News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by anthay on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @05:32AM (#13317079)
I was one of the first employees in a UK tech startup. I was given share options that I calculated represented about 0.5% of the value of the company. When the company was sold about 10 years later, making the founders multi-millionaires, I got about £30K. I was clueless and didn't realise the shares could and would be diluted many times.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by neffy on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:39AM (#13318570)
Ten years ago it was much harder to find information on all of this - and even if you went in knowing it, there was little or nothing you could do about it.

I knew enough then to discount options to 0, but I'm permanently jaundiced in retrospect by just how many outright lies I was told at interviews, and saw being told to my colleagues.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by walkingolof on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:10AM (#13317239)
Yea, and dilution is just one issue, its almost impossible to know as a employee what the stock options represent, you have no insight in to the corporate structure and what entity the stock options are given for.

Its just all a lottery ticket...

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by new299 on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:42AM (#13317417)
It is possible to know. In the UK it's easier to know than in other countries, private companies still have to disclose share ownership and file public accounts (which you can download from companies house).

It's just that this information is often not provided or explained. Why companies think it's ok to say "you'll get X shares" when X is a meaningless number without more information, is beyond me.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by arethuza on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:26AM (#13318486)
There can be all manner of agreements in place that mean that the mapping from the share ownership structure pre-IPO/acquisition might not be straightforward.

e.g. When the company I co-founded went public there was a ratchet agreement in place (amusingly, which we'd tried to get removed at the time of the first round of VC investment) that gave us large amounts of new share options that was much larger than the employee share option scheme. Things like liquidation preferences also can also have a huge impact and as an employee your are probably not going to get visibility of all of these and I'm pretty sure none of this will be in Companies House!

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by aedron on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:13AM (#13317589)
But the dilution happened because your company had to sell out a lot more of its equity in order to succeed. You were not cheated. You could argue that you should have been offered to buy into the additional financing rounds in order to retain your share, but in all honesty, would you have taken them up on such an offer?
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by cmdrfred on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:16AM (#13317619)
I think the issue is they probably offered lower than market pay and "half a percent of the company" but what he ended up with was lower pay and .00025% of the company. Sure it's all legal and his fault for not understanding the fine print but I understand why he would feel cheated.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by aedron on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:41AM (#13317749)
The company could have shut down, and he would have gotten nothing. Would he have felt cheated then?

Instead they sold a part of the company (out of everybody's share) and with the money that brought in, they eventually succeeded. I don't see anything unfair in it.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by wastedhours on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:55AM (#13317832)
But also, the company succeeded due to the people who worked there working for less than market rate. Obviously dilution and all of the (fairly numerous) ways your share can be reduced are a risk factor and need to be taken into account, but still valid to feel hard-done by. Just because it's fair doesn't mean it's an easy pill to swallow.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by hubb on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @10:45AM (#13319159)
it shouldn't be hard to understand that being mislead about the actual value of your options is unfair. pointing out that things could have gone worse doesn't change that.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by danielweber on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @02:29PM (#13321286)
> (out of everybody's share)

Except that every dilution I've witnessed has come with re-upping the people who really Matter. Current employees we want to keep, and people sitting the board room.

Not everyone takes an equal hit from dilution. Some don't get hit at all. Some can get hit but handle it. (A founder diluted from 10% to 5% still is sitting on a huge nest-egg. An employee diluted from 0.01% to 0.005% may see her 200K payout changed to 100K.)

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by cmdrfred on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:56AM (#13317837)
I think the moral of the story is rate equity like that as worthless and refuse to work at a discount for it. These contracts are complicated and as a programmer you likely won't completely understand them unless you get a lawyer involved.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by wcummings on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:06AM (#13318329)
Tech workers need an organization to provide legal services, most people I know aren't empowered to have a lawyer review their employment terms. More accessible legal help would create pressure on employers to stop bad practices.

People on HN sometimes talk a big game about negotiating job offers, but in my experience, most software engineers are terrible at it, and are not equipped to go up against enormous companies with a lot of resources dedicated to paying them as little as possible.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @12:47PM (#13320366)
In my experience, most software engineers simply don't ask.

Forget negotiation. Just saying "I want $XXX" when interviewing for a position is a simple thing to do. What's the worst thing they can do? Not hire you! What's the best thing they can do? Give you what you asked for.

Is it really that hard to say "I really like the position you're offering, but unless you can meet my salary requirements, it's a non-starter?"

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by danielweber on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @02:30PM (#13321296)
How long has it been since someone linked 'patio11's guide to getting more money? If more than a week, too long, so:

http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/

We should all read this once a year. Even if you can't take it all to heart, whatever you read will help, and getting your colleagues to negotiate better will raise your rate, too.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by acjohnson55 on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:06AM (#13318326)
Lots of companies don't have the cash to pay market rate, in the early stages. Our even the mid stages. In those cases, it's best to make sure you're advocating for your stake on the business. But you're not going to get much unless you're indispensable to the company's success.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by logfromblammo on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @02:25PM (#13321233)
From a perfectly rational standpoint, the companies that cannot pay market rates for those employees required for their success should either raise more capital from qualified investors or fail immediately.

Don't defecate where you eat; don't invest where you work.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by acjohnson55 on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:37PM (#13323640)
One does not simply "raise more capital" to pay employees market wages in cash. That might very well be the morally superior approach, but it simply doesn't match reality. Most startups can't get that kind of capital at all, let alone on terms that would be worthwhile to the founders. Besides, the labor market is largely clearing, so you're not going to shame founders and investors to put more cash into comp. The much better bet is to educate employees so they can advocate for themselves.

> "Don't defecate where you eat; don't invest where you work."

That sounds pithy, but I don't see why that's good advice. If you work in a role where you can have a significant impact on the success of your employer, that can be a very advantageous situation compared to being a random investor in a venture you have no agency within. You also potentially have a lot more visibility than a silent investor. These are reasons one might choose to take equity over cash.

Had you argued that it might not be a universally great idea, from a portfolio management standpoint, to trade a lot of upfront cash for illiquid, volatile stock option, I'm with you.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by logfromblammo on Thursday January 05, 2017 @11:31AM (#13328487)
In practice, the people that can have a significant impact on the success of their employer are officers, or at least upper management. And they will also be in a position to negotiate their equity compensation. They don't need to take sound-bite advice from the Internet.

If you don't have a contract (you are "at will"), don't invest in your employer, ever. If you do have a contract, but can be fired for any reason that is outside your control, don't make an investment that is not completely liquid. If you can make the stock price move unilaterally, perhaps you should consider shorting it, quitting, and airing all the dirty laundry in public? That would be a dick move, but so is diluting all your employees into oblivion so you get a bigger share of the payout.

If one cannot raise enough capital to execute on the business plan, I question the value of the investment. In any case, the market is not homogenous. If you can't afford the market wages in Silicon Valley, move your startup to the Rust Belt. If you can't afford those wages, hire remote from Britain, Australia, or India. If you can't afford that, try your hand at lowballing freelancers. Or maybe hire one 40+ developer at 120% median pay instead of two 25-year-olds at 80%. Tricking your employees into thinking you're paying them more than they're actually getting is not a viable way to conduct business in the long run. Believe it or not, there is value in not being a scumbag employer.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by st3v3r on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @12:15PM (#13320046)
Really? How much of the founders share got sold? And how much of a say did he have in this happening?

I see nothing but unfairness in this.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by anthay on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @07:21AM (#13317643)
You may well be right and to be honest I don't really understand exactly what happened. But I do know I thought I'd get more than I did.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by jackgavigan on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @08:03AM (#13317895)
What was the company? We may be able to analyze what happened by looking at the documents published at beta.companieshouse.gov.uk
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by briffle on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @01:44PM (#13320910)
Seems like as a shareholder (well, I guess potential share holder, since they are options) you should have some say in that.. Is it okay to dilute my shares by x%, in order to continue functioning as an employee..

Of course that kind of insight would lead to employees jumping ship when there is trouble...

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by pjlegato on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @03:45PM (#13321867)
You do have some say in that as a shareholder -- most companies are goverend by shareholder vote. However, as a startup employee, your total number of shares is insignificant compared to the number of shares held by the founders and the investors.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by st3v3r on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @12:12PM (#13320006)
Diluting shares should be straight out illegal. There is no reason for it other than fucking over employees. You know, the people who have actually worked to make the company a success.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by mywittyname on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @04:41PM (#13322320)
In egregious cases, you could probably sue the board and win. Another user here discussed an example where employees were diluted to a literal penny right before a sale.

If the employees didn't win in that case, then there's some fundamental, structural flaw in American laws.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by danielweber on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @02:22PM (#13321215)
Dilution is way too easy to abuse, but there's a lot more to it than just "fucking over employees."
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by st3v3r on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @06:11PM (#13323021)
Really? Give me one example where it doesn't fuck over the employees?

And don't say "they get to keep their jobs", cause if that's all that's needed for benefit, we might as well devalue the options to 1 cent, cause after all, they still got to keep their job.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by danielweber on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @09:48PM (#13324303)
Shares need to come from someplace. Other people selling shares to the VC doesn't put any money into the company. The company needs to sell shares, and create shares if it doesn't have any left.

It's often abused, and easy to abuse, but you are making the story too pat by saying it exists only to screw over employees.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by adrianN on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @08:25AM (#13318035)
You did not specify "multi" further, but 30k * 1/0.5% is around 6 million. So your assessment seems at least in the right ballpark?
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by anthay on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @08:36AM (#13318101)
It was a private sale to a US company. I believe it was for an amount many times that figure.
Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by kurthr on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @10:12AM (#13318858)
Indeed... it's likely that the board issued themselves new stock to prevent their dilution, but not yours.

As an extreme example, I watched a startup in a private sale issue new stock to those on the board such that all of the other early (0.1-0.5% stock ownership) employees were diluted to $0.01. The total valuation was in the $100M range. It was a good way to make a few enemies and retire at 30.

In the end the acquiring company ended up having to hire some of those employees back for consulting... I believe several of them received >$1k/hr. Most of those employees suspect that the acquiring company tacitly signed off on the issuance of new stock.

Re:Big IPO, Tiny Payout for Many Startup Workers (2015) by shostack on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @12:13PM (#13320017)
You bring up a good point though which is that if you stand to make millions and retire early, and it comes at the expense of your employees making a comparable amount, is it worth it to screw them over?

Unfortunately in this messed up world and rollercoaster economy the answer is often yes, it is better to put yourself first. Not that I would, but I can see how those who do justify it.