Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa...
by omarchowdhury on Sunday January 08, 2017 @03:21AM
(#13348872)
Was going to post this. Only qualified dividends are taxed at the lower capital gains rate, normal dividends/distributions of profits are taxed at ordinary rate...
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa...
by kxyvr on Sunday January 08, 2017 @03:40AM
(#13348929)
Just checked. I think both of you are right on the distributions. My mistake.
Let me see if I can push out better numbers. From here:
http://taxfoundation.org/article/2017-tax-brackets
https://www.tax-brackets.org/newmexicotaxtable
$100k income generates $20981.75 federal income tax. FICA is paid on the full amount, so $15300. In my state, the top income tax rate is 4.9%, but with graduation, $4620.50. All together, that's $40902.25, or about 41%. That's not that far off the 45% estimate from above, but it is lower. I still contend that taxes on small businesses are still absurdly high.
Re:Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS compa...
by nodamage on Sunday January 08, 2017 @04:23AM
(#13349019)
If you're going to run numbers you might as well use a calculator that at least accounts for the standard deduction, personal exemption, and deducts 1/2 of the SE tax:
Income: $100,000
Self-employment tax on $100,000: $14,130
Taxable income: $100,000 - $6,300 (standard deduction) - $4,050 (personal exemption) - $7,065 (1/2 SE tax) = $82,585
Federal income tax on $82,585 = $16,418
Total federal income tax and self-employment tax: $30,548
That's about 30%. Add in $4-5k for state income tax and you're up to 35% effective tax rate at most. And this is assuming a single filer with no dependents and no other deductions. Add a spouse or dependents, or IRA/401k contributions, or business deductions, and it goes even lower.
Because tax brackets are progressive, it really does not make any sense to add the percentages up like that. No one making $100k/year is paying $45k/year in taxes.
> Your first $118,500 are brutal because you're paying an extra 15.3%, but after that FICA goes to 0%.
Only the Social Security tax (12.4%) tops out at $118,500, the Medicare tax (2.9%) does not have a cap, so you're still paying 2.9%, not 0%.
> However, money above that amount can be distributed to the shareholders as dividends. These are taxed at 15%.
This is grossly incorrect. S-corp profits are taxed as ordinary income (regardless of whether they are distributed to the shareholder or not).
> For example, if you can convince the IRS that the prevailing wage for your position is $120k, and you made $300k, then the first $120k gets taxed at 45% or so (see above) and the last $180k gets paid out in dividends and taxed at 15%.
No, the last $180k is taxed at ordinary income rates (which would be 33% given the example numbers). Do you actually operate an S-corp?