? Mind you, it's OK to give your opinion without knowing the topic; but it's also OK to point out that the above is wrong and based on misinformation.

EU != Eurozone

P.S.: I'm sorry I've stalked your profile for exactly 2 minutes in order to get some context of who I am talking to. You claim to be studying economics, yet you fail to understand the difference between the EU and the Eurozone - being the latter purely economic and the former mainly political. I have also noted you are very keen on commenting about EU disintegration and passing biased opinions as facts (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406733).

What's your agenda, Mike?

P.S.2: Ok, just spent 2 more minutes (I just scrolled down your last 4-5 comments) and I know now what's your agenda.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by jimnotgym on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:26PM (#13453251)
That is not at all clear Mike. Even the French nationalists have dropped their calls to leave. This sounds opinion based
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by Mikeb85 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:08PM (#13453390)
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by pikzen on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:09AM (#13454076)
The plan to drop out of the EU was removed from the FN's website because it was the one measure that was too unpopular with their voter base. Of course, it may just be for appearances, but I guarantee you that any Frexit plan would start up a shitstorm the likes of which have never been seen, and I wouldn't feel safe in the Elysée
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:37PM (#13456873)
http://www.frontnational.com/le-projet-de-marine-le-pen/poli...

That's their up to date position concerning Europe. They're calling for an end to the euro, a reintroduction of national currencies, and end to the Schengen zone (national sovereignty over borders), and article 50 of the Lisbon treaty is specifically mentioned...

You're right though, their page concerning a referendum to outright exit has been archived.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by quickben on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:36PM (#13453277)
They can exit, but they would lose the richer part that stayed to trade in and buy their goods. It's a mess. The private creditors will probably want the opposite of exit, stability and more money, so they would be against any exits.
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by tw04 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:44PM (#13453299)
>Not to mention, ruining their economy also ensures you won't get paid. Will private creditors stand for that?

No, it really doesn't. It may incite a war, but it won't ensure you don't get paid. See: post-WWI.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:41PM (#13453289)
Have you not seen the negative financial consequences Britain has experienced from Brexit? Their currency has lost its strength and companies are looking at moving out. It's not all sugar plum fairies and nationalism.
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by laughfactory on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:56PM (#13453348)
Wow, that's quite the personal attack there. One of the things we learn in Economics is short run versus long run. Yes, Brexit is causing and will continue to cause a great deal of short run pain for Britain, but in the long run I believe it will prove to be the better choice. The problem is that we all want things to be great and pain-free in the short run, and in the long run. But almost by definition that isn't possible. There are always trade-offs. If you over consume today on credit, you will be paying a future premium for the short run easy living.

The point is, attacking someone personally, for their opinion that the long run gain will outweigh the short run pain of Brexit makes you look less informed, and more like someone who (without critical thought) believes the media propaganda: which focuses exclusively on the short run pain of Brexit.

Read up.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by Mikeb85 on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:14PM (#13453402)
What negative consequences? A slight drop in their currency?

The point of them exiting is to reclaim blue-collar jobs through protectionist policies. Not entirely progressive, but it'll likely accomplish that singular goal.

No, it's not all sugar plum fairies, but the electorate decided they'd prefer protectionism and nationalism to the status quo, they want blue collar jobs, not to maximize GDP or the exchange rate.

Edit - I should also add, nowhere did I mention what I thought is the best course of action. The fact is, there's a growing movement to leave the EU. Draghi is making threats. I question the legality and practical application of these threats. Maybe someday I'll write a blog post or something about Europe and economics. For now I'm done school and working on a business of mine.

As the other poster said as well, protectionism isn't contrary to economic orthodoxy. It's just not considered particularly progressive.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by laughfactory on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:00PM (#13453361)
Also: the EU is clearly imploding. Anyone with half a brain can see it is so. It was pretty clear from the outset that the long term viability of the Union was quite tenuous. I'm surprised it has lasted this long, honestly.
Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by alva on Saturday January 21, 2017 @09:47PM (#13453313)
As he studies economics he is probably aware of quarterly GDP growth rates across the EU, including 2016/7 + projections.

Or is GDP "sugar plum fairies and nationalism."?

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by toomuchtodo on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:15PM (#13453405)
GDP is a poor reflection of quality of life. The US GDP is "healthy", yet the middle class continues to evaporate and people keep ODing in rural areas from no future prospects.

EDIT: I suppose its okay to be poor if you were the one to make the decision. I hope for an educated electorate in the future.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by alva on Saturday January 21, 2017 @10:27PM (#13453437)
So your original post was in regard to negative financial consequences, not quality of life. So far the UK has far exceeded expectations since Brexit especially compared to EU countries.

Luckily you have articulated and agreed with one of the main drivers behind Brexit. Quality of life is not dictated by GDP. Brits were repeatedly warned of the potential economic (short and long-term) consequences of Brexit (short term turned out to be absolutely incorrect) but decided having full sovereignty was worth it. They decided Brexit would lead to a better quality of life even if it meant a weaker economy.

Re:Any country leaving euro zone must settle bill first: ECB... by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2017 @02:46PM (#13456934)
> I hope for an educated electorate in the future.

It's not about the electorate being educated/not educated. Part of the problem is that the uneducated working class hasn't benefited as much as the educated/elites in society.

Part of why globalism was pushed, is the idea that by outsourcing/eliminated manufacturing and other blue collar work, our society could become more educated, and focus on an 'information' based economy. What wasn't anticipated is just how many people would be left behind, due to many factors including inequality, rising education costs, and then the fact that not all blue collar workers are cut out for university/office jobs.

Anyhow, both globalism and protectionism are valid economic policies, depending on what you want the outcome to be. My personal opinion - both are highly flawed, but no one is ready for anything more progressive.