Re:Philosophy vs. ethics
by woodruffw on Sunday January 15, 2017 @08:10PM
(#13407578)
In ethical theory/moral philosophy, ethics and morality are the same thing. Both are concerned chiefly with two questions: what we ought to do given what is (unless you're Hume), and whether what has been done is good (or just, or right).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Philosophy vs. ethics
by bleachedsleet on Sunday January 15, 2017 @08:48PM
(#13407753)
I'd be honestly interested to know why you believe they are considered the same in the field of ethical philosophy. Throughout my education toward a degree in philosophy I was consistently taught they were very different. One cannot confuse the terms in the study therein because of cause and effect: ethics is the cause that leads to morals.
That's funny. I'm currently pursuing a degree in philosophy, and I was consistently taught that they were the same. Most of my professors used them interchangeably, with a slight preference for "ethics" when discussing theory.
I realize that my previous comment made it sound like I'm an authority on the subject (I'm most definitely not), so please forgive me for being so brusque in dismissing an alternative definition.
Re:Philosophy vs. ethics
by woodandsteel on Monday January 16, 2017 @06:21PM
(#13413940)
My impression is the two terms are not exactly the same, with some vague differences in connotations, but a great deal of overlap, and often used interchangeably.
By the way, this is general problem in philosophy, as compared with other fields. Many standard terms are inexact in their meanings, and used differently by different philosophers. So for instance, some philosophers use the term ontology to mean the same thing as metaphysics, and others make a strong distinction between the two. Heidegger even switched his meanings between his early and later career.
Indeed, there isn't even a standard definition for the term philosophy itself.