News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by mberning on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:42PM (#13352515)
I love the characterization that most if not all of these people are highly skilled and highly prized talents. My experience working with many over the years is quite the opposite. That is not to say that there are not a few good talents here and there, but to say that most of them are good or above average developers would be innacurate. I recently started working on a codebase that was developed by 200 on shore and off shore Indian contractors over the course of a few years. What a disaster. And no engineering disipline whatsoever to mitigate it.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by headcanon on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:46PM (#13352530)
If you had a codebase that was developed over a few years by 200 different remote contractors, thats a recipe for disaster regardless of their nationality.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by nsgi on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:57PM (#13352581)
Why should it be any more of a disaster than an open source project?
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by mehwoot on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:09PM (#13352656)
An open source project is primarily composed of people writing some software out of passion with few hard deadlines. A team of 200 developers, some off shore, are developing in order to get paid for a client who likely has strict time and budget constraints. I'm not sure I could come up with many scenarios that I would expect to see a wider gap in code quality, even if the developers were the same level of skill.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by rak00n on Monday January 09, 2017 @11:12PM (#13362511)
Also it's easier to nope a bad decision for OSS. Office politics makes it way difficult.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by zeroxfe on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:02PM (#13352609)
For one thing, an open source project typically has a stable set of one or more core contributors, who really care about the project.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by mistermann on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:02PM (#13352605)
I would wager that open source projects are most likely some of the best run projects in the world.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by devnonymous on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:13PM (#13352687)
I suggest that you (re)read Cathedral and the Bazaar if you really are curious about the difference between a project worked on by 200 odd developers in a company and an open source project.

The more we learn the less we know.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by nedwin on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:48PM (#13352547)
My experience is quite different. Almost every Indian-born engineer I have worked with has been hard working, intelligent, skilled and experienced.

This is reflected in not only the volumes of Indian candidates hired in SV but also their seniority with a disproportionate number of South East Asian CTOs at fast growth companies.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by johnnyb9 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:05PM (#13352628)
Maybe that's the case with Google or Facebook or Amazon. For all the other medium or small businesses for which these visas predominate (albeit indirectly), my experience has been quite the opposite.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by nedwin on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:26PM (#13352749)
Why do you think that is?
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by bsg75 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @07:27PM (#13353078)
As with any employee, you get what you pay for. If the program is used to obtain cheap labor, quality will be affected.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by jimbokun on Sunday January 08, 2017 @07:25PM (#13353070)
Just a guess, but maybe because Amazon, Google, Facebook hire better developers in general?
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by ardit33 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @05:49PM (#13352551)
my experience is quiet the opposite. Almost all foreign engineers I worked with, were way above average. But, it was mainly the companies that I worked for: They cared to hire the best they could (independent of ethnicity or country of origin). Their foreign staff was quiet diverse as well (not dominated by one country/ethnicity).

The only company that I worked where this was not the case, it was a company that didn't care much about the quality of engineers, and it was friends hiring friends type of things (mostly Indians hiring each other). The quality of engineering become poor, and I left after a bit.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by Spooky23 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:01PM (#13352600)
Most companies bring in these guys to save money. When you're paying a body shop $50/hr, you're getting a drone.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by maxxxxx on Sunday January 08, 2017 @10:05PM (#13353690)
From my experience the H-1Bs from bodyshops like Infosys and TCS are often not every good. The H-1Bs directly hired by companies are often way over average. It's pretty much directly correlated with salary.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by 464192002d7fe1c on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:12PM (#13352680)
Completely agree. I've been forced to rescue a number of projects that have gone completely off the rails. Nearly invariably in my experience its because someone decided that their American workers were too expensive so they decided to either hire in foreign workers, or offshore the work to a contractor.

In every situation where I've seen that situation happen, projects go completely off the rails. I don't think its because their foreign, but, I think people expect too much of these foreign workers (because they were getting that from local workers). They require far more supervision, both on a technical level (making sure the code they commit is sane) and on a managerial level (making sure they're actually committing code), and by far the worst offender, actually making meaningful progress towards the goal.

To explain what I mean by meaningful progress, I was brought in to figure out what was going on with a telephony app project that was off shored to Indian developers (think: twilio but definitely not twilio). The team of about 20 offshore developers had been plugging away for over a year working on the code at that point. Measured by things like code commits, they were amazingly productive. Thing was, there was no actual usable code. Firstly, the technology the team had been working with on both the frontend and the backend had changed multiple times, converting frameworks and methodologies repeatedly. Think: completely dumping a prototype-d Python framework application (with 100000s lines of template-generated MVC code) of and deciding to reimplement in Ruby-on-Rails, then after converting all their MVC concepts to 100000s of lines of MVC in RoR, they then converted to a symphony PHP framework (I wish I was kidding). When I arrived, the team was mulling switching to yet another framework (I want to say converting to nodejs on the backend?). The frontend had gone through many similar revisions as well.

The thing is, by many metrics, the team was actually amazingly productive. They had lots of meetings, had tons of commits, had massive numbers of bugs found/reported/fixed.

But, they had no idea about how to make the core of their product. They had no ability to answer basic questions, like, "how are you going to interface with the PSTN?" or even, like, "what database server are you planning on running in production?" Everything up to that point was based around running SQLite on their local dev machines. They didn't understand why they couldn't just continue to do so in production and moreover had no idea why (ORMs aside) their choice of database server might be important.

Now, don't get me wrong. I'm sure there are good and great Indian (and other foreign) developers. I just don't think that they are more common than great local developers and moreover I don't think they are ever cheaper than great local developers.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by sremani on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:25PM (#13352745)
If it top tier companies generally speaking the talent level is there, but if you are interacting with Offshoring company, it is usually a hit and miss.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by gorkemyurt on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:04PM (#13352621)
a stanford undergrad needs to apply for H1-B as well.. which is ridiculous
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by curiouscat321 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:10PM (#13352661)
So where does the line get drawn? Foreigners with Stanford degrees don't need visas but those else where do? What about MIT? Arizona State?

If you establish an arbitrary boundary, it won't make sense.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by gorkemyurt on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:20PM (#13352723)
4 year STEM degree from an american university seems like a good place to start.. its not enough but better than a fake or real engineering degree from somewhere else.

Because how the lottery is structured, anyone who went to an american college for undergrad (4 years) plus two years of OPT, has lower chances than someone who just did a masters degree in an american university (1 year), and equal chances with anyone else in the world.

Anyone who spent first 6 years of their adult life in the US is much more likely to adjust to the american lifestyle than than anyone else.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by HarryHirsch on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:49PM (#13352880)
4 year STEM degree from an american university? Good Lord. So someone from Oxford, EMBL Heidelberg or Lomonossov University in Moscow is out, whereas someone from any unranked place in the US that no one sane has ever heard of is in?

Half of the students that graduate from my department cannot calculate stoichiometry reliably, and they are a state college, issue a four-year degree and are properly accredited.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by gorkemyurt on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:57PM (#13352925)
No no they are not out.. just give them priority over literally any college in the world. By no means ideal, if it was up to me I would allow all forms of immigration (maybe in return of a small social safety net fee) just trying to brainstorm easy improvements to the current system.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by HarryHirsch on Sunday January 08, 2017 @07:07PM (#13352978)
What do you hope to achieve by prioritizing graduates of below-average domestic schools over graduates of some of the best universities in the world? Pay your dues to the man? Someone who graduates from a decent school can be productive at any company in the world, but a Doldrum State graduate is just a health hazard.

As for fitting in, back when when Soviet Russia came apart we had quite a few Russians at my university. They were all academics in their mid-40s and managed extremely well.

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by gorkemyurt on Sunday January 08, 2017 @07:24PM (#13353069)
Current System prioritizes people from India. From my personal experience (also see the article below[1]) people coming to the US for undergrad education usually end up in good universities.. Probably a small portion of them are going to below average private schools because their families are rich. They usually don't study STEM or they can't find jobs after graduation, you need a job first to apply for an H1B.

1. https://www.timeshighereducation.com/student/news/25-us-univ....

Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by turar on Sunday January 08, 2017 @07:33PM (#13353091)
Just like someone with low IQ and GPA and born in the US is in, but someone with high IQ but not lucky enough to come out of a vagina in the US is out.
Re:Plan to restrict highly skilled foreign workers could be ... by aub3bhat on Sunday January 08, 2017 @06:04PM (#13352620)
I worked at a very well reputed Unicorn. And everyone up the hierarchy including the CTO were recent arrivals. All were indians, except one who is russian.

Maybe you are suffering from Dunning-Kruger yourself and vastly overestimating your own skill relative to others.

Before you trash everyone from a specific nationality in xenophobic manner, Care to post your own genius qualifications? Maybe we can then determine what you mean when you say average in context of your occupation/employer.

Somehow implicit xenophobia and racism is fine on Hacker News as long as its directed against asians and indians.