News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:56AM (#13372074)
"Externalities" is how economists describe those costs.

Realistically speaking, the barber shop could only really push people to park:

* On the street. And you know what? That's fine. If the street was built to have parking, and people are parking there, it's not a problem. It might be more of a PITA for the clients. If it's too much of a PITA, the business may suffer. But that's how markets work.

* In some other business' parking spots: that can easily be solved by other means, rather than having city-wide laws covering all barbers in the city, some of which may cater to hipsters riding fixies who do not need car parking, and others who have elderly patrons who will not tolerate being forced to walk more than they absolutely have to.

I'm not a "markets solve all the problems kind of guy" because externalities are real things. But I feel that our cities are way too regulated. Zoning didn't even exist in Bend until 1947. Some of the first zoning regulations didn't come about until the early 20th century in the rest of the US.

How would we react if there were a "planning commission" that dictated how much of each kind of restaurant (Vietnamese, Mexican, Burgers, etc..) at what kind of price point could exist in a city? Zoning should be to keep truly noxious things away from where people live, not to keep duplexes away from single family homes, or barber shops outside of residential areas.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:05AM (#13372096)
Yes, there are externalities and also other ways markets fail; that's why I didn't use the term.

Maybe there aren't enough street parking spots for all the businesses, and then the market fails: No business wants to spend on on-site parking in order to free up parking for everyone else. The way to move forward is to come together and pass a law.

> Zoning didn't even exist in Bend until 1947. Some of the first zoning regulations didn't come about until the early 20th century in the rest of the US.

I'm not sure that means anything either way. Baseball didn't become desegregated until 1947 either. Is there something suspect about advances or changes in society that are recent? Did humans live better before 1947?

> I feel that our cities are way too regulated.

With due respect, this is too easy to say without evidence, is too general to have much application, and it has become cliche to say it about everything. In what ways are they too regulated, and in what ways not regulated enough? Do you have anything to back it up? How much regulation is just right?

> How would we react if there were a "planning commission" that dictated how much of each kind of restaurant (Vietnamese, Mexican, Burgers, etc..) at what kind of price point could exist in a city?

Vote them out of office? Appear at the planning commission meeting? Organize restaurant owners and talk to elected representatives? Democracy is a proven, effective tool. Case in point: I haven't heard of your hypothetical extreme scenario happening.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @01:13AM (#13372117)
By enacting laws, you create a very rigid situation that's much more difficult to change than "there's not enough parking", which is something the neighborhood could adapt to without too much trouble.

When I was born, Bend was still a wood products industry town based around logging and the local mills. These days, it's trying to develop a high tech industry, and doing reasonably well at it for a small-ish town. Places need to adapt, and rigid zoning is probably detrimental to that adaptation. Markets take in everyone who lives, or wants to live in a place. Planning commissions, or even city councils, have just a few people with their own ideas of "how things should be".

In terms of how they're too regulated, sure:

http://marketurbanism.com/2016/09/06/shut-out-how-land-use-r...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/10/04/...

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/04/business/how-anti-growth-...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/08/10/why-c...

And Exhibit A: the market for housing in the San Francisco Bay Area, which is completely batshit crazy because of the refusal to build housing.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @03:29AM (#13372572)
I do think the market is a very useful tool and that some things are over-regulated and some are under-regulated. But I don't understand your point: All regulations are bad? Everything is too regulated? I know these ideas are trendy, but they don't really mean anything or inform us. As I asked before:

In what ways are they too regulated, and in what ways not regulated enough? ... How much regulation is just right?

Without answers to those questions, we have nothing serious to act on.

> By enacting laws, you create a very rigid situation

A general statement, but laws can change. Laws often are written to create flexibility, delegating authority to regulatory commissions. Markets can be very rigid; look that the market power of Windows, whose dominance has lasted longer than most politicians' careers. When is the last time the market allowed in a new car manufacturer (Tesla hasn't yet survived infancy, and if it does it will be the only exception in (80?) years). How long does it take to change a web standard in the 'free' market? If they were government regulations, they could be changed like analog to digital TV or the reallocation of spectrum. I thought Europe's regulated, universal GSM was better than the U.S.'s 'market' solution of competing technologies.

Also, laws allocate power democratically to all citizens. The 'market' allocates it to those with the most money.

> Planning commissions, or even city councils, have just a few people with their own ideas of "how things should be".

I disagree; they are creations of and responsive to the democratic process. The market, on the other hand, is responsive to a few people with the most money; most citizens have no say. I don't want my community run by the wealthy, with 99% of citizens living like subjects under an aristocracy.

> In terms of how they're too regulated, sure: ...

I don't see a few op-eds as evidence; I have no doubt there are enough people who believe it that op-eds could be supplied daily. If you are correct about SF Bay Area (I don't know), it is an example of something that is over-regulated in some way, not evidence that the everything is over-regulated (again, could you really be saying that?).

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:16AM (#13373969)
I'm not a 'markets solve all problems' guy. There are plenty of good regulations and plenty of places where markets don't seem to work. I'd be happy to tell you about how single payer health care works in Italy - better than the mess we have here in the US.

That said, I think housing and cities are overregulated in the US.

Those op-eds point out a lot of issues that you can study further and find that mostly, the cause is zoning and regulation of housing/land use. They also cite other sources.

Here's a book, talking just about parking:

http://amzn.to/2jvfxpJ - Donald Shoup's "The High Cost of Free Parking".

Here are some books about zoning and regulation:

Ryan Avent's "The Gated City": http://amzn.to/2jv3dpk

Bill Fischel's Zoning Rules!: http://amzn.to/2j62fTw - dry and very, very thorough.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by thinkloop on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @03:59AM (#13372674)
Doesn't parking specifically seem like an easy thing for a market to fix: paid parking lots.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by richmarr on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:25AM (#13372966)
The word "fix" is important here. When you fix something it starts broken and ends up working how it should. Since space in cities is fiercely constrained any change is always a trade-off with repurcussions.

Cities plan transport infrastructure years or decades in advance, and spend vast sums of money, with very different incentives to the market. Leaving parts of that plan (like parking) up to the whims of the market might seem a bit irresponsible.

For example; if a city makes design trade-offs favouring heavy long-term road use, but the market decides in the shorter term that office blocks are more profitable, then you end up with mismatched capacity (headaches for drivers and ineffective public spending) and inadequate investment in infrastructure for cycling, walking, and public transport. Now you could argue that the market will step in and fix the parking problem, but that could easily take longer than an election cycle, and cost the local economy vast sums in wasted investment and lost opportunity.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by Zach_the_Lizard on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @06:58AM (#13373312)
>very different incentives to the market.

They are concerned about being elected, that's it. Hence why we have huge infrastructure bills coming to haunt us, pensions that are out of control (though dwarfed by infrastructure costs), and other passing the buck behavior.

That's not to say they're bad, do no good, etc. Just that their incentives are such that they can't enact good policy oftentimes or possibly even tell the truth to voters. Otherwise they lose power.

>Leaving parts of that plan (like parking) up to the whims of the market might seem a bit irresponsible.

In NYC, large portions of the subway system, Metro North, the PATH, Long Island Railroad, and New Jersey Transit and the Amtrak Northeast Corridor were built by private companies (or even multiple competing companies) to make a buck.

In the case of the subway, the city wanted control and fixed the price such that it wouldn't rise with inflation. A few decades of that and heavy car subsidies and suddenly the two companies go bankrupt and the city takes over.

Then the city demolished a whole bunch of useful elevated lines which even now are not fully replaced.

Then it continued to fix prices (even had an elected board to set prices, guess what voters wanted?) and now we have a huge backlog of deferred maintenance and outdated technology when we once were world leaders.

Most American cities have similar stories, it just is streetcars instead of subways. LA even used to have a bigger rail system than NYC, believe it or not.

Tokyo by the way continues to have multiple semi private companies run its rail and subway systems. Seems to work well. Same in Hong Kong IIRC and a few other Asian cities. Outside of Asia, many cities at least outsource running the systems to companies like Keolis (which is French), even if they fund expansion.

>For example; if a city makes design trade-offs favouring heavy long-term road use, but the market decides in the shorter term that office blocks are more profitable, then you end up with mismatched capacity

The best transportation policy is to not move at all or otherwise minimize trip distance and increase the density of connections.

Pre-zoning US cities were all mixed use, compact, and generally either gridded or (as in downtown Manhattan) grew organically with many connections (lots of narrow windy streets down there) as you see in many Old World cities.

Transportation costs were low; foot, bike, and transit were sufficient, even after the advent of the automobile.

If the city is ignoring this to promote cars it's a failure of city planning, not the market, when valuable land is used for valuable purposes. It's doubly a failure since it can use zoning to prevent these buildings from being built and / or eminent domain afterwards.

What that has to do with the market I don't understand.

>inadequate investment in infrastructure for cycling, walking, and public transport.

Businesses generally love walkers, hence why Fifth Avenue rents are so high. They'll pay for sidewalks for sure if they're not provided in front of their buildings if it's a place walking can be expected.

In Okinawa Japan where I lived it was a car centric place but they provided (possibly paid) parking with no legal mandates.

Historically most transit was built by private companies in the US, including the NYC subway (which was two companies originally, with the city owned IND later).

>Now you could argue that the market will step in and fix the parking problem, but that could easily take longer than an election cycle, and cost the local economy vast sums in wasted investment and lost opportunity.

The first subway line, using mostly pickaxes and other hand tools to excavate, took 4 years to build. We had a whole bunch of elevated rail lines and streetcars in NYC built by private funds. I'm sure with modern technology we could build faster than that.

So long as competition isn't heavily subsidized the market can work.

With transit cars were subsidized (even by transit itself; oftentimes they'd have to pay for some of all road maintenance on their routes) and most cities fixed transit prices driving them out of business.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by richmarr on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:00AM (#13373608)
> They are concerned about being elected, that's it.

Politicians are clearly incentivised by election, but saying its their only concern is generalising and reductionist.

The rest of your comment makes a lot of points, but broadly seems to assume that I'm claiming that private companies have no place in transport infrastructure, which is not the case. My point was that "the market" meaning an unmanaged build-it-and-they-will-come approach would not be optimal, in response to my parent commenter's "an easy thing for a market to fix".

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:48AM (#13374203)
Trying to plan very complex, dynamic systems leads to:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem

Of course, public things like streets and roads and so on needs some planning. I'm no Ayn Rand "privatize all the things" guy.

But make that infrastructure flexible and less rigid and allow a city to adapt. The city where I live had 20K people 40 years ago, and was a logging/mill town. Now it's a tourist town with a budding high tech industry and closing in on 100K. Too much land use planning gets in the way of a city adapting.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by richmarr on Thursday January 12, 2017 @06:37AM (#13381473)
Totally valid. It happens. On the other hand it's clearly a statistical outlier. I'd be wary of trying to create one ruleset that covered both wherever you live, cities like Detroit, rural towns, industrial towns, etc. that will all have different environmental needs, density, rates of change, access to private investment capital, etc.

Similarly... it's hard to impossible to predict the future, which is why economists predictions are so often wrong, as you point out. Gold rushes often ended in ghost towns. Who's to say in another 20 years your town won't be back doing logging and milling, and would be better off not bending to support an industry that may turn out to be ephemeral?

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by jsymolon on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:09AM (#13373934)
>My point was that "the market" meaning an unmanaged build-it-and-they-will-come approach would not be optimal, in response to my parent commenter's "an easy thing for a market to fix".

The item that worries me, and based on decades of observation, that the private companies will snap up all the profitable routes and leave the non-profitable routes to the city, thus deepening the budget gap.

The "market" will do that w/o some sort of regulation specifying that the private companies have to support the other routes.

Kind of points to the cable industry and local agreements w/ towns.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:20PM (#13378032)
> They are concerned about being elected, that's it. ... / That's not to say they're bad, do no good, etc. Just that their incentives are such that they can't enact good policy oftentimes or possibly even tell the truth to voters.

I must say, I'm happy with my local elected officials. The main problem I see on the national level are politicians with an ideology - government can't do anything, thus they obstruct everything. They are the problem, not government.

(I'm not saying government is at all perfect, but democracy is a great tool.)

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by thanatropism on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @06:47AM (#13373266)
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by richmarr on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @04:38AM (#13372815)
Thanks for making all these points so eloquently.

It does seem like an easy, and popular, refrain to claim over-regulation. It's a great way to sound contrarian and wise without actually having to do any analysis, after all, the market do the work so no planning is needed. In that noisy environment, asking for specifics of precisely what is over-regulated and why seems both fair and necessary.

> I thought Europe's regulated, universal GSM was better than the U.S.'s 'market' solution of competing technologies.

A similar example, the market has decided on competing standards for charging points for electric vehicles (in the UK at least, I expect most other places too). If a family of standards had been created to cover the various voltage/current requirements, rather than leaving it solely up to manufacturers then the time overhead for drivers of EVs could be dramatically improved, removing a significant obstacle to adoption.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by Zach_the_Lizard on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @04:06AM (#13372700)
>Maybe there aren't enough street parking spots for all the businesses, and then the market fails: No business wants to spend on on-site parking in order to free up parking for everyone else.

Or it could be parking is a low value land use and little parking is truly optimum. Oftentimes when streets are closed to car traffic permanently there's a boost to business in dense cities.

Many cities don't have parking minimums and they have minimal parking but yet function well. Manhattan for instance is like that.

I lived in Japan and I don't think auto centric Okinawa where I lived had Parking minimums. It had less parking, but from what I recall more private paid lots and higher utilization (no seas of unused parking because a random bureaucrat decided malls needed exactly 2.5 spaces per 1000 square feet).

>Did humans live better before 1947?

In some ways, yes. There were obviously planning failures, but mostly zoning was put in place to exclude the poor and minorities without passing an explicit ban. Just build a place they can never afford and it'll be all great, or so they thought.

IIRC a majority of wealth inequality is due to housing costs. These zoning laws prop up the cost of housing and make it more and more difficult for the young to buy.

Used to be you'd have like a 5 or 10 year loan to buy a house, which might cost 3x the average salary. Not anymore.

>Do you have anything to back it up?

You can compare US zoning with that of other nations and compare cost of housing, transportation, and other metrics.

I think you'll find that on many metrics we do quite poorly.

Also: mobility is decreasing as the cost of housing has increased, which in turn has GDP growth ramifications as workers cannot seek out the highest paying jobs.

This is why some countries like Japan handle zoning at the national level.

>Vote them out of office

Good thing in many cities these planning guys are unelected. Voting out, say, the mayor or city councilman is also ineffective as a majority would be needed.

Incentive wise it's in each district's best interest to ban new housing as that gives land owners more and more money as the population rises and chases the same housing stock.

Add in rent control and rent stabilization and a slim majority are incentivized to keep things as they are.

>Democracy is a proven, effective tool.

Democracy is effective at not rounding up dissidents in secret police raids, but in cases like this it breaks down. Zoning acts as a ban on people, and those people can never become voters, thus perpetuating the system.

Choosing the voters is almost as good as not having a vote at all.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @04:57PM (#13377863)
>> Did humans live better before 1947?

> In some ways, yes.

Humans in the U.S. are far better off now in almost every way. Of course there are exceptions.

> Democracy is effective at not rounding up dissidents in secret police raids, but in cases like this it breaks down.

I disagree strongly; democracies perform exceptionally well economically. All the wealthiest economies are democracies, and they are far wealthier than any other economies in the history of the world. Saying democracies do well for political rights but not economics is like saying Microsoft did well with operating systems but not office suites.

And one could argue that human welfare is better in democracies with more planned economies, such as the Nordic countries.

Are democracies still very flawed? Absolutely, but I haven't seen a better option. As someone said, democracy is the worst possible choice, except for all the others.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by LordKano on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:24AM (#13374013)
This desire of urban planners to regulate virtually every aspect of city life is precisely why I live in the suburbs.

I like to remind budding conservatives and libertarians that the free market is an ideal, not a mandate. The situation you describe is one that it perfect to be handled by the market. It's a cliche but it's also true that what matters is "Location, Location, Location". If you locate a business in an area where the people who would normally patronize it do not often travel or where they can't obtain adequate parking, that business will suffer.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by ocschwar on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @12:26PM (#13375620)
> This desire of urban planners to regulate virtually every aspect of city life is precisely why I live in the suburbs.

That's a bizarre thing to say.

Construction in the suburbs is far more tightly regulated in the suburbs than in the city.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:28AM (#13374050)
> regulate virtually every aspect of city life is precisely why I live in the suburbs.

You could easily get the same thing out of a HOA in a city with fewer city-wide rules and regulations.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by LordKano on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:38AM (#13374120)
You are absolutely right about that, I also would never buy a home in a community with a HOA.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:41AM (#13374145)
Ah, I see what you are saying: you think that suburbs are not planned down to the most minute of details?

I don't know where you live, but I bet if you read a copy of your local zoning code, and have a look at the zoning map, you will probably find that yes, your suburb is very, very heavily regulated, including parking minimums, minimum floor/area ratios, setbacks, uses, and so on and so forth.

Probably less than some HOA's demand, but still a lot of details. I too am not the kind of person who relishes that level of control, but I suppose some people like it.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by LordKano on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @09:59AM (#13374307)
You raise a valid point. I just looked at my local code book of ordinances and they do cover a lot, including the number of parking spaces by square footage.

In my experience, in a smaller town, these things are primarily used as a weapon to punish otherwise bad businesses.

For example, we had a bar whose patrons became a neighborhood nuisance. They began to enforce the letter of the law for every violation until the bar closed.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by davidw on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @10:14AM (#13374444)
There's an alternate universe where these kinds of problems are entirely dealt with through nuisance and noise laws and that kind of thing: the bar is permitted wherever people want to build it, however, the local authorities come down hard on people being a PITA. So if it's a wine bar where middle aged people sip quietly and chat about business, it's not going to bother anyone. The rowdy biker bar probably won't last long in a residential area.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by WWLink on Thursday January 12, 2017 @12:36AM (#13380033)
That sounds pretty bad. If you make everything illegal then only selectively enforce the laws...
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by LordKano on Thursday January 12, 2017 @08:39AM (#13382070)
In the USA, that seems to be the model at all levels of government.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by zeroer on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @06:06AM (#13373128)
Just have metered parking everywhere and have the cost per unit time reflect the local demand for parking. Now you've eliminated an externality.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by hackuser on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:01PM (#13377899)
> Just have metered parking everywhere and have the cost per unit time reflect the local demand for parking. Now you've eliminated an externality.

But that doesn't resolve the question of the supply of parking spaces - i.e., how many there should be. That only allocates the existing ones.

Also, it allocates them to those who can pay more; that's not always desirable. For example, should citizens' access to the grocery store be limited by their ability to pay for parking? To city hall?

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by zeroer on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @05:46PM (#13378173)
Yes? It's a finite resource that has to be allocated somehow. Having to have space for parking is a negative externality of owning a car. Make owning a car more expensive and you'll see fewer people driving, taking up parking spaces.

I don't own a car because it doesn't make financial sense for me to do so. That's the kind of longer term market impact you'd want to see.

Edit: The choices are not between allowing people to go to the grocery store and courthouse or not, it's between taking the bus and driving. I do just fine on public transport without a car.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by dnautics on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @06:41AM (#13373248)
Who gets to decide the cost per unit time? Do we have 24/7 real-time bidding system?
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by zeroer on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:51AM (#13373835)
Presumably some governmental authority. Some realtime bidding system would be nice, but that may or may not realistic. I think a realistic goal is that the prices should be set such that there's always 1-2 spots available in any given small area (say, one city block). If you have zero spots available, then the prices are too low and should be raised. If half the street is empty, the prices are too high and should be lowered. The prices will have to adjust based on time of day and day of week, etc.. It doesn't have to be be perfect to be much better than the system we have now.
Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @08:53AM (#13373847)
> Some realtime bidding system would be nice, but that may or may not realistic.

Realtime bidding would be a UX nightmare, though I guess it's Econ 101 (i.e., ignoring lots of real factors, including transaction costs) optimal.

Re:Why Many Cities Have No Money by zeroer on Wednesday January 11, 2017 @10:07AM (#13374380)
Yea, I don't really think realtime bidding is worthwhile for these kinds of transactions. It makes bothering with it too much trouble.

Rather, I think a municipality setting prices by fiat to be something that mostly gives the an approximate solution most of the time.