News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by elidourado on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @05:41PM (#1339297)
My view is that people should be allowed to opt out of FDA regulation if they wish to do so. It's my body; I should be allowed to put anything I want into it.

It took 10 years for the first beta blockers to be approved in the US after they were in use in Europe. In that amount of time, thousands of Americans died for lack of the drugs. It's hard to distinguish this from mass murder, or at least mass manslaughter.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by proee on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:07PM (#1339384)
It's not that simple. If they allow the sale of non regulated drugs then you'll have a 10x increase in commercials on TV trying to sell you an untested and unregulated "purple pill".

The fine print will say "this drug has not been tested and is not approved by the FDA. It may cause death or create an uncontrolled viral outbreak..."

The drug will sell like hotcakes though because the commercials will have lots of happy-smiley people and the distributor will get a healthy 80% profit margin on the sales.

There's some comfort in knowing that a non-profit agency is looking into the safety of a drug before it goes out to the public for consumption.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by barry-cotter on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:01PM (#1339528)
There's some comfort in knowing that a non-profit agency is looking into the safety of a drug before it goes out to the public for consumption.

What's so awesome about non-profits? They have their very own perverse incentive structures. Proposed replacement or supplement: Any company wishing to sell Drug X to the public must be insured against patient lawsuits. Insurance companies are quite capable of hiring people to assess risk and wouldn't have the same biased weighting of risk and benefit.

Why not make getting these non-approved drugs conditional on getting X% of the questions on a MCT correct, where said test is a quiz on the effects, side-effects, toxicity etc. of the desired drug? If I was implementing this I'd mandate that the source material for said test be publicly available at a centralised registry, that you need to get 100% of the answers right that the questions be randomly drawn from a test bank and that the test cost say half a day's median wage. Have authorisation lapse after three months so you need to take the test again.

Informed consent has just been assured, and people can now make their own decisions but they need to really want the drug.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by Groxx on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @10:20PM (#1339941)
What's so awesome about non-profits? They have their very own perverse incentive structures.

I wonder the same thing. And it's not like the people in the non-profit agencies aren't paid, and can't accept bribes.

Not that anyone bribes the FDA, of course. They're non-profit, what possible gain could there be?

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by yardie on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @02:28AM (#1340328)
FDA is a federal agency, paid for by the government. It is not a nonprofit because it doesn't have to seek funding whatever the govt't gives it is what it works with.

BTW, bribing a government official will usually result in one or both of you doing time in a federal (not a country club) prison.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by lionhearted on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @02:55AM (#1340378)
> BTW, bribing a government official will usually result in one or both of you doing time in a federal (not a country club) prison.

If bribed with cash, maybe, unless it can fall under "campaign finance". Sports tickets, dinners, and gifts are generally accepted though.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by barry-cotter on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @03:24AM (#1340407)
Calling an elected politician a government official does not fall within the common use of the term.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by lionhearted on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @04:33AM (#1340504)
Ah, good point, my mistake. So if I've got it right, the common usage would be "government official" for administrative positions, and "politician" for elected?

Cheers for pointing that out.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by barry-cotter on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @08:57PM (#1342846)
That's welll over 97% of the meaning[0] but for some reason I must say more. I'd be very surprised if anyone described am elected judge in America as a politician, even though they're elected.

[0]Ain't spurious exactitude great?

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by xiaoma on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:22PM (#1339432)
The US already has that situation in the supplements industry and while heavily-advertised weight-loss/muscle/hair supplements are annoying, it's not that bad. The cost of not getting valuable drugs is underestimated since people only hear about it in rare cases such as this one, whereas dangerous treatments generate a lot of media coverage.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by carbocation on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @02:48AM (#1340363)
Right, weight loss supplements are OK because hypertension and cardiomyopathy (along with the occasional sudden death) are no problem? At the end of the day, the FDA needs to carefully regulate the market not because dumb people need them to, but because smart people such as most HNers do.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by matwood on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @08:08PM (#1339697)
"There's some comfort in knowing that a non-profit agency is looking into the safety of a drug before it goes out to the public for consumption."

You're kidding right? At least with a for profit corporation I know their motives. With a government agency I have no idea if they are returning a favor, taking money, or simply like the person. With that said, the FDA still requires a large profit motive since no one would spend the millions required to get approved unless they expected some return.

I wonder how many possible working drugs for esoteric diseases are floating around that will never be released because of the expense of getting through the FDA.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by tome on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @05:18AM (#1340550)
Could you please clarify what it is about for-profits that makes you think they would never accept bribes?
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by matwood on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @09:30AM (#1340852)
That's the thing, I fully expect for-profits to accept bribes and would act accordingly. Assuming that the FDA is some high and mighty agency that only approves safe drugs is the problem.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by infinite8s on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:42AM (#1341222)
What do you mean you would act accordingly? You would ignore any recommendations they make? So then you are left trusting the original drug developer to have properly done and analyzed the safety trials?
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by tlrobinson on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:34PM (#1339469)
Why not simply prohibit advertising of non-FDA approved drugs?
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by staunch on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:14PM (#1339558)
And require a signed waiver and prescription from a doctor? Presumably (most) doctors are smart enough not to prescribe cyanide as a cure for insomnia.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by megablast on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @08:26PM (#1339729)
OK, so now the doctor has to come up with the millions of non-FDA approved drugs that are about to come onto the market, because there will be lots of these drugs.

Personally, if you are stupid enough to go for the non-FDA approved drugs, you are too stupid to help anyway. Unless you are going by some other approval system, for example whatever they use in Canada, UK or Australia. But if you are just going by what you read on the website, you are a fool.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by psadauskas on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:14PM (#1339560)
If I write a blog post saying I like X non-approved drug, do I get arrested? What if I was paid to do it?

Prohibiting advertising strays dangerously close to the 1st Amendment.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by staunch on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:18PM (#1339574)
Drugs companies were prohibited from advertising on television until not so long ago. There's even a special law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prescription_Drug_Marketing_Act...
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by roboneal on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @10:14PM (#1339931)
Arguably, that is the crux of the 1st Amendment issue -- government regulation of speech - including that of "evil" or "unpopular" drug companies -- is a slippery slope.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by nitrogen on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @01:45AM (#1340271)
The past few years seem to indicate that we're slipping up the slope, then, as what was once prohibited is now allowed, both in the case of prescription drug advertisements and corporate political speech.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pmccool on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @01:41AM (#1340264)
Compare with the following phrases: Prohibiting forgery strays dangerously close... Prohibiting defamation strays dangerously close... Prohibiting Ponzi schemes strays dangerously close...

I can accept that regulation of speech is inherently suspect, but not that it's inherently bad. The reasons for regulating this kind of advertising are pretty clear to me.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jrockway on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @04:54AM (#1340528)
Prohibiting slander, libel, and inciting imminent lawless action are also technical violations of the first amendment. Society tolerates these rules because they provide even greater value than the freedom of speech alone.

In this case, I agree that prohibiting advertising is a first amendment violation. Instead, we should simply disallow all outdoor advertising and advertising that is broadcast on the publicly-owned radio spectrum.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by talklittle on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:17PM (#1339569)
Even so, the advertising aspect seems relatively minor to the whole picture. Hospitals are the ones who need to worry most about FDA and non-FDA. Would a hospital be able to acquire the funding it needs if it ever allowed the prescription of any non-FDA approved drugs? What would insurance companies think? It opens up too many liabilities to try any experimental drugs--that is, drugs not approved by a mandating organization--for any large organizations to consider doing it. Then we're back where we started--we need something like the FDA, though definitely in a more efficient form.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by Groxx on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @10:14PM (#1339927)
And when people finally quit looking at medication as a cure-all, because we've had the FDA around to "prove" things are safe?

Of course, they've never made mistakes, oh no, not them. Approved medications aren't dangerous in the least degree. And no "medications" are sold which aren't FDA approved. Not supplements, not energy drinks, nothing. McD's approves their fries, so does your corner diner.

I think the solution may be to have multiple standards bodies, the FDA being one of them. If bodies A, B, and Q approve a drug, and they have a good track record, people can choose. If a drug is experimental, bodies X and Y agree with research Z and not Q because someone ate a peanut, so take your pick based on your circumstances. At least then there would be other options.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by artsrc on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @12:30AM (#1340179)
There is a non-profit agency that looked into the safety of the drug in Mexico.

The FDA should have a rule that any drug approved by any of the following agencies is automatically approved for use in the USA.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pwim on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @08:51PM (#1339777)
Allowing advertising for drugs is a problem in and of itself. I think the United States is pretty unique in allowing direct to consumer drug advertisement.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by s3graham on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @03:53AM (#1340452)
I always find watching US tv bizarre because of that. You have all the usual crap car/cellphone/food ads and then all of a sudden they're diving into surreal craziness about cholesterol levels and brain chemistry that I suspect 99%+ of viewers can't possibly critically evaluate.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by elidourado on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:17PM (#1339416)
If that's really your concern, then why not at least let college graduates opt out? Or people holding PhDs? My suspicion is that many people would oppose this because it disadvantages the uneducated, but of course you can't have it both ways. Either regulation is good for the uneducated or it is not.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by eru on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:45PM (#1339489)
> Or people holding PhDs?

In which fields? You are entering a mine field.

> Either regulation is good for the uneducated or it is not.

There could be different kinds of regulation.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @08:08PM (#1339696)
>It took 10 years for the first beta blockers to be approved in the US after they were in use in Europe.

Yet Europe has drug regulation. Maybe the problem isn't regulation as such, but the way regulation works in the US.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by nooneelse on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @11:33PM (#1340078)
"It's my body; I should be allowed to put anything I want into it."

It is my understanding that many drugs are not entirely metabolized/naturalized by the first person they enter. So the presupposition you are working with isn't entirely true.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by varjag on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @06:31AM (#1340622)
OK, who will give you prescriptions for non-FDA drugs then? Your physician, only to be sued into oblivion when you die?

Or would you rather prescribe them yourself too?

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by earl on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @05:45PM (#1339318)
And Thalidomide wasn't approved in the US whereas it was approved in Europe and Canada. So... your point is stupid.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jerf on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:05PM (#1339376)
When you measure only the costs of one side and only the benefits of the other, the conclusion is predetermined, and of no value.

How about you engage the question of whether the costs and benefits of our current policy outweigh the costs and benefits of a looser policy directly, instead of just tossing a rhetorical hand grenade into the debate ("look! mangled babies!") and running away? It would look something like this:

"The number of thalidomide birth defects estimates range from 10,000 to 20,000 according to Wikipedia. Given the rate of cancer death in this country, a net one year delay applied across all effective therapies compounded across many years almost certainly outweighs your one example. Excessively liberal medicine policy may kill and maim, but so does excessively conservative policy; it's not a pure win by any means. Are you so sure that our policy is really the best policy?"

This isn't a question you can actually determine the best answer to with a series of anecdotes. You have to actually do a statistical analysis. I have not done this statistical analysis, so all I can say is something like "I'd bet money we're being too conservative", or "My libertarian leanings lead me to say we should have a more liberal acceptance policy on the grounds of personal freedom", but just screaming about deformed babies with no other analysis like this is an emotional tactic that should be replaced with something better. Too many people's lives are on the line for this debate to be shut down with "won't someone please think of the babies?"

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pyre on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:10PM (#1339394)
It's also effectively a non-issue. Why not slap a big "THIS IS NOT TESTED TO BE SAFE FOR PREGNANT WOMEN" label on the thing? I mean doctors don't recommend ibuprofen for pregnant women, but mostly because there are no studies on the effects of ibuprofen on unborn babies. We don't out-right ban ibuprofen just because we don't know how it will effect women/babies during pregnancy.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by infinite8s on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @11:47AM (#1341240)
If there was no FDA, you'd basically need to slap a label on that said - "This is not tested to be safe for anything", since it's the FDA that mandates all the safety testing.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by Retric on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:49PM (#1339499)
You also can't assume a single bad drug was the only downside until the end of time.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jsn on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @05:58PM (#1339350)
No, it's not, but your point definitely is irrelevant. You see, it's my body, so I can put whatever I want in it, be it aspirin, heroin, thalidomide or cyanide. And yeah, I may wish to make an educated choice about that, but then again, I don't have to.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pyre on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:12PM (#1339400)
True, but when you're talking medicines, you may not have a choice in the matter. e.g. You come into the emergency room unconscious, what medicines should the doctors be allowed to use?
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jsn on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:18PM (#1339423)
Basically, if someone is going to make a decision affecting my body while I'm unconscious, I'd rather have someone I picked for that job to do it (like, I don't know, my doctor or my wife or my dad or my friend or even my insurance company) than some bureaucrat in FDA.

But that's not quite the issue in question, eh? My understanding is, you can't get the unapproved anti-venom even if you are conscious and you are about to die without it anyway, by doctors opinion.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pyre on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:12PM (#1339553)
I realize that you still can't get it when you are conscious. I'm just saying that 'personal choice' isn't the only weighing factor here. If you come into the emergency room and you are unconscious, who says that you are with someone (wife,friend,etc) or that there is enough time to try and get in touch with your doctor?

I personally think that the FDA approval process is bogus too. I'm just trying to expand the discussion a bit.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jsn on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @05:21AM (#1340556)
I was just trying not to drift too much into complicated parts of the problem, since the society is obviously unable to fix even the most obvious and simple parts of it.

Yeah, maybe there should be some rules about corner cases like that (what to do with you if you are unconscious and there is nobody to ask about what you'd want to be done to you). And maybe one way to get those rules written and enforced is to have people on government payroll for that. Or maybe we should just leave it to the ER folks. But, frankly, I think it would be nice to fix the obvious big wrongs first, and worry about all this stuff later.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by nitrogen on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @01:49AM (#1340280)
Since you include heroin and cyanide, would you have some kind of provision that prohibits people from taking certain substances if they've demonstrated by their behavior that those substances would cause them to harm other members of society? In other words, should we allow susceptible people to become junkies if they end up doing something really really bad while they're under the influence?
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by jsn on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @05:01AM (#1340537)
I'm not sure there is a one-size-fits-all solution to that. But, in general, I think that what matters is the real damage done. I mean, if you do harm others, you should be punished/restricted, and if you do harm others repeatedly under the influence of some substance (be it snorted cocaine or internally produced adrenaline), you should perhaps be punished/restricted more. But the punishment/restriction should always be a response to the harm done to others, not to whatever the person does to her own body.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by Alex3917 on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:01PM (#1339367)
Millions of people have died because the government has banned certain drugs. Whereas the number of people who have died because of a drug not being banned is zero. It seems like a clear tradeoff to me.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by pyre on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:13PM (#1339403)
> Whereas the number of people who have died because of a drug not being banned is zero.

I'm sure this is a debatable 'fact'/statistic.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by prodigal_erik on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:23PM (#1339435)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fen-phen had a body count before it was banned. Such cases are rare, but that means the system is doing at least part of its job.
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by Alex3917 on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @07:00PM (#1339525)
People died because they took a dangerous drug. They didn't die because the drug wasn't illegal.

If you want to cut down the number of people taking dangerous drugs, ban doctors from prescribing non FDA-approved drugs and ban companies from marketing them. However, I have only contempt for people who want to put their fellow citizens in jail for making their own medical decisions.

Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by devinj on Wednesday May 12, 2010 @12:58AM (#1340226)
"guns don't kill people, the pauli exclusion principle kills people"
Re:Why Snakebites Are About to Get a Lot More Deadly by alaithea on Tuesday May 11, 2010 @06:23PM (#1339436)