That is, in a 1080p v. 4K streaming contest, if you dedicate the same larger number of bits to the 1080p content as the 4K content, you'd get a better 1080p signal, too. With lossy compression, pixels aren't directly comparable, they have a quality, and low-quality 1080p pixels v. low-quality 4K pixels makes it hard to tell what differences are the format, and which are just the low quality in general.
(In other news, I consider the idea that streaming is obviously superior to disks to be a bit crazy. What disks have is higher quality pixels, and I expect that to continue to be true for a while. I've seen Bluray 1080p streams that are clearly superior to putatively 4K over-the-internet streams. And I've got DVDs that upscale to a higher quality than putatively 1080p streams of the same content.)
Far more important is the increased color gamut and HDR support, which does provide a noticeable increase in image quality. Even from those aforementioned dubious-quality streaming sources; the higher-gamut HDR images are a visible improvement over the NTSC-sunglasses we were all wearing without realizing it.
Heck, for 10 years I've seen people watching 4:3 TV on 16:9 screens, horribly stretched. People are almost blind, seriously. They'd tolerate about anything.
HFR and HDR on the other hand, are great. I've seen HDR/HFR demos in 2K at Amsterdam IBC and it looks much better (much more realistic) than standard 4K.
8K? The NHK makes 8K demos, and they can only show almost still images, else you only have extremely detailed motion blur at ordinary framerates. They even give you a magnifying glass to look at their 8K screen. That's impressive, but I don't plan watching movies through big lenses to catch the details, anyway. What's the point, apart from planned obsolescence?
I care very much. The Force Awakens was in 2k and looked like a gameboy game. And just about everything else unless I'm sitting right at the back.
[0] http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/by-size/size-to-distance-re...
We can make blunt statements about the limits of audio, because output devices behave (largely) linearly and band-limited, and because human perception can be modeled accurately and is also band-limited.
You can't say the same about video. The output is an array of points, not even perfectly square or smooth, it is picked up by another array of receptors, and is non-linear. The limit being 1/60th degree is too blunt a rule of thumb. That's picking an arbitrary point on a curve showing how much better than guesswork a viewer is.
The screen isn't a perfect output source, and the viewer isn't a perfect receiver, and the combined effect is you can easily observe the difference of 2K vs 4K images at distances those graphs say you wouldn't. I can easily observe the difference where it says I shouldn't be able to, and I'm nowhere near perfect vision.
I would say pretty much everything in those graphs is off by a factor of 2.
The real benefit from 4k is actually HDR and the MUCH higher bitrate for video. The majority of streaming 4k is really low quality when compared to a normal bluray. Just because the resolution is big doesn't mean the picture quality is any better. Also a lot of 4k content is actually upscaled from 2k sources. http://realorfake4k.com/
I am constantly consulting realorfake4k.com especially since the marketing for streaming (and even purchasing) is so confusing on Amazon Video.
That table is purely relative to the mass-market options and tries desperately to make a case for buying a TV in 2017 which only supports lower resolutions than were common a decade ago. Looking at you, "HD" in 720p.
So 2400dpi might be comparable to 150ppi for photographic images.
And by using colored ink (and/or colored paper) you can get some spectacular results on a fairly reasonable budget that way (worked at Kinko's a lifetime ago).
The only reason for me to go to a newer TV at this point is for HDR.
Definitely had a bit of shock reading text on the 1080 screen. My eyes had forgotten how painful it was by comparison.
A good example to consider is mobile phones and how sharp and precise the UI can be, with lines almost at hair thickness. Anti-aliasing is almost useless on phones already, and its all due to their pixel densities.
(of course, not so useful for 60" screens!)
And some unintended consequences as well. Buddy on my hockey team got a notice from Comcast that since he continually went over his 100GB data limit every month, they were raising his rates.
Incredulous, I asked him, "What on earth on you doing where you're blowing through 100GB of bandwidth every month?!"
His response? "I have to stream all my Netflix movies in 4K."
I presume the TV does upscaling? Not an expert, but theoretically a kick-ass algorithm should be able to gleam more resolution out of a temporally changing signal than the native resolution - thus actually providing more than 1080 pixels worth of resolution out of the 1080p stream.
When I bought a HD TV either the Blu-Ray player or my TV (can't recall anymore) upscaled my old DVD:s with surpising quality - I can only presume the same applies for the current generation (haven't had the chance to do detailed analysis).
Experts please revise.
Do you mean a wavering 4k sream outputted as 1080p?
The Freedman and Fattal paper they mention can be found here: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/7df0/39049948d54fd1f4d75526...
It's called super-resolution, or upsampling. Here is a good overview of techniques: http://www.robots.ox.ac.uk/~vgg/publications/papers/pickup08...
More recently, Google's RAISER: https://research.googleblog.com/2016/11/enhance-raisr-sharp-...
This repo pulls together techniques from several papers with impressive results: https://github.com/alexjc/neural-enhance
Anyway, it's an area of active research, there are already four dozen relevant papers in 2017 alone: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q="machine+learning"+"sup...
To this day, I don't think we've had a single installation with 4K projector / Receiver / player working together of different brands without some kind of serious issue.
ARC is another disaster that we STILL are having trouble with, and thats been out for years. I really hope that more has been done in the way of standardisation to help iron out these issues
That said, I'm not sad I went 4k because the set really IS that much better than a 1080 set, especially a low-end one. Sony upscaling and motion processing really is where it's at.
I went from a 2001 Toshiba 720p flat CRT to 2016 55 inch 4K SUHD HDR. I guess my brain had to get over the shock.
My tiny laptop screen is almost 4K, and the difference is massive from a 1080p screen because I'm so close.
Likewise, your 55" inch screen wouldn't need to be 4K if you sit 10 meters away from it.
According to the charts, I'm right on the outer edge of where it may make a difference, so it's at least physically possible I could tell, if I got a truly 4K stream.
http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/vizio/p-series-2016 has a 120hz panel but at 4K the "120hz" is interpolated; it's not actually getting 120 updates per second from the source (I wish). I have this exact TV as a monitor and 1080p gaming @120hz is glorious. 60hz is fine for desktop use but now that I've tasted it I can't go back.
20/20 vision is about 60 pixels per degree, depending on which study you want to believe. 41x60 is 2460 pixels across -- you've already reached the max required pixels with a 3840x2160 display.
I couldn't wait for the 40" Phillips to arrive in Canada, so I ended up getting a Dell 27" 4K monitor (that turned into two once I got addicted to all the real estate).
I have my monitors side by side on a standing desk where the range of closest and furthest distance of the screen to my eyes is between 21 and 27 inches. I have the monitors running at native text scaling in Windows (my wife and friends look at my screens and think I'm nuts), so I am pretty close to the threshold of seeing every pixel. Granted, I have single vision glasses that I wear for computer use (combination of distance + presbyopia correction), and those glasses coincidentally magnify what I see by a hair.
I'd love to get a 55" 8K curved display as a monitor. Oh, the added real estate...
Looking at the HN site, which has pretty small text to start with, I'm perfectly fine reading the text on the screen. If the text is too small, zooming once or twice usually fixes it.
I originally thought 40 or 32 would be the ideal size, but got tired of waiting for the models to come out.
I went into a store and checked out the 28" 4K monitors (which were pretty common), but I wanted IPS, so I ended up with the 27" Dell IPS, which got good reviews and not that much denser than the 28s (for me).
I actually am glad that I did not go 32 or larger because I got acclimated to the added real estate very quickly and wanted more. My desk handles two side by side 27s in landscape. I guess I could have went with two portrait 32s but I definitely could not fit in dual 40s.
I don't know if I can handle four monitors (more head turning than I have now), but I've got some mini monitors in addition to my two main ones, and I still feel at times that I don't have enough screen real estate when I'm multitasking.
Bright sunlight is about 120000 lux. That's about 38000 nits -- and the brightest specialty monitors I know of go up to about 10000 nits. A typical "wow, look at that" display is 2-3000 nits.
I run two of the Philips 40-inch 4Ks on my desk and although these are fantastic displays for the price, there are many areas for improvement.
Most importantly, and easiest to fix: they should be fully matte rather than semi-gloss. My contention is any display used for work should be matte unless you work in an environment with absolutely no lighting. Lighting glare is the most frustrating issue with computing, in large part because it's so easy to fix. In the early 2000s and before, monitors, including the highest-resolution monitors of the time, were almost exclusively matte. During the malignant era when living room displays converged into desktop workspaces and "HD" reigned terror on computing, we also accepted glossy/mirror displays. Although we have recovered from that period of resolution regression, matte remains marginalized.
40-inch at 4K is too small to use singularly and too low-resolution. I feel ideal is ~55 inches, concave, 10 to 15K horizontal resolution.
For what it's worth, here is a blog/rant I wrote in 2014 about ideal desktop displays: http://tiamat.tsotech.com/ideal-desktop-displays
I have an i3-5010u as a backup, which has a 28" 4K attached... it feels sluggish just on desktop use (150% zoom) in windows.
I you want to push much more than that, you're going to need some really beefy video cards in tandum.
Maybe the new 43 inch version is more matte but I have not seen it yet. Could not agree more that a 55 inch'er 10k resolution, would be my absolutely perfect display. With a low radius curve, and possibly curved vertically too (i.e. a rectangular sector of a sphere) though I am not holding my breath for that.
I'm with you on that. I run a pair of 27" 4Ks at native scaling, and I feel like I'm looking at a 10 year old monitor.
27" was about the smallest screen my eyes could tolerate at 1:1 scaling - I was driven by real estate more than sharpness. All other things being equal, I'd prefer a pair of 27" 8K monitors so that I can get my 4K equivalent real estate with crisper text.
Meanwhile matte displays actually get more affected by light falling on them, just that it's spread out a bit.
And if you've tried VR, we're still at the point where pixels are obvious and higher densities would be an improvement. The usual comment I get when friends try my Vive is that it looks like an N64.
Today's 2K VR headsets are the 480i of their nascent industry. They're good enough to kickstart a revolution. But the next generation of VR, with 4K displays, will be like the jump to HD – and the eventual adoption of 8K will be much more impactful than the TV world's move from 2K to 4K.
If I were guessing, this standard would be only for 1) large format projectors and 2) really larger and expensive boardroom/home theater LCDs.
The boss' son was a total audiophile and was constantly bragging about all the high end audio they sold and put in their clients home theaters.
I used to listen to a set of $15K speakers and then to a set of $8K speakers and I just couldn't tell the difference. It's kind of the same I think with monitor resolution, at some point, can the human eye really tell the differences between all the high end resolutions out there right now?
I have doubts most people can TBH, but would love some evidence we're not beyond the capabilities of what the human brain and eyes can actually differentiate between.
For me it starts to push up against the question of whether monitor resolution has hit the top of the s-curve. A 9600 x 5400 (10K) screen at 200PPI is 48" x 27". That is a 55" High DPI screen. And while glorious and amazing as that would be, I'm wondering if that would be "main stream" any time soon.