News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by pjc50 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:40AM (#13425411)
Even a little attention to acoustics could make the open or quasi-open office much better for workers. At the moment, you're expected to deal with this yourself by putting on headphones and overwriting the noise with music.

The "modern" open-plan office in which I work is particularly bad at acoustics. The dining area has a dome, which looks nice but sounds like an echoing railway station. I avoid it because I can't make out conversations in that kind of environment. Said dining area is isolated from the rest of the office by a partial wall that does not go all the way up.

All walls and ceiling surfaces are smooth and flat to maximise acoustic reflection. When we first moved in, the glass-fronted meeting rooms were echoing little boxes that were also impossible to hold conversations in, so we had to fit fabric acoustic suppressing wall hangings.

Offices could do well to learn from the "modern bar vs. traditional pub" layout approach. The bar is open and loud; conversation requires either out-louding people or leaning into someone's ear. The traditional pub "snug" has wooden half-partitions into booths, lots of fabric on the seating, maybe a few wing chairs, and a twisty internal layout. The ambient volume is much quieter.

An office laid out like a snug would still technically be "open" but would stop noise travelling across the office. Even just an acoustic suppressant ceiling would make a big difference.

Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @05:44AM (#13425423)
You are also at the mercy of where you are seated, not just wrt acoustics, but also how loud the people nearby are.
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by pjc50 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @06:24AM (#13425595)
Yes, but most adults tune themselves somewhat to the ambient level. So having a loud incoherent "murmur" from the rest of the office also makes your neighbours louder.
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:47AM (#13425943)
This is culture, and personality, dependent. Many adults do not do this, IME
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by JBReefer on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @07:17AM (#13425809)
The sale guys seem to compete to be the loudest, not revert to the mean.
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by WorldMaker on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @11:42AM (#13427708)
There are similarly competitive people in engineering disciplines, even. I think many of us know that person that when trying to argue why their problem solution is the best problem solution tend to try to be the loudest person in the room. (Some of us work to reform in college; others might be that way their entire lives.)
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by pjc50 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @06:29AM (#13434935)
Back at university I went to dinner with one of those people who liked to talk loudly over other people, and another person who was normally soft-spoken but had been an officer in the Navy and therefore professionally trained in loudness.

The ensuing loudness war almost got us thrown out of the restaurant.

Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by mbel on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:12AM (#13426379)
> Offices could do well to learn from the "modern bar vs. traditional pub" layout approach. [...] The traditional pub "snug" has wooden half-partitions into booths...

Booths, partitions... just like qubickles?

Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by fnord123 on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @10:33AM (#13427004)
Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by toomanybeersies on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:57PM (#13432593)
My coworking space has acoustic dampening all over the place, which helps heaps.

We have booths for phone calls/skype/whatever as well as multi-person booths for meetings which are all super well dampened, you can barely hear people outside of them.

I guess they're very similar to a snug like you're mentioning. We also do have some acoustic suppressing things hanging from the roof (it's a very high-roofed office). There are also seperators at the desks b

Re:Workplaces need more walls, not fewer (2014) by aries1980 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @03:58PM (#13439428)
It is not just about the acoustics, but visual distraction. You can make vacuum silence with 3M earplugs + Peltor X5A as I do, but that doesn't help sensing people walking around me.