John Bogle, founder of Vanguard and renowned investor, seems to disagree with you: "The stock market has nothing—n-o-t-h-i-n-g—to do with the allocation of capital. All it means is that if you’re buying General Motors stock, say, someone else is selling it to you. Capital isn’t allocated—the ownership just changes. I may be an investor, you may be a speculator. But no capital goes anywhere. This is basically a closed system. You have new IPOs and whatnot, but they’re very small compared to this vast thing we call a market, which is now around $24 trillion. The allocation of capital? That’s just nonsense."
I think you are mixing up the concept of a market economy with a specific kind of market, the "stock" market.
Why would people sell equity in their company except for cash, and why would you pay cash for ownership in a company except for the stream of income it represents and the secondary market for that ownership?
How come people decided it is illegal to trade ivory from an elephant killed a couple hundred years ago? Was it made illegal to possess child pornography that was already created only because it is morally toxic, or does said consumption also induce demand for additional victims?
Even though debt markets have a lot more to do with day to day financing of corporations, equity markets have a great influence on terms. Furthermore, the unavoidable importance of secondary markets for debt and their derivatives can be understood by considering the importance of secondary markets with respect to prices of homes, automobiles, or any other large consumer purchases.
My main point really was that the examples parent gave seemed much closer to examples of market economics in general and would hold true, with or without stock markets.
Is it? I thought the idea behind HFT was to make a shedload of money for the firms with the most effective algorithms. To be clear, I have no problem with that, and I'm not close to the industry. But it would surprise me to hear that those in it conceive of themselves as optimizing social resource allocation, rather than, say, setting themselves up to retire at thirty with all the money they'll ever need.
The algorithms talked about here are not HFT algorithms, but investment algorithms. Things like "if it's down for 3 days in a row, allocate 5% in the stock" type programs, written using machine learning. They generally will not change orders rapidly. They are about more efficient/effective investment, and the argument I gave is more focused on what the function of a stock market and investing is.
Because these algorithms are much more like traditional investors than HFT.
GM's stock price has very much to do with GM's actions. GM can do countless things which will impact its equity value.
Also, changing the effective|marginal tax rate by 50% has material implications on your business model and capital structure, e.g. debt (and tax shields).
10% to 20% is a 100% increase not a 50% increase. Now sure, paperwork changes, but the price of your widget or the layout of the factory etc don't really care about the taxes outside of extreme cases.
Anyway, profitable companies like GM can issue stock to raise capital or buy back stock. Buybacks don't really depend on the stock price as it's not an investment it's another form of dividend. Issuing stock is an inefficient way to raise capital better to issue bonds or not issue dividends.
Now sure, there are second order effects of stock price such as stock options. But again +/- 10% to stock price on a given day does not do much.
PS: Consider Microsoft if the tax rate where to increase to say 40% what would they change?
For your widget company, it does matter! ;-) What widgets you make, your price, your price relative to competition, market share protection, pricing power, where you build your factory, PP&E decisions, and more all depend on your tax rates. I promise, and want to compete against firms that overlook these parameters.
For GM, you're overlooking other (mis)management decisions that will show up in the share price.
Right now, MSFT is facing just such an issue re: re-patriating money from overseas. If there were a one time foreign tax holiday as floated by Obama, MSFT would choose very different decisions than the status quo in terms of buy backs and R&D spend. In terms of operations changing, I guarantee they'd re-think their debt and their product mix within their 3 reporting segments. Some products wouldn't be profitable enough to sell if the profit margin shifted 2-3%.
I have had several successful CEO's all tell me to ignore taxes. That does not mean you install or don't install solar panels based on tax breaks. It can be very important, but it's generally premature optimization. Further, it's not the top tax rate that is important it's differential tax rates aka A @X or B @ less than X.
MSFT's re-patriating money is a good problem to have. They may see a tax holiday in the next administration or they may not. But again, it's getting to that point is the issue.
The idea is that letting algorithms decide will result in better/more productive allocation of resources, which will result in more and better everything.
Of course, is that reality ? I would point out, however, that stock markets resource allocations are far better than royalty/governments allocating resources.