It's brutal. I ended up way down at the far end of a level (a sewer I think) only to find that I was missing something I needed to do or have from back near the beginning. Lack of attention gets punished hard. Great game though, you really feel like you earned beating each level.
Games that up the difficulty by making the mobs bullet sponges, meh.
(With that said, some levels in the first were a real grind to deal with all the guards.)
I don't particularly ever wish to revisit The Cathedral. Spent three hours retracing my steps trying to find about 15 gold...
It's well worth a try if you've never given ghosting a shot, although the game design doesn't always permit it.
No, I didn't make that up. Someone on the looking glass forums brought it up as a joke. I don't think anyone has done it yet, though.
Given how many games there are blind runs of, though...
Thief 2 was almost entirely composed of human enemies, and even had some missions where you couldn't knock them out - or even be seen by them.
Aside from the no-kill requirement, higher difficulties reduced the amount of items you could find, increased the number of objectives you needed to accomplish, and greatly increased the number of guards you had to deal with.
It's also an absolute blast to play, and an important piece of gaming history (one of the first First Person Stealth games, helped codify 3D stealth as a genre, engine later used in System Shock 2, had some influence on Warren Spector's next game, Deus Ex).
While the renderer wasn't particularly impressive for the time, the AI, sound, and lighting engines were, which was essential for a stealth game.