News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by olegkikin on Monday January 16, 2017 @09:41AM (#13410193)
The author makes a classical mistake, thinking that the displaced low-skill workers can and will gain high-tech skills. I think that's a complete pipe dream. Yes, millions are employed in IT and engineering, but we're talking about billions of uneducated or barely educated people who will lose their jobs very quickly.

If you want to see what happens when people go into IT out of necessity, look at the Indian IT market. It's full of "programmers" who can't solve the simplest problems, who hate what they do, who produce really low quality code. (And don't get me wrong, India has their share of talented and brilliant guys, but the average case is rather bad).

Not only that, we don't have the IT jobs, even if all of them did learn to code.

As far as I can see, welfare state is inevitable, as much as I'm against it. It's still better than to let people lose their homes and/or starve.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Moshe_Silnorin on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:36AM (#13410965)
It seems clear to me that there is an IQ cutoff below which one cannot be an effective programmer. And this cutoff is actually quite high, comparatively. I'd be very surprised if more than 5 percent of the population, with the current distribution of intelligence, could become effective programmers, even if highly motivated. All psychometric evidence points to IQ being largely genetic, and the environmental components irreversible after after a very young age. It's odd, but my very "conservative" view on intelligence and heredity, that of agreeing with the scientific consensus, leads me to support some forms of wealth distribution.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by api on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:53AM (#13411100)
You've really hit on the elephant nobody talks about because talking about actual inborn differences in human ability is taboo across the board.

What we will see in the 21st century is a large fraction of the human population fall off the edge where the marginal value of their labor becomes <=0 no matter what they do. They can't change this because they got a bad hand in the genetic lottery, which is not their fault.

This is very different from industrialization 1.0. That created a lot of jobs because the machines were dumb, and because economic growth was huge. Now the machines are smart and growth is slow.

Welfare state, violent revolution, or absolute surveillance state totalitarianism and starving ghettos. Pick one dystopia. I think welfare state is definitely the least of these evils.

Eventually we could fix this with augmentation and universally available genetic engineering, but the tech is not ready and the social, philosophical, and religious understanding and assimilation is even less ready than the tech. The process of cultural adoption cannot even begin until the tech is mature enough. Unskilled labor disrupting AI will arrive long before the means of improving ourselves.

Edit: some have brought up the Flynn effect and evidence IQ is growing. Unfortunately even if true I think it's far too slow. Automation tech is advancing much faster with a decades shorter iteration cycle. Doubt digit median IQ growth over decades would probably be required to prevent mass unemployment at the scale of billions and that's pure sci-fi.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by fellellor on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @02:07AM (#13415686)
The IQ cutoff thing is, to me clearly, arrogant bullshit. In fact your whole comment seems like nothing but arrogant bullshit. If overall intelligence were indeed entirely genetic, since western societies operate on meritocracy, then the upper classes of these countries would be full of supremely intelligent uber mensch or whatever. That however, even from cursory inspection, is definitely not the case since you have more than your share of rich and stupid individuals.

Programming is nothing but an area of work which is more suited to people with a certain analytical skill sets. There are plenty of cases of people from diverse backgrounds excelling in this area in spite of the obstacles in front of them.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Moshe_Silnorin on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @10:54AM (#13418509)
The upper classes do have higher average IQ, an effect which is more pronounced the more meritocratic the society. Yes, there are lots of stupid rich people and tons of smart impoverished people, but we are talking about averages here. As most people desire wealth and intelligence is your capacity to realize your desires, intelligent people acquire more wealth than less-intelligent people. As intelligence is very heritable, this has unfortunate class implications. I’m not endorsing this description as normative, I just think it is accurate. This state of affaires is allowed to be both true and objectionable. Natural selection is a horrible process that runs on death and suffering, it would be very odd if it shaped our variations in a manner that matches our ideological preferences.

> Programming is nothing but an area of work which is more suited to people with a certain analytical skill sets.

If you think you can turn 100 IQ people into productive programmers, you could make billions by training your own staff and undercutting everyone else. Give it a try.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by cm2012 on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:48AM (#13411054)
Intelligence is not as set in stone as all that over time. The Flynn effect is well documented across different societies, showing a rise in the average population IQ by ~3 every year, and by 10 every 30 years. This means if you need an IQ of 110 to be a programmer, the average person will be able to do it in 30 years.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Moshe_Silnorin on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:51PM (#13411593)
It seems to have stopped in developed countries: https://www.gwern.net/docs/iq/2016-dutton.pdf
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:43AM (#13411016)
Consider a Trump voting factory worker who lost his job. There is nothing (besides his own pride) preventing him from taking up elder care, house cleaning, nursing or something similar. This is a necessary economic transition.

As the article notes, a BI makes it easy for this person to avoid making the necessary transition into the pink collar economy. The result is that our elderly are not sufficiently cared for, our high skill labor has dirty houses, our patients don't get adequate nursing care, and similar things.

Why should the elderly suffer without adequate care simply because this person's misguided pride is preventing him from taking on pink collar jobs?

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by big_youth on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:43PM (#13411520)
I think your alternatives for a factory worker are interesting as they are jobs whose wages I know are being driven down by (often illegal) immigrant labor. House cleaning is the most notorious and has almost always been done by fresh off the boat immigrants for peanuts, I pay my mexican maid in Austin $75 in cash for a day of labor. Elder care pays employees a bit more but usually less than $10 an hr. How many jokes are there that maids or elder care nurses are from foreign nations? Just the other day I saw a Seinfeld episode where the elderly care taker was african and didn't speak english. Of your suggestions the only with decent pay is nursing which requires a degree and my mom constantly complains about the thousands of oversee nurses they fly over every year to drive down her wages. Similar to how Tech the employers complain about the huge talent shortage but don't pay competitive salaries and rather import labor.

I don't know where I'm going with this other than to say that the Trump voters are justifiably angry at the WHOLE DAMN SYSTEM and suggesting the entire rust belt become house cleaners or personal aides is silly.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:53PM (#13411608)
We wouldn't be hiring immigrants to do these jobs if the jobs were automated away. That's the point.

I understand that you feel an African woman should be prevented from economically competing with white men, but I don't really agree with that. I'm sure it feels very bad when people lose status relative to out-group members, but I don't consider the anger that result from this to be "justifiable".

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by benjohnson on Monday January 16, 2017 @02:36PM (#13412323)
>>I understand that you feel an African woman should be prevented from economically competing with white men

In my opinion, you're intentionally misconstruing the previous poster in an attempt to discount their concerns as racist or sexist.

The issue wasn't the race of the individuals, but the fact that a American was being displaced by someone who came outside of America.

In my opinion, we can debate about levels of immigration with understanding.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by areyousure on Monday January 16, 2017 @05:01PM (#13413412)
One of yummyfajitas's shticks is arguing that nationalism is essentially the same thing as racism.

Many people don't respond favorably to this argument because (if correct,) it defeats the "I'm not racist, I'm just nationalist" retort.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:03PM (#13414406)
Why is "born to American parents" a more meaningful moral category than "born to white parents"?

I don't think the poster is racist. I think he holds a moral position which is equally indefensible.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by flukus on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:57PM (#13414603)
Because Americans want to maintain their standard of living and can't do that if they are competing with a billion Africans who would be happy with half that standard.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:53PM (#13415284)
White Americans wanted to maintain their status/standard of living too, and economic competition with negros made that difficult.

Can you make any moral arguments for nationalism that don't support racism equally well?

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by flukus on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:56PM (#13415296)
Why do there have to be moral arguments? We want a particular outcome and can make it happen. If people in other countries want the same outcome then they can make it happen there.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @12:38AM (#13415440)
I agree with you in that sense - we have the strength to segregate, to impose nationalism or to pillage the world. Does this mean we should?
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:09PM (#13411241)
If you want people to join your "pink collar economy", you're going to have to pay them an adequate wage and provide decent working conditions. The days when people would work as personal servants in exchange for a crust of bread and a pile of straw to sleep on aren't coming back, nor should they, even for "Trump voting factory workers" (like Peter Thiel, you mean?).

By the way, nursing is a skilled profession. Most nurses today have degrees in the subject and a significant number have advanced degrees. The ones who don't have degrees are almost all older women who went through a multi-year hospital training program (these used to be common, but are pretty rare today). Nursing isn't something that you can just walk into the day after you stop tightening bolts at the Ford plant.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:14PM (#13411278)
If you want people to join your "pink collar economy", you're going to have to pay them an adequate wage and provide decent working conditions.

Alternately, we could just stop paying people to sit around being lazy. Here in India people fill these jobs and earn far less than what most western activists consider a "living wage".

Why do you believe that the non-working Trump voters should be able to mooch off of the rest of society? Why do you believe social obligations go only one way?

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by LyndsySimon on Monday January 16, 2017 @01:50PM (#13411956)
> Alternately, we could just stop paying people to sit around being lazy. Here in India people fill these jobs and earn far less than what most western activists consider a "living wage".

I've honestly never understood why government believes they should make it illegal to pay someone a mutually-agreed-upon wage, or why anything thinks doing so is a good thing.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by mcphage on Monday January 16, 2017 @02:22PM (#13412235)
If it costs $X/year to live, and you can find people in a bad situation willing to work for you for $Y/year (where Y < X), where do you think the remaining $X-Y comes from? From government subsidies, of course. So why should the government have to pay that money? If you have a business plan, but to make it work you need to have your workforce on government subsidies, you have a bad business plan and should be allowed to fail.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:07PM (#13414423)
If someone has no job the government pays the full $x. So the employer is only helping the government. I agree with you that we should cut these government subsidies.

However, the subsidies are to the worker, not the company. To see this, imagine a hypothetical world without the subsidies, and try to figure out if the employer would be richer or poorer. (Hint: richer, since they don't need to compete with the "stay home and watch TV while collecting welfare" option.)

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by mcphage on Monday January 16, 2017 @08:49PM (#13414560)
> If someone has no job the government pays the full $x. So the employer is only helping the government.

Better to let the government pay the full $X, rather than keeping companies around that only succeed because they depend on the government to keep their employees alive. And think of a company like WalMart—by paying its employees very little, and depending on the government to take over things it doesn't want to pay for (like security, leaving it to the police instead, at enormous cost to them, but no cost to WalMart), they can undercut other companies that cost the government far less, leaving the whole economy less healthy.

> However, the subsidies are to the worker, not the company

The subsidies are to the worker, yes. GP was asking why the government has any say in a business relationship between a worker and a company, and the answer is: because they're involved as well, through the need to subsidize whatever the company doesn't pay. They're automatically part of the equation, and thus have a say in what the worker & company can settle for.

> To see this, imagine a hypothetical world without the subsidies, and try to figure out if the employer would be richer or poorer. (Hint: richer, since they don't need to compete with the "stay home and watch TV while collecting welfare" option.)

You mean, if companies were unable to pay less than a living wage? They would have to pay the worker more money, so they would be poorer. However, since all companies were paying more, everyone would probably do better in the end.

Or do you mean, if they could pay people as little as they wanted? They'd be richer, but less and less money would end up moving around in the economy, and everything would slowly grind to a halt. And lots of people would starve.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @01:13AM (#13415552)
Better to let the government pay the full $X, rather than keeping companies around that only succeed because they depend on the government...

How is wasting more money and having less productive output better?

Or do you mean, if they could pay people as little as they wanted?

Of course. In this world, companies don't need to compete with the "stay home and watch TV and get free money" option, so they can pay less. Your "subsidy" is actually directly harmful to the people you claim it benefits.

...keep their employees alive....They'd be richer, but less and less money would end up mving around in the economy, and everything would slowly grind to a halt. And lots of people would starve.

Yet somehow I'm surrounded by about 1 billion living people with a GDP growth rate double that of the United States. Your theory doesn't fit any of the facts.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by mcphage on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:36AM (#13417349)
> Of course. In this world, companies don't need to compete with the "stay home and watch TV and get free money" option, so they can pay less. Your "subsidy" is actually directly harmful to the people you claim it benefits.

So if companies can pay people less, that will then lead them to... pay people more?

> Yet somehow I'm surrounded by about 1 billion living people with a GDP growth rate double that of the United States.

When your per capita GDP catches up to the US's, tell me again about your growth rate.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:21PM (#13411325)
Here in India people fill these jobs and earn far less than what most western activists consider a "living wage"

That's nice. I prefer living in a first world country with a first world economy, myself.

"Why do you believe that the non-working Trump voters should be able to mooch off of the rest of society?"

Do you have any evidence that "Trump voters" are more likely to be on welfare than non-Trump voters? I will be quite surprised if you do (in fact, I'll be shocked).

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:31PM (#13411403)
http://wallstreetpit.com/89671-are-welfare-recipients-mostly...

80% of those in public housing are Democrats. 74% of those receiving Medicaid are Democrats. 67% of those receiving food stamps are Democrats.

"Trump voters"? Really?

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by hamax on Monday January 16, 2017 @01:31PM (#13411859)
Statistics in this article are so misleading it's hard to see it as anything other then deliberate.

From the raw data, 4.95% of democrats are on welfare compared to 3.48% of republicans (Total number of people on welfare in the poll is 54, so the margin of error is large).

You get the 65% number only if you don't account for the fact that there are more democrats in the poll (almost twice as many). The same goes for the 22% republican number in appendix.

This is propaganda.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by TheCowboy on Monday January 16, 2017 @01:23PM (#13411813)
Public housing, medicaid, food stamps aren't the only form of government assistance. It's better to not make comments that tell your story that depend on partial statistics. It's easy to respond that states voting for Trump on a whole receive more federal aid than ones that didn't. The situation is likely more complex than what you've described.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by SamReidHughes on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:36PM (#13411455)
You'll note those numbers are not 100%.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:48PM (#13411568)
Of course it isn't 100%. That's why I said "most".

I think skewing 80% Democrat is more than enough to show that the OP's characterization of welfare recipients as "Trump voters" is ridiculous.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:43PM (#13411527)
That's nice. I prefer living in a first world country with a first world economy, myself.

Why do you think caring for the elderly, providing child care to working women and making Ubers more available would make the economy third world?

Do you believe India would suddenly become more prosperous if people refused to work? Will people sitting at home watching TV somehow build toilets for everyone?

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @01:02PM (#13411670)
"Why do you think caring for the elderly, providing child care to working women and making Ubers more available would make the economy third world?"

I don't. I think expecting people to do those things in exchange for a crust of bread and pile of straw to sleep on makes an economy third world.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by synicalx on Monday January 16, 2017 @06:20PM (#13413933)
Yeah right because there's a lot of skills from assembling engines that can easily be transferred over to wiping geriatric bums.

Go and spend a few months doing all those jobs, then come back and re-read your post.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by eximius on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:52AM (#13411094)
They won't make the transition anyway. They'd rather claim unemplpoyment.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by wrsh07 on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:52AM (#13411088)
At some point there won't be jobs to transition to, though. How do humans survive when they simply aren't needed?

(And how do we make them feel valued by society?)

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:05PM (#13411204)
If that day ever comes then perhaps a BI might be helpful. It'll certainly be cheap. Right now the problem we have is too little labor, not too much.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:16PM (#13411301)
Evidence? 95 million adult Americans are currently out of work. That doesn't sound like "too little" to me.

What you really mean is "too few willing to do scut work for a pittance". That's an entirely different thing.

https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS15000000

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by yummyfajitas on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:20PM (#13411320)
You realize that your number includes children, the disabled and retirees, right?

It's not an entirely different thing that people are refusing work because they prefer the laziness that government programs enable. That's the whole point. BI only makes this problem worse.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by Turing_Machine on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:29PM (#13411391)
The only "children" on that chart are those 16 and up (i.e., old enough to quit school and go to work). While there have been increases in retirees in recent years, that's not nearly enough to account for the spike on that chart.
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by tarr11 on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:57AM (#13411137)
How do you know that there won't be enough jobs?
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by olegkikin on Monday January 16, 2017 @02:23PM (#13412237)
> elder care, house cleaning, nursing

All of these will be automated as well. House cleaning first. It already started with Roomba and its clones.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by holydude on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:59PM (#13411647)
People forget that IT is not the final product. Facebook is not big because they solve technical challenges (related to code and infrastructure). They are big because they are solving a specific problem people had. They are not a special snowflake. If FB would disappear the world would not loose anything. We would just move to something else and which basically happened in China due to chinese gov's protectionism.

We do not need that many programmers,sysadmins,engineers. We do not need zillions of compilers,programming languages, frameworks or crud apps.

If we want to be effective at using and consuming resources we need to be effective at redistributing the wealth. I am a capitalist by heart but in a dystopian world of mega corps we just do not need billionaires. We do not need brilliant businessmen the same way we do not need that many workers. In such a world we do not need capitalism. We do not need companies competing with each other (well at least not on planet earth). We can move on and reward the 1% of scientists and provide them with much more money and resources.

If we want to keep people in line we can make them study more and provide good standards of living. We are talking more or less socialism / communism here but the reality is that we will not need to compete with each other anymore. Our only problem will be to avoid a war between superpowers and people revolting against governments. The fact is we do not really need improvements that much when compared to the past. We do not need faster iphones and more efficient batteries. It would be nice to have but it's not that important after all. The only purpose of iphone is to be connected and consume. The only purpose of a car be it electric or normal is to transport people or goods from point A to point B.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by atemerev on Monday January 16, 2017 @10:46AM (#13410577)
The answer is that there is no solution. Basic income is economically unsustainable. Social crisis is inevitable (like in previous two installments, agricultural -> industrial and industrial -> knowledge economy), and there is nothing that can be done about it except of surviving through it.

Any possible basic income solutions will only make the problem worse.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by elsurudo on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:19AM (#13410816)
In the current economic ideology, sure. But there is a lot of surplus (profit). What makes you think it's economically unsustainable? People would have to readjust their expectations, for sure. I'm not saying I know that it _is_ economically sustainable, but I haven't done the math. Have you?
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by newyankee on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:32PM (#13411415)
If you think of giving everyone 6000 $ per mth it may be unsustainable , but i think 1500 $ per mth + a reformed healthcare is very much doable, it is less than 1 standard deviation from the mean per capita income
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by gjkood on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:16PM (#13411298)
Would it be possible to make cogent arguments without resorting to stereotypical India bashing?

Would you make the same arguments using Chinese manufacturing and the fact that it leads the world in electronics manufacturing?

India is large.

Population: 1,250,000,000+

Population employed in IT: 10,000,000+ (i.e <1% of population)

In a group of 10,000,000+ people you will find all kinds of competencies, capabilities and behaviors statistically speaking.

I assume you have non-anecdotal data from which you have derived your generalizations.

I don't think any Indian child grows up dreaming that his greatest goal in life is to replace an American IT worker.

If you have been affected by Indian IT workers, blame it on your management. Somebody is definitely benefiting.

Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by cderwin on Monday January 16, 2017 @12:34PM (#13411438)
With all due respect, OP did note this: "And don't get me wrong, India has their share of talented and brilliant guys, but the average case is rather bad".
Re:Basic income is the worst response to automation by ddebernardy on Monday January 16, 2017 @11:55AM (#13411116)
FWIW no need to go as far as India (or China or SE Asia) to find mediocrity. There's also plenty in Europe and North America. The main difference is you're in the same office as the bad developers, so you spot them faster.