News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by JumpCrisscross on Sunday January 01, 2017 @10:55PM (#13298938)
Is a Tesla bought today designed to be software upgradeable to full autonomy?
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by will_pseudonym on Sunday January 01, 2017 @10:59PM (#13298949)
"All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware" (October 19, 2016)

https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now...

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by dzhiurgis on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:26AM (#13300068)
I assume you pay extra for software though?
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by ntelson1s on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:53AM (#13300185)
Yes, you do.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by lazyjones on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:00PM (#13298955)
I don't think this can be answered safely. Recent models (like the one I ordered in November) have additional sensors, but until there is a safely working full autopilot, we won't know whether additional/different types of sensors will be needed.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by plttn on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:06AM (#13299556)
From what I've seen, technically anything with Autopilot HW2 is fully capable of complete autonomy, but legally isn't allowed to have it.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Animats on Monday January 02, 2017 @03:54AM (#13299930)
The California DMV is ready to license autonomous vehicles for deployment. Here are the regulations.[1] There's a "Application for a Permit to Deploy Autonomous Vehicles on Public Streets, form OL 321". The requirements aren't that difficult.

Highlights:

* The manufacturer has in place and has provided the department with evidence of the manufacturer’s ability to respond to a judgment or judgments for damages for personal injury, death, or property damage arising from collisions or accidents caused by the autonomous vehicles produced by the manufacturer in the form of an instrument of insurance, or a surety bond... That's the key condition. If it crashes, the manufacturer is financially responsible and has to carry insurance or post a bond, just like human drivers.

* The manufacturer shall identify any commonly-occurring or restricted conditions, including but not limited to: snow, fog, black ice, wet road surfaces, construction zones, and geo-fencing by location or road type, under which the vehicles are incapable of operating in the autonomous mode and certify that the vehicles are incapable of operating in autonomous mode under those conditions. Reasonable enough.

* The manufacturer shall certify in the application that the subject autonomous vehicles are equipped with an autonomous technology data recorder that captures and stores autonomous technology sensor data for all vehicle functions that are controlled by the autonomous technology at least 30 seconds before and at least 5 seconds after or until the vehicle comes to a complete stop after a collision That's like the air bag data recorder cars have now, but more comprehensive.

* Certification that the vehicle complies with the “Vehicle Performance Guidance for Automated Vehicles” in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Federal Automated Vehicles Policy This is the national policy.[2] It's not very restrictive; it's mostly self-certification. This is where there's a big distinction between NHTSA levels 1 (basic auto-brake) and 2 (auto-brake plus lane keeping), and levels 3 and above. Basic concept: at levels 1 and 2, the driver must pay attention and systems must not let the driver stop paying attention. This is the "hands on the wheel" requirement. At level 3 and above, the driver doesn't need to pay attention in autonomous mode, and if anything goes wrong, the manufacturer is responsible.

* The national requirements require a "safety assessment letter" from the manufacturer to the NHTSA answering questions in a few key areas:

    Data Recording and Sharing
    Privacy
    System Safety
    Vehicle Cybersecurity
    Human Machine Interface
    Crashworthiness
    Consumer Education and Training
    Registration and Certification
    Post-Crash Behavior
    Federal, State and Local Laws
    Ethical Considerations
    Operational Design Domain
    Object and Event Detection and Response
    Fall Back (Minimal Risk Condition)
    Validation Methods
Those all seem reasonable enough. There's no requirement for third-party testing.

* DMV reserves the right to revoke the self-driving license of a system that drives badly.

Passing certification gets a sticker for each car, like the stickers for low-emissions vehicles.

All this is far less restrictive than what's required for light aircraft.

Tesla needs to qualify for a license. Time to put up or shut up.

[1] https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/211897ae-c58a-4f28... [2] https://one.nhtsa.gov/nhtsa/av/av-policy.html

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by djsumdog on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:04AM (#13299968)
Thanks for the info and source. That's a very comprehensive summary about the base legal requirements for the test pilots in California.

It's interesting to see that the burden of insurance falls upon the manufacturer. I think that's fair during these pilots.

I still think there are a ton of legal questions that need to be addressed though. Should self driving car algorithms be standardized across the industry for safety? Because of the nature of saving lives, should self driving software be open for inspection and review in ways other software isn't? If people modify the software in the car, who is responsible? Can car "owners" legally modify code when safety and lives are of concern?

I had a post that addressed a few of these:

http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-sol...

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Animats on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:39PM (#13303756)
It's interesting to see that the burden of insurance falls upon the manufacturer.

That's what makes it all work without detailed regulation. Otherwise, there would have to be detailed technical regulations and pre-deployment testing. This way, the manufacturer is responsible. Period.

Volvo's CEO originally proposed that.[1] Volvo Car Group President and CEO Håkan Samuelsson said in 2015 that "the company will accept full liability whenever one of its cars is in autonomous mode." That's now US policy. Tesla and Uber probably hate that; both have tried to evade liability for bad autonomous driving. GM, Ford, and Chrysler seem to be OK with it; they've all survived big vehicle defect lawsuits and recalls. It's going to lead to much safer cars.

[1] http://fortune.com/2015/10/07/volvo-liability-self-driving-c...

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by halomru on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:06AM (#13300458)
I feel like all of those questions have existing answers in the automotive industry. Modern cars include so much software that there are very few legal angles that full autonomy adds.

>Should self driving car algorithms be standardized across the industry for safety?

Just like every other safety relevant feature of my car; Baseline requirements and tests standardised, implementation open to innovation and competition.

>Because of the nature of saving lives, should self driving software be open for inspection and review in ways other software isn't?

Same rules as the software of my ABS system, or of my airbag: it's up to the manufacturer, in practise nobody cares.

>If people modify the software in the car, who is responsible?

If I modify my brakes or my steering system I'm responsible for any damages caused by this modification. Why would software be different.

>Can car "owners" legally modify code when safety and lives are of concern?

Can I legally modify my breaking systems? Yes, but it has to fulfill the same road safety regulations, and frostin depending on what I do getting all required certifications might be impractical.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by billhathaway on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:05PM (#13298966)
Yes, Teslas manufactured since mid-October all have the hardware for full autonomy[0]. It will be interesting to see how long it takes and what technical and legal hurdles are involved.

[0] https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now...

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Animats on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:24PM (#13299025)
Maybe, maybe not. Tesla still doesn't have LIDAR. Their sensor suite is still much weaker than Google's or Volvo's or Otto's.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Reason077 on Monday January 02, 2017 @11:53AM (#13302285)
Tesla still doesn't have LIDAR.

It's not clear that LIDAR offers any real advantages over a camera suite combined with RADAR.

LIDAR has the same limitations as optical cameras with regards to rain, fog, etc.

As image processing capabilities continue to improve, the case for LIDAR gets weaker.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Animats on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:52PM (#13303862)
LIDAR has the same limitations as optical cameras with regards to rain, fog, etc.

Actually, no. With appropriate signal processing, LIDAR units can see through rain and fog. The early noise returns from rain and fog can be gated out until the system gets a reflection from something solid. There are expensive LIDAR binoculars that can see through fog. You adjust the minimum range until you're seeing past the fog. So far, automotive LIDAR units don't have that feature, but they could.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by toomuchtodo on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:32PM (#13299049)
Didn't the DARPA grand challenge show self driving was a software problem, not a hardware problem?

Tesla has a level 4 autonomy demonstration video on their site. Maybe computer vision is superior to LIDAR; not a lot of human drivers with laser arrays on them driving around.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by justinpombrio on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:58PM (#13299142)
> Didn't the DARPA grand challenge show self driving was a software problem, not a hardware problem?

Yes, the software is the hard part. That's why it makes sense to use hardware that makes the job of the software easier. LIDAR tells you how far away objects are; if you're using cameras you have to do that with software instead. AFAIK no one yet knows how to do computer vision with cameras in the sorts of situations a self-driving car needs (though I'm not a vision researcher). That means that Tesla is betting on solving a research problem to get the cars they've already sold to start driving themselves. I always thought that was an insanely audacious business plan.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by jon-wood on Monday January 02, 2017 @04:17AM (#13300030)
To be fair Elon Musk has a track record of coming up with insanely audacious business plans and then following through.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by taneq on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:59AM (#13299538)
> a software problem, not a hardware problem

I don't think this term even means anything. The problem can be solved by various mixtures of hardware plus software to varying degrees of adequacy.

On the one hand, we know that it's possible to drive a vehicle with high reliability in a wide range of circumstances with just two relatively low resolution cameras... if those cameras are feeding into a trained human-level intellect. What combination of hardware and software is required to generate that intellect is still unknown.

On the other hand, the problem seems relatively well solved using 3D laser scanners and relatively straightforward software. It works pretty well and just needs to be shaken down in all of the possible circumstances it might encounter. It's also unreasonably expensive.

We seem to be converging on an "easiest" solution which uses a mixture of cameras, radars, ultrasound and maybe LIDAR, using deep learning for image processing. That's just one solution, though.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by halomru on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:28AM (#13300538)
>with just two relatively low resolution cameras...

We probably can, but most of us drive with two cameras with approximately 120 megapixels of feature resolution with highly optimized non uniform pixel density and incredible dynamic range. Micromovements allow the software to boost the effective resolution by about a factor of four, to over 400 megapixels. Image stabilization works in multiple layers and executes stabilization movements within 10ms in the fastest layer.

The human eyes and vision system are certainly one of our more impressive parts, and we have a really hard time replicating their performance.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by robotresearcher on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:06AM (#13299182)
Here's the winning car from the last GC:

http://www.tartanracing.org

Lots of LIDARs, lots of cameras.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by toomuchtodo on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:34AM (#13299285)
"Stanley", the VW Touareg that won the 2005 grand challenge, also used LIDAR (but fused with camera imagery). In the event that the fused sensor data reduced confidence, the vehicle would slow and lean more heavily on the LIDAR sensors.

"Additional guidance data was provided by a video camera used to observe driving conditions out to eighty meters (beyond the range of the LIDAR) and to ensure room enough for acceleration."

"Stanley was characterized by a machine learning based approach to obstacle detection. Data from the LIDARs was fused with images from the vision system to perform more distant look-ahead. If a path of drivable terrain could not be detected for at least 40 meters in front of the vehicle, speed was decreased and the LIDARs were used to locate a safe passage."

This computer vision processing was performed with 1.6ghz Pentium M processors 11 years ago. Is it so far fetched Nvidia parallel processing hardware can't do better with CCDs than LIDAR?

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by argonaut on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:41AM (#13299643)
This is a research problem, not a compute problem. Directly trying to replicate what LIDAR gives you (SLAM, a 3d map of your current environment) using just cameras is still unsolved today. And it is an active area of research.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by toomuchtodo on Monday January 02, 2017 @11:31AM (#13302093)
I agree it's a research project. Who better to perform said project than Tesla? They have 100k+ vehicles on the road being trained by drivers at a rate of over 2 million miles per day.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by argonaut on Monday January 02, 2017 @10:50PM (#13306538)
Tesla does not have the world's experts in visual SLAM. Those people are in academia, or at Google/Microsoft.

The 100k car/driver thing is a red herring. Steering angle / brake / acceleration info is not the kind of data you need for this task. Big useless data is still useless data, even if it's big.

The right kind of data, if this is to be treated as an ML problem, is a 3D model of the environment (this would be the label), along with camera data (this would be the data). Ironically you need LIDAR to get those labels. It bears noting that the state of the art in visual SLAM is not ML based (it's really difficult to get the "ML" problem I just described to actually work - and it's not for lack of data, Google probably has petabytes of this data from their cars).

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by greglindahl on Monday January 02, 2017 @11:38PM (#13306764)
I thought that the data Tesla is collecting is things like "places where drivers always steer unexpectedly" or "places where drivers always stop but our system didn't detect a stop sign". Those are labels.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by argonaut on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @02:25PM (#13312180)
Those are not the labels for the problem I was talking about (visual SLAM).

Those are labels for a different problem.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by snovv_crash on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:10AM (#13300473)
No, it is solved and there is commercial software that will do this for you. Look at Pix4D, AgiSoft, DroneDeploy, etc. The problem is that it typically doesn't run in real-time, and scales badly with number of images.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by robotresearcher on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:00PM (#13303449)
So it's not a solved problem then. Apart from realtime there is a robustness problem that the offline reconstruction systems don't suffer from too badly. Missing data and poor reconstructions are inconvenient for an offline system but could be deadly in a car.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by snovv_crash on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @06:18AM (#13308399)
Parent said it is a research problem, not a compute problem. I asserted it is a compute problem because we already have robust 3D reconstruction from cameras, but it doesn't run in real-time. If you can come up with a 500GHz CPU with a GB of cache, the problem is solved. It is a compute problem, that we may be able to bypass with research.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by argonaut on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @02:28PM (#13312210)
1) "Scales badly with the number of images" seems like a research problem to me.

2) In theory almost everything is "just" a compute problem (just enumerate or search over all possibilities - of course this may not finish for millenia). But if Moore's law says the compute is 20 years away, I think it's reasonable to call it a research problem.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by agildehaus on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:31AM (#13299459)
The last Grand Challenge was in 2007. A lot has changed since then. Tesla's prototypes are doing what that car did, and quite a bit more, without any LIDAR.

Not to say LIDAR isn't essential. I think LIDAR will get cheap enough that it'll just be silly not to have it.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by argonaut on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:48AM (#13299666)
Tesla is doing highway driving and some turns without LIDAR. The point of LIDAR is to help you parse a complicated urban scene (and so far what Tesla has are demo videos of urban driving). Of course you don't need LIDAR for the highway.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by sbierwagen on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:49PM (#13299112)
Animats would indeed be a good person to talk to about CV/LIDAR in the DARPA challenge, since he lead a team that entered it.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by datguacdoh on Monday January 02, 2017 @11:58AM (#13302345)
That demonstration video is very deceiving. There are many times where they switch camera angles and the car has driven some distance that isn't shown. They used clever editing to make it feel like it was 100% autopilot but if you know the area (I live nearby) you can see the jump cuts. I'm hopeful they can do full autonomy with their sensor package but I'm still skeptical at this point.
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by wyldfire on Sunday January 01, 2017 @11:59PM (#13299150)
I think the safety standard for autonomous car drivers will be much, much higher than human drivers. So it's not fair to compare with just a stereographic camera pair.

IMO the most successful implementations are ones that can predict accidents that humans couldn't even see taking place (obscured by other cars, etc).

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by toomuchtodo on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:03AM (#13299172)
> IMO the most successful implementations are ones that can predict accidents that humans couldn't even see taking place (obscured by other cars, etc).

Such as Tesla'a forward facing radar, highlighted the other day on HN preventing an additional accident participant by detecting a vehicle slowing down ahead that the driver could not visually detect?

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by dr_ on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:14AM (#13299216)
A Tesla bought today does have the hardware to implement what they call full self driving, once the software is ready and state regulations, if any, are in place.

That being said, i would imagine said hardware would evolve over time with new releases. It would be nice, and probably safer, if cars could actually communicate with each other, rather than have to rely on their own cameras, to determine another vehicles position. Same with traffic lights, road signs, etc.

that's probably a long way off, although i wonder if Teslas have hardware that would allow them to communicate with one another.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by Maxious on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:26AM (#13299439)
> if cars could actually communicate with each other, rather than have to rely on their own cameras, to determine another vehicles position.

This is being tested right now eg. 802.11p/ITS-G5/Vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle-to-everything

A video of some demonstrations by Ford Motors https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PF1a-g9suR8

Tesla might already have the hardware needed; this implementation for Linux uses Qualcomm Atheros AR93xx chipset devices operating in the 5.9 GHz band https://rtime.felk.cvut.cz/publications/public/ieee80211p_li...

(https://events.ccc.de/congress/2015/Fahrplan/system/event_at... outlines the current security model - car manufacturers are a small set of organisations that could act as intermediary Certificate Authorities and manage key exchange so messages via these protocols can be "trusted")

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by dcosson on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:00AM (#13299373)
> if cars could actually communicate with each other, rather than have to rely on their own cameras, to determine another vehicles position.

I wonder how useful it would actually be though. I don't think you'd want to involve such a complex a distributed system in a hard-realtime domain like deciding whether you're about to hit the other vehicle, the CAP theorem seems pretty unavoidable there.

Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by brianwawok on Monday January 02, 2017 @08:23AM (#13300996)
Just think of a few common cases. Sending out a "applying emergency brakes at coords x,y"... You maybe don't drive in a ditch to respond but maybe your AI starts the braking process as it evaluates...
Re:Tesla Rolling Out Autopilot Software Updates to 1000 Cars by sanswork on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:08AM (#13299397)
Probably also not the best to actually trust the data from other sources without verifying it yourself anyhow.