News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by kxyvr on Sunday January 08, 2017 @01:08AM (#13348563)
Note, I am not an accountant, but these are my experiences running a business in the U.S.

If you are a passthrough entity like a sole-propietorship, partnership, or S-corp, probably not. Note, this doesn't matter if you're an LLC or not because the IRS doesn't care. Basically, passthrough entities calculate all business income minus deductible expenses as personal income. Therefore, the amount is subject to federal and state income tax as well as payroll tax (FICA). Certainly, income tax is tiered and FICA caps out at $118,500, but let's assume that you're pulling in $100,000. This mostly puts you in the 25% tax bracket. We'll assume that there's also 5% of state income tax. For FICA, since you're both the employee and the employer, you pay 15.3%. All together, that means you're losing about 45% to tax off the bat. Note, this taxes apply regardless of where you register your company unless you live out of the country for 330 days a year or can claim foreign residency. Then, it gets complicated because a certain amount of income is tax free, but not over a certain amount. Anyway, if you decide to live in the U.S., that 45% or so of tax from above applies regardless of where the company is registered. The reason people register their company outside the state where they do their business, other than liability and tort concerns, is because they're trying to avoid sales or gross receipts tax. However, everyone just bills that amount to their customers anyway, so it's really a wash.

If you really want to know the implications where you live, just hire an honest accountant for an hour and ask. That's what I did. It's worth the money.

--- Edit 1 ---

Look, if you really want to save money on taxes, just make more money. That sounds silly, but it's true. Register as an S-corp. Your first $118,500 are brutal because you're paying an extra 15.3%, but after that FICA goes to 0%. Now, the top tax rate in the U.S. is 39.6%, but dividends are how people cheat that rate. Basically, an S-corp is required to pay the people who work in the company the prevailing wage for that position. However, money above that amount can be distributed to the shareholders as dividends. These are taxed at 15%. Note, you can't just underpay yourself and then claim everything as a dividend. That's illegal and you will get caught eventually. That said, the overall tax rate for someone who's running an S-corp and making $300k is almost certainly lower than someone making $100k. For example, if you can convince the IRS that the prevailing wage for your position is $120k, and you made $300k, then the first $120k gets taxed at 45% or so (see above) and the last $180k gets paid out in dividends and taxed at 15%. That's how you get your tax rate down. Note, at this point, really, just hire an honest accountant who can do the correct calculations and paperwork.

--- Edit 2 ---

Note, I talked about being an S-corp above. However, even if you register your company out of the country, it doesn't matter. Americans must file their taxes every year regardless of where they live. If you are a bonified foreign resident, then the first $100,800 is tax exempt, but we still have to file this number. We also have to file what bank accounts have foreign assets over $10k at any time during the year. So, basically, when you file your taxes, the IRS doesn't care where your company is registered at all. You're going to pay your income tax and FICA, which is going to be in the 40% range if not more. Quite simply, if you're self employed, you're paying 15.3% in FICA. If you try to cheat this and your employer didn't pay the other half, the IRS will still want its money and you'll get caught. Even if you setup a foreign bank account with a foreign business, if a company pays you more that $600, they're probably going to file a 1099 in order to deduct that expense from their taxes, which means that the IRS knows about your income. Further, if you try to wire the money into the U.S. from your foreign bank, that goes through a check as well. Really, the IRS wants to get paid and they will one way or another.

It's not that illegal action can't hide money. Certainly, it can. However, it's difficult to hide money or reduce tax liability unless you have a lot of money to pay someone with a lot of know how to do it for you. At that point, just be happy that you're rich.

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by nodamage on Sunday January 08, 2017 @02:30AM (#13348762)
> This mostly puts you in the 25% tax bracket. We'll assume that there's also 5% of state income tax. For FICA, since you're both the employee and the employer, you pay 15.3%. All together, that means you're losing about 45% to tax off the bat.

Because tax brackets are progressive, it really does not make any sense to add the percentages up like that. No one making $100k/year is paying $45k/year in taxes.

> Your first $118,500 are brutal because you're paying an extra 15.3%, but after that FICA goes to 0%.

Only the Social Security tax (12.4%) tops out at $118,500, the Medicare tax (2.9%) does not have a cap, so you're still paying 2.9%, not 0%.

> However, money above that amount can be distributed to the shareholders as dividends. These are taxed at 15%.

This is grossly incorrect. S-corp profits are taxed as ordinary income (regardless of whether they are distributed to the shareholder or not).

> For example, if you can convince the IRS that the prevailing wage for your position is $120k, and you made $300k, then the first $120k gets taxed at 45% or so (see above) and the last $180k gets paid out in dividends and taxed at 15%.

No, the last $180k is taxed at ordinary income rates (which would be 33% given the example numbers). Do you actually operate an S-corp?

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by omarchowdhury on Sunday January 08, 2017 @03:21AM (#13348872)
Was going to post this. Only qualified dividends are taxed at the lower capital gains rate, normal dividends/distributions of profits are taxed at ordinary rate...
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by kxyvr on Sunday January 08, 2017 @03:40AM (#13348929)
Just checked. I think both of you are right on the distributions. My mistake.

Let me see if I can push out better numbers. From here:

http://taxfoundation.org/article/2017-tax-brackets

https://www.tax-brackets.org/newmexicotaxtable

$100k income generates $20981.75 federal income tax. FICA is paid on the full amount, so $15300. In my state, the top income tax rate is 4.9%, but with graduation, $4620.50. All together, that's $40902.25, or about 41%. That's not that far off the 45% estimate from above, but it is lower. I still contend that taxes on small businesses are still absurdly high.

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by nodamage on Sunday January 08, 2017 @04:23AM (#13349019)
If you're going to run numbers you might as well use a calculator that at least accounts for the standard deduction, personal exemption, and deducts 1/2 of the SE tax:

    Income: $100,000
    Self-employment tax on $100,000: $14,130
    Taxable income: $100,000 - $6,300 (standard deduction) - $4,050 (personal exemption) - $7,065 (1/2 SE tax) = $82,585
    Federal income tax on $82,585 = $16,418
    Total federal income tax and self-employment tax: $30,548
That's about 30%. Add in $4-5k for state income tax and you're up to 35% effective tax rate at most. And this is assuming a single filer with no dependents and no other deductions. Add a spouse or dependents, or IRA/401k contributions, or business deductions, and it goes even lower.
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by zerr on Sunday January 08, 2017 @01:39AM (#13348635)
Wow 45%? What is this, the socialist state without any benefits of it? In Germany you pay less taxes (30%-42%) but you get free healthcare, education, 1 year maternity and paternity leave and tons of other similar benefits...
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by kxyvr on Sunday January 08, 2017 @02:22AM (#13348745)
It's actually worse. The numbers above do not include the cost of healthcare nor retirement past what FICA pays for in social security. Say we're working with the magical $100k number above. In my state, my healthcare premiums were $500/month, which are not tax deductible. That means, I lose another $6k in premiums, or 6% of the $100k. My out of pocket max was $3300. I never want to be in a position to not go to the doctor because of money, so I always budget for it. Though, the payments for qualified medical expenses in that $3300 are tax deductible. So, let's pretend that 3.3% is really 2% after tax savings. That means that I spend 8% of $100k income on healthcare. If I add that to the 45%, then we're at about 53% of the money gone. Again, the number is slightly lower because of graduated tax brackets, but, candidly, it's not that much lower.

I lived a few years in Norway and have my company registered out there as well. I paid less in taxes there and got more in services. Other than culture, it's literally easier to start and run a company is many socialist countries. Simply, the taxes are lower; the services are higher; and the risk is lower because there's a safety net to fall back onto. That said, cultural does count for a lot and American culture is supportive of taking a risk as a small business. The U.S. is also the home to some of the world's largest companies, so opportunities to make contacts and contracts here can be higher.

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by mahyarm on Sunday January 08, 2017 @02:34AM (#13348770)
Employment law also makes it harder to hire employees. Every employee hire in places like Germany and such are huge risks to small corps, since it's very hard to fire bad employees who are net negatives, and they know it and abuse it. That is ironically probably the biggest barrier to starting a corp in Europe for me.

Health care insurance costs although should be tax deductible, and there are things like FSAs and HSAs that help make health costs even more tax deductible. Are you talking about the costs for paying other things in health care costs, like the $XXs per doctor visit and so on?

-----

America is ironically a high tax nation, but these things usually reduce tax and COL:

1. The mortgage interest tax deduction. That is easily a +$20k/yr tax deduction right there. There are other small tax deductions that can remove a few thousands here and there.

2. States like Washington or Nevada that have no state income tax.

3. Almost everything is significantly cheaper to buy in the USA

4. Sales tax / VAT is %0-%10 vs the common ~%20 that is common in the EU. Because the US is a mismanged mess governmentally, buying something online from another state is a common sales tax dodge.

5. Pay is significantly higher in the USA for software professionals. I once read it doesn't matter how much you spend, but really how much you make and that can make up for the tax rates.

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by matt4077 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @02:31AM (#13348767)
Top tax rate is 45% + 2.5% 'solidarity surcharge' and that does not include healthcare, which is another 12%. Unemployment is another 3%, pension is around 20% (although you'll get it back eventually), "pflege" (nursing?) is 2.5%, VAT is much higher than most places in the US at 19% so that sums up to... 105.5% – the error being that most of these are only applied on the net that's left over after paying other taxes. And some of these are the marginal rates applied only to income above certain thresholds (that 'solidarity' tax get to 2.5% only on income > ´1.3 million) while others, like healthcare and unemployment, have upper limits.

The best way to measure this is probably government spending/GDP (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending#As_a_perce...) which is about 46% for Germanys and 43% for the US, although you could argue that healthcare should be included in those numbers.

Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by tomcam on Sunday January 08, 2017 @01:46AM (#13348648)
This answer is comprehensive and correct, especially the second half. You cannot game the IRS, period. Google and Apple have billions of dollars in the bank in Ireland they can't spend because they have tried to game the IRS.
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa... by usiegj00 on Sunday January 08, 2017 @02:09AM (#13348716)
Actually--they borrow their own money from their foreign subsidiaries to have full use of the cash in the US. Expect the incoming US president to suggest changes that allow Apple, Facebook, et al to allow this openly rather than through construction.