What's so awesome about non-profits? They have their very own perverse incentive structures. Proposed replacement or supplement: Any company wishing to sell Drug X to the public must be insured against patient lawsuits. Insurance companies are quite capable of hiring people to assess risk and wouldn't have the same biased weighting of risk and benefit.
Why not make getting these non-approved drugs conditional on getting X% of the questions on a MCT correct, where said test is a quiz on the effects, side-effects, toxicity etc. of the desired drug? If I was implementing this I'd mandate that the source material for said test be publicly available at a centralised registry, that you need to get 100% of the answers right that the questions be randomly drawn from a test bank and that the test cost say half a day's median wage. Have authorisation lapse after three months so you need to take the test again.
Informed consent has just been assured, and people can now make their own decisions but they need to really want the drug.
I wonder the same thing. And it's not like the people in the non-profit agencies aren't paid, and can't accept bribes.
Not that anyone bribes the FDA, of course. They're non-profit, what possible gain could there be?
BTW, bribing a government official will usually result in one or both of you doing time in a federal (not a country club) prison.
If bribed with cash, maybe, unless it can fall under "campaign finance". Sports tickets, dinners, and gifts are generally accepted though.
Cheers for pointing that out.
[0]Ain't spurious exactitude great?
You're kidding right? At least with a for profit corporation I know their motives. With a government agency I have no idea if they are returning a favor, taking money, or simply like the person. With that said, the FDA still requires a large profit motive since no one would spend the millions required to get approved unless they expected some return.
I wonder how many possible working drugs for esoteric diseases are floating around that will never be released because of the expense of getting through the FDA.
Personally, if you are stupid enough to go for the non-FDA approved drugs, you are too stupid to help anyway. Unless you are going by some other approval system, for example whatever they use in Canada, UK or Australia. But if you are just going by what you read on the website, you are a fool.
Prohibiting advertising strays dangerously close to the 1st Amendment.
I can accept that regulation of speech is inherently suspect, but not that it's inherently bad. The reasons for regulating this kind of advertising are pretty clear to me.
In this case, I agree that prohibiting advertising is a first amendment violation. Instead, we should simply disallow all outdoor advertising and advertising that is broadcast on the publicly-owned radio spectrum.
Of course, they've never made mistakes, oh no, not them. Approved medications aren't dangerous in the least degree. And no "medications" are sold which aren't FDA approved. Not supplements, not energy drinks, nothing. McD's approves their fries, so does your corner diner.
I think the solution may be to have multiple standards bodies, the FDA being one of them. If bodies A, B, and Q approve a drug, and they have a good track record, people can choose. If a drug is experimental, bodies X and Y agree with research Z and not Q because someone ate a peanut, so take your pick based on your circumstances. At least then there would be other options.
The FDA should have a rule that any drug approved by any of the following agencies is automatically approved for use in the USA.
The fine print will say "this drug has not been tested and is not approved by the FDA. It may cause death or create an uncontrolled viral outbreak..."
The drug will sell like hotcakes though because the commercials will have lots of happy-smiley people and the distributor will get a healthy 80% profit margin on the sales.
There's some comfort in knowing that a non-profit agency is looking into the safety of a drug before it goes out to the public for consumption.