A hospital cannot "publish prices" because prices vary wildly based on many factors. Even if they did, how am I supposed to know what I need for my healthcare? If I go to the doctor and they say "you need a surgery and it will cost 10,000" the posted prices do not tell me if I need that surgery at all, just what they cost. And, of course, the most expensive medical care is emergency, a time when price shopping is not possible.
> Remove the boundries of the state borders. This is regulation. Not allowing companies to work and provide across state lines is ridiculous and again government overreach that could quickly drive down costs.
I'm not opposed to this, but it does remove state control over insurance regulation, which is an anathama to Republicans. I also have no idea how it will drive down costs? Are some states that much healthier than others?
> Birth Control, yes and no. We should be able to opt out paying for it, especially if it goes against my religion and frankly it does, but I won't stop others from opting in and paying for it.
I don't even know where to start. If I can opt out of paying for some medically approved procedures, where does it end? Can I say that I want to opt out of ob/gyn care for unmarried women?
Here's a question: Dentists routinely publish prices. If you ask them how much some procedure will cost, they will tell you. If there is uncertainty, they will give you a range (e.g. to account for the possibility that complications will arise during an oral surgery). What is different in the hospital situation, apart from some rather extreme measures taken to obfuscate pricing?
> And, of course, the most expensive medical care is emergency
Is it? Or is it end-of-life? Genuinely curious to see numbers here!
> I also have no idea how it will drive down costs
Prices, not costs. The current situation is that in a lot of states there are somewhere on the order of 1-3 companies offering insurance of certain types at all. For example, for Maryland, I believe there is only one company offering an ACA-compatible PPO (everyone else has HMOs or even EPOs). See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13393287 for where I got that data.
Of course in a monopoly situation there is absolutely no incentive for a monopolist to cut prices. Why would they? So to the extent that prices represent excessive profits (as opposed to the actual costs of health care), allowing cross-state insurance sales should drive them down. People who believe insurance companies are price-gouging should be _very_ in favor of removing restrictions on such sales.
Similarly, when your diagnosis comes in and surgery is required, you can take time off from your three jobs to carefully research the pros and cons of various procedures to determine which is most financially appropriate for you. I mean, it's not exactly heart surgery we're talking about here. Well, technically and literally it is, but it shouldn't be too hard for anyone to understand the pros and cons of different surgical equipment and procedures to evaluate the risks and cross-compare with the clear apples-to-apples data sets to arrive at a medically and economically responsible decision while blood is pouring out of your extremities and your body feels like it's on fire. Take the time and shop carefully. You are a model fiscal actor and will make the right call.
Free market forces will make this system work and work well. The invisible hand has been after all such a huge success in setting health care prices and has proven to be the model every modern industrial country has taken because it's so intuitive and has great proven results.
A lot of hospital care is non-emergency, but they don't explain pricing schedules for _that_ either, now do they? I think everyone understands the impossibility of comparison-shopping on emergency care.
> I mean, it's not exactly heart surgery we're talking about here
No, it's hip replacement surgery. And people _already_ do comparison shopping on things like that as much as they can, including comparing to and shopping in other countries. See medical tourism.
More to the point, people do comparison shop just like that for oral surgery. Yes, they may not have all the data they might like. Yes, they don't always make the right decisions. But by and large, dentistry works OK.
Again, the "stuff that must be done RIGHT NOW" thing is a strawman: there's plenty of hospital care that is not that sort.
> The invisible hand has been after all such a huge success in setting health care prices
The invisible hand has absolutely nothing to do with most health care prices today (at least in the US). There are some exceptions: plastic surgery, laser eye surgery, dentistry, some forms of occupational therapy, and maybe family medicine.
> and has proven to be the model every modern industrial country has taken because it's so intuitive
Various industrial countries have price transparency for their medical care. If want to know how much my hip replacement will cost in the UK not via the NHS, I go to http://www.privatehealth.co.uk/conditions-and-treatments/hip... and I get all the data I could want, including prices and the hospitals charging those prices. Importantly, those hospitals publish their prices. If I did go via the NHS, I suspect there is no real difference in the pricing, but would welcome data on how it really works.
Anyway, knowing how much medical procedures will cost you is not an uncommon situation. Except in the US, of course, where hospitals will never tell you ahead of time how much a procedure will cost.
Note that price transparency is necessary, but not sufficient, for some sort of sanity in the discretionary medical care market.
Pharmaceutical and medical equipment companies are raking in double digit profits. And they can sell wherever they want.
And you're right: by no means are insurance companies the only ones in this sector that engage in attempts at regulatory capture and creation of monopoly profits.
Though I should note that pharma companies have a lower return on capital than insurance companies last I checked, because pharma is so capital-intensive in practice. I haven't really looked into medical device manufacturers.
https://www.asrm.org/FACTSHEET_Noncontraceptive_Benefits_of_...
Also consider the case of a woman who does not want to become pregnant due to genetic or physiological issues that would make pregnancy dangerous for her or the baby.
I know this is a common retort, but are pills to give men erections worthy of medical coverage? What about hair loss medications? If your rubric is based on fertility, should we not cover women once they reach menopause?
Finally I have a critique of your rhetorical strategy, "let's face the truth" is lazy and weak. For example, "Let's face the truth, jimlawruk hates women."
Does this exception generalize? From the start, I felt it was immoral to go into Iraq, topple the government, get 4000+ US soldiers killed and cause the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Iraqis. The pennies you pay for birth control a nothing compared to what I as compelled to pay for a war I didn't support from the get go. Can I get my money back for that one? I'm sure my objection to it is/was as sincere and deeply felt as your objection to birth control.
Do you not realize how awful that is? How much of a hypocrite it makes you to hide behind freedom of religion as a means to try to force your religious beliefs on others? Especially via their health care.
How would you feel about tying health in to praying to Mecca multiple times a day?
How about if you work on the sabbath you lose your coverage?
Divorced? No health care for you sinner.
STD coverage should probably be banned. I mean sure, there are other ways to get AIDS but if you were having sex in a nice normal marriage then you probably wouldn't get it.
Oh wait, you mean that someone made a personal choice to use it. A choice that has exactly nothing to do with you, but you see an opportunity to oppress their freedom to choose so you are going to take it.
It's on the fuckin' money!
You want to talk about faith being shoved down people's throats, the Christians are the worst at it.
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."
Also known as the Separation of Church and State.
You are free to exercise your religious beliefs by not using birth control. But you cannot demand that Congress write the laws to fit your belief system.
edit: By the way, I downvoted you not because I disagree with you, but because of your hypocrisy.
As for being a Christian, fine, but my faith defines how I think. It doesn't mean the church controls my way of thinking. Just influences it. That in no way has anything to do with the separation of church and state. ESP for founders that were all very religious.
First, separation of church and state, your faith doesn't get to be part of government decisions.
Second, do Jehovah's Witnesses get to not pay for blood transfusions in other people? And before you cite that blood transfusions are far more necessary, I think you should hold fast to your fiscal conservative tenets and help prevent unwanted burdens on the state from being born.
Of course. What part of
> but damnit kid, get a job. Do something with yourself
did you not understand.
Our economy is switching from full time employment to a gig based(lyft,postmates,uber). How do contract workers get health insurance?
If pre-existing conditions can't be denied, and insurance can't be mandated, how do you prevent people from only picking up insurance when they get sick/hurt?
I graduated just before 25, and my first job didn't have benefits because although I was working 40 hours they called it casual.
> Birth Control, yes and no. We should be able to opt out paying for it, especially if it goes against my religion and frankly it does, but I won't stop others from opting in and paying for it.
No, you shouldn't have the right to decide what your employees get to do with their health care. You don't have the right to decide who they sleep with and how. This is the theocratic, forcing my bullshit voodoo beliefs onto others crap that makes the republican party so repugnant.
Now, I'll ask again. Are you going to place restrictions on what I (the business owner) buy with my money?
Health care benefits are also part of that compensation. Why should you have any say in how your employee uses that compensation.
Your employees use of their health care plan is none of your damn business. Trying to use health care to regulate their behaviour based on your religious views is a particularly nasty form of oppression.
Pot, meet kettle.
1: If people choose not to get health insurance and then have to go to the ER, who pays for that? You and me. In most cases, it is cheaper for people to get preventative care and reduce their chances of a very expensive ER visit.
2: Preexisting conditions. Sure, but without a guaranteed customer base supported by subsidies then those people will be effectively denied insurance by having to pay insane premiums and deductibles. I have seen no evidence thus far that effectively counters this argument.
Lastly, you say you want to live off the land in some small town somewhere and you don't want the government to force you to pay for other people. Splendid! Say hello to Thomas Jefferson for me. But who builds the roads that lead to your house? What about utilities, water, internet? If you slip and fall down the stairs and break your leg who do you call, 911? If so, who pays for the 911 service, let alone the ambulance to take you to the hospital?
Again, I do agree with your premise, but since in my experience most libertarian arguments tend to crack under the pressure of public goods (like national security), where do you draw the line between independence and the needs of the populace as a whole?
2. Then prices will increase within each insurance company and as a user, I will pay for the insurance I want, rather than be forced.
3. Oh Stop. I didn't say I wouldn't pay taxes.
When did Healthcare become a government problem, rather than something that can be done through businesses. Its a business! If you can't afford to pay the bills then work a little harder to do something better with your life.
I think the problem is that healthcare after years of this broken system is now seen as private consumption rather than a public interest (like infrastructure and basic education).
Healthy people already sign up for it. Go look at the math before the aca.
I think this is something that a lot of small-government conservatives don't want--it's moving responsibilities from the state governments to the federal government.
The problem with this POV is that young, healthy people end up having no insurance and thus leave the older, unhealthier population to pay all the bills, whereas a full-insured population would distribute the financial load.
Also, it would lead to young, healthy people foregoing insurance in order to save money, and then when catastrophes happen (you're talking about living on the land, so imagine something as harmless as scratching yourself on rusty farm equipment, being bitten by an animal... both can send you to the hospital for weeks!), these people would face financial ruin.
The purpose of mandatory healthcare thus is to protect elderly or otherwise pre-conditioned people from having to pay devastatingly high premiums, and to protect people literally from their own short-sightedness.
Also, if there's only 50k in the account and the bill is 100k, you're still straight screwed.
2) Sam Altman agrees with you that it's okay to repeal it as long as we maintain the best parts of it.
> "If Congress ends up repealing it, I hope they earnestly try to preserve the best parts, and put in place something better."
We have to start somewhere. The provision about preexisting conditions, and by extension the ACA, is literally life-saving.
The government doesn't require me to get vaccines. Nor does it require me to educate my children.
Now, you can homeschool if you choose, or place your children in a private school. But I'm not sure, legally, that you can leave them completely uneducated.
Private schools can also require vaccines.
These are good things. We want people to be vaccinated and literate.
We want everyone to be able to receive medical care. In the US, that means we want everyone to be insured.
Well, correct as far as healthcare goes, even with the ACA "mandate". You can choose not to get insurance, and you get some extra taxes in return.
Yep, and I hope it's to prevent "lowest common bidder" syndrome on plans. Why does Delaware get all the Corps? Why does a East Texas Court get all the patent cases ?
Frankly, my Texas health care plan sucks. Doesn't cover "anything".
> Lastly, I want hospital prices published. I want to shop around.
Can't shop around in an ambulance.
Well, let's put that to the test. I consider myself pretty liberal. Here's what I think about your bullet list.
* Re: individual mandate
I actually agree with you very strongly on this. When the government wants to force me to pay for something, there's already a long-established way to do that: taxes, with services rendered by the government and thus fully accountable to the people. Forcing us to pay for private services sounds awfully similar to forcing us to pay for British tea, which isn't supposed to be how our country works. If the government wants to force us to pay for health insurance, they should tax us and provide universal coverage.
* Preexisting conditions cannot be denied and should be slightly elevated costs compared to the average user.
Agreed on preexisting conditions, disagreed on higher costs for the affected. "Slightly" quickly becomes a loophole that enables "outrageous". And anyone who lives long enough will eventually acquire a condition anyway. Seems kinda redundant to optimize for that. Just distribute the cost evenly with the understanding that everyone will eventually receive the benefit.
* Age 26 under the parents health care plan, fine, but damnit kid, get a job. Do something with yourself.
That's what the original post is about. When kids have health care, it's easier for them to make their own jobs instead of going out and begging someone else for them. Sounds like a win for this audience on HN, no?
* Birth Control, yes and no. We should be able to opt out paying for it, especially if it goes against my religion and frankly it does, but I won't stop others from opting in and paying for it.
The goal of health-related regulation should be to improve health-related access and outcomes. There is no question, based on data, that birth control improves women's health, allows them to finish school or further their careers in greater numbers, and eventually increases their lifetime earnings potential, which of course contributes back. If you make exceptions for people's precious feelings, you're looking at an awfully slippery slope. I envision a bunch of assholes declaring that they will opt out of vaccines for religious reasons, then everyone else starts opting out of paying for vaccines and, well, hello again Mr. Measles. No, terrible idea. You don't have to like the latest military campaign to acknowledge the need to pay for a military, and likewise, you don't need to approve of the way others behave to acknowledge the social benefits of birth control.
* Remove the boundries of the state borders. This is regulation. Not allowing companies to work and provide across state lines is ridiculous and again government overreach that could quickly drive down costs.
Sure.
* Lastly, I want hospital prices published. I want to shop around.
This just doesn't work unless you publish a single price list at the national level and force all health providers to honor that list (Japan). There are two problems. One, sometimes your health needs are too immediate to allow shopping, and you're beholden to whoever happens to pick you up and treat you. If you're bleeding out on the road, you're not gonna stop someone from calling the ambulance just so you can go on yelp and find the best service. Seems like a bad idea to build policy around the assumption that buying health care is like shopping for shampoo. Two, as a person who is likely not a medical professional, you probably wouldn't be able to make sense of any such price list with respect to your needs. Any such list would be detailed beyond the common person's understanding (see Japan), and anyway, you would need to seek diagnosis to know what to pay for in the first place.
> * Age 26 under the parents health care plan, fine, but damnit kid, get a job. Do something with yourself.
I don't think you can simply equate having a job to "do[ing] something with yourself". Neither can you equate not having a job to not "do[ing] something with yourself". As always, situations (especially in the macro) are complex and subtle and solutions can't be boiled down to a simple directive.
Adults < 26 are often not the ones responsible for not being able to obtain a job. Yes, they may have chosen a field of study that's not in demand (even though many were probably told to "do what you love"), but they've also likely had very little opportunity to impact things like domestic economic policy, employment trends, or even employers not recognizing shifts in demographically driven skill-sets.
> * Birth Control, yes and no. We should be able to opt out paying for it, especially if it goes against my religion and frankly it does, but I won't stop others from opting in and paying for it.
In a system where much (most?) health insurance is provided as an employer paid benefit, why should my employer get to decide whether I'm opted in or out of a particular thing based on religion?
Ideally (from my point of view), religion plays zero part in health care. What is wrong with a benefit being available to all and only used by those that want to use it? Is this so different from the "in the privacy of my own bedroom" argument?
Personally, if someone is morally opposed to what they perceive as killing, I don't care if their morals are based on religion, atheism, or just squeamishness. Preserve their moral objection to killing. It's too valuable to society for us to trample on it.
I can't opt-out of supporting the military with my taxes - how is this any different?
And, while you're at it, please answer my original question rather than throwing out strawman arguments.
> why should my employer get to decide whether I'm opted in or out of a particular thing based on religion?
Setting aside arguments that abortion is permissible even if the fetus has a right to life (e.g. Thomson's "A Defense of Abortion"), for many people the crux of the matter is whether or not a fetus is a living human being. The problem is that current science cannot tell us exactly when a clump of cells becomes conscious; we don't fully understand consciousness, so assigning it to a given object can be contentious. We simply have no good way of knowing when there is a person "in there", so to speak.
Since science cannot answer this question, religion has filled the void with beliefs about when someone's life actually begins. If we understood consciousness and could detect when it "starts", I suspect this debate would be much less dramatic.
Now that thats out of the way.
I hate the ACA. Its overreach by what the government should be doing. No where in the constitution does it say the government is allowed to force law abiding citizens to do something. ACA does exactly that. It forces people to do things against their will. Or they will be forced to pay a fine. Alright, don't down vote me just yet.
Lets repeal the ACA. But I certainly see things that should be quickly made into law.
* Preexisting conditions cannot be denied and should be slightly elevated costs compared to the average user.
* Age 26 under the parents health care plan, fine, but damnit kid, get a job. Do something with yourself.
* Birth Control, yes and no. We should be able to opt out paying for it, especially if it goes against my religion and frankly it does, but I won't stop others from opting in and paying for it.
* Remove the boundries of the state borders. This is regulation. Not allowing companies to work and provide across state lines is ridiculous and again government overreach that could quickly drive down costs.
* Lastly, I want hospital prices published. I want to shop around.
* I am business friendly, but these are common sense laws.
I think EVERY Republican can get behind these thoughts as every other Democrat, but forcing me to pay for it, when I just want to live off the land in some small town somewhere. Complete overreach and strictly unconstitutional.