News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Sunday January 01, 2017 @06:58PM (#13298129)
There's a reason the takedown of a good private tracker is seen like the burning of the Library of Alexandria all over again.

It was very sad to see What.CD go down recently. They had every release of every LP, EP and demo, of every obscure artist you could possibly imagine. The curation and amount of content made commercial services like Spotify and TIDAL look barren in comparison. Best of all: there was no DRM on the content and you could freely use your VPN.

I just hope enough libraries survive for the content to last.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by awalton on Monday January 02, 2017 @01:15AM (#13299417)
> There's a reason the takedown of a good private tracker is seen like the burning of the Library of Alexandria all over again.

The irony of course being that we developed the Internet to prevent Single Points of Failure from destroying our American society, yet we're seeing our culture die over and over again to the crumbling of Single Points of Failure.

Maybe at some point we'll start seeing the point of building failure-resilient networks, but as long as there's money to be made in Facebooks and Netflixes and other walled gardens, we're just going to keep seeing these failures wipe us out.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by Spivak on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:26AM (#13299598)
Sure but what made What.CD the gold standard was the control they had over their community to curate and moderate which doesn't seem to have a distributed solution yet. Public torrent sites & trackers are very distributed and failure resistant but they're a cesspool of low quality content.

This isn't to say that you can't find what you're looking for but most of the quality stuff is usually repackaged from other higher quality sites/sources that are single points of failure for their niche of content.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by ue_ on Monday January 02, 2017 @08:49AM (#13301119)
I can't see the problem with having a select group of people maintaining the repository (i.e WCD users) and also distributing the content of the repository on the Internet for all.

As another commenter mentioned, GNU/Linux package management and in fact most free software projects are managed this way.

The only downside would be that maybe some of the information would be infringing copyright, even if it's just the database rather than the music itself.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by thatcat on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:16PM (#13303577)
>maybe some of the (torrent database) information would be infringing copyright.

This isn't likely unless they're hosting the cover images instead of distributing them with the torrents. iirc, wcd used a separate domain to host cover images to be viewed when browsing the site.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by damson on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:22PM (#13305645)
That's exactly the case, what.cd had its own image host (whatimg) for cover art.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by belorn on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:16AM (#13300502)
I would think that signing is a good method to curate and moderate a distributed solution. Looking at debian repositories, they are both trusted, distributed and failure resistant.

People still need a platform to build the community, but that could be built in a separated system from the distribution.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by Fnoord on Monday January 02, 2017 @09:16AM (#13301225)
> I would think that signing is a good method to curate and moderate a distributed solution. Looking at debian repositories, they are both trusted, distributed and failure resistant.

BitTorrent uses cryptography to ensure file integrity. DCPP does too. Even FXP did (although only CRC32 this was reasonable back then).

Debian repositories don't compare to the illegal distribution of quality audio (and video) because Debian repositories are legal to host/spread. Because of this reason they're widely available and therefore the supply meets the demand. Unlike with illegal distribution of quality audio (and video).

The comparison with Library of Alexandria goes moot. During the burning of the Library of Alexandria many works got lost forever. Thanks to the invention of printing in the 15th century this is already more unlikely to happen. Nevermind storage on computers which has seen tremendous progress. One also needs to keep in mind that all the copies people had from the content on What.CD still exists. So it is more akin to a Library of Alexandria being burned down while all the copies are still spread (multiple times!) among large groups of individuals around the globe. I don't think many people on Earth would be able to figure out where those copies are, except maybe the NSA or GCHQ. But it'd cost them a lot of effort which isn't worth the hassle, besides being outside their scope of interest.

This is not to say we're there yet, just that its less dramatic than it seems. The burning of the Library (What.CD) is substantial because it was a meeting place for those interested in the data, akin to the shutting down of Silk Road or Timothy Leary getting busted. However one lost battle doesn't mean the war is lost.

Its still important to improve distribution of data, allow anonymity on the Internet, or the combination of both.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by touristtam on Wednesday January 04, 2017 @12:15PM (#13320039)
2 thoughts there: Convenience trumps pretty much all other rationals in the decision making once a price point is reached. And we are still being feed ADSL instead of SDSL. Meaning that while your ISP and mine are maximizing the bandwidth they can sell, we are just seen as consummers. There might be a shifting point in the future for the consumer to be seen as a potential distributed hosting node. But this will leave the question of who is really owning the connection and therefore who is responsible in front of the law? The current context of internet data flow is very much a grey area.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by erikbye on Monday January 02, 2017 @08:39AM (#13301086)
IPFS
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by Klathmon on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:01PM (#13298142)
why don't these kinds of sites distribute their database in the same way they distribute their content?

At least that way if shit goes south the information is still out there even if the curation and "updates" to it will no longer happen.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by optionalparens on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:08PM (#13298171)
There are peer-to-peer sharing options that have tried to do this (now and previously), but aren't widely adopted in the face of bit torrent.

Most private trackers are using the same pretty dismal PHP bit torrent tracker libraries/servers that work with mysql or sqlite. It would of course be possible to replicate these or do something as simple as cron jobs, rsync, etc., but that's not often the real issue.

The larger issue is the legal aspect. Most of the time a big tracker is taken down, the owners are known to authorities or don't want to risk being known, even by association. As such, continuing the same site, even under different management would put them at risk. If I remember in the case of what.cd and a few others, they put out notices saying they intentionally nuked their databases for this among other reasons.

If for example a big site shuts down and one of the members spins up a new instance, the fear is that the original owners would be liable. It doesn't matter if this holds up or not in court or is even a real thing, merely the threat of it is not worth the trouble to many people. Not many people want to sign up to go to jail or deal with financial threats because of sharing movies or music.

Distributing the database doesn't solve the legal aspect. In fact, distributing the database might be seen as more ammunition to threaten the original site admins as being "enablers." So in theory what you are saying makes sense and would be a good idea, but in the face of reality and human behavior, it is much harder and more than a technical issue.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:13PM (#13298186)
Why not: one crew builds great P2P software, another uses it?

I mean, I do feel like we're ready to start jailing/extrajudicially punishing people just for writing software that the copyright lobby/intelligence community doesn't like, because it makes piracy/privacy more accessible, but it'd be a first for someone not involved in actually commiting piracy to wind up in the sights of the copyright lobby.

In the Netherlands everyone has to pay a premium on CD's and DVD's, "for rightsholders", which goes to some shady copyright organization which distributes part of the money to top-40 artists. I don't think "copyright tax" on all storage media is a much larger step, nor do I think government-mandated DRM is. Not having "the right to tinker" like we do now already comes pretty close.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by optionalparens on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:31PM (#13298260)
Probably not, but IANAL. In the world of big companies and even governments coming after you, it becomes hard to claim innocence when conspiracy charges are levied. Using things that enable further proliferation tend to add to the charges and make the case.

Chinese walls/firewalls don't quite hold up in court as well as one might think. Obviously it can depend on the country and circumstances, but anytime people feel there is a criminal conspiracy at work, they come up you hard. It is also hard to keep such a wall "clean" as all it takes is one person being stupid to establish a link.

Again, it's also about fear and human nature, not reality. I'm sure there are people with great opsec and planning who don't have this problem, but they also don't necessarily attract enough attention to get shut down. Factor in that many admins start a site because of ego, and that doesn't lead to great opsec. Nor do most people want to use software they know nothing about.

I should probably add FWIW, married to a prosecutor who goes after international criminal conspiracies among other things. Not the computer stuff thankfully, but I've seen and heard about what happens when the words criminal conspiracy get thrown about and people with money are involved. Doubly dangerous when extradition treaties exist or the country handling the case is a bigger power like the US.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:04PM (#13298393)
I do feel like it'd be prudent to wait until everyone I love has died, before I even publicly speak about these issues. Power is not something we as a race have learned to tame, and we currently have a bunch of very powerful actors who hate piracy (and free-spirited citizens in general). You can call my fear paranoia, but is it that if you really are constantly being watched by the invisible eyes of powerful and ruthless interest groups and government agencies?

I do wonder how much cooperation there is between the copyright lobby and intelligence agencies. Their interests and arenas are very much alligned.

Chilling effects matter a lot, and that is part of the reason I do choose to speak up, though it gives me more anxiety than I'd like to have. I can't imagine what a hell it must be to run an actual illegal pirate network.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by optionalparens on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:37PM (#13298508)
I don't blame you or think you are paranoid. I don't know as much as I like, but for various reasons ranging from family to work to my childhood, I've seen a fair amount of "stuff" in the world that at the very least makes me both cautious and skeptical.

The average person isn't really going to be targeted for most things though. What is scary sometimes is the recklessness that people exhibit when they do have powerful information about other people. That enables some of the bad actors, whether private citizens, criminal organizations, fraudsters, or otherwise to do bad things with the information. Gathering information is a dangerous thing even if used for noble purposes because it's very hard to guarantee it is used for that.

As far as cooperation between intelligence agencies and copyright lobby, again I can't say. My feeling and first-hand experiences have more been it's an indirect relationship at best. More that lobbies pressure people, who in turn pressure intelligence. That combined with negligence and sloppy information handling and operational security, and sometimes the wrong people are able to see information they shouldn't that was often for other purposes.

I'll never understand what makes corporations and the idea of nations make people act so irrationally and often evil. It's really not that hard in life, don't be an a-hole. If you have to ask yourself if you are doing the right thing, you probably aren't most of the time. Money has just become such a huge part of civilization that it becomes a primary motivator of behaviors for many people, and the results speak for themselves.

I could go on, but I'll leave it at money makes the world go round, and sometimes I feel we've just recreated things like serfdom, monarchy, divine right, and the whole family of awfulness like that in new forms.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by roblabla on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:38PM (#13298292)
This is pretty much what Popcorn Time does right now AFAIK. The development of the client and stuff are done under the "Butter Project" (which is completely legal, distributing only works that are free of copyrights), while popcorn time merely administers servers and replace the logos.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by optionalparens on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:28PM (#13298482)
Yup, plenty of others examples. There's also more sort of "gray" examples of things like streaming sites that just "index" the streams that are on various servers and file sharing sites like openload.

It's always a matter of how much attention you grab and what people you piss off. Things can look like they are fine, legal, and alright, until they aren't. It's hard to know if a strategy works until it doesn't.

Beyond the perception issues I mentioned, all I am saying is that the legal issues tend to be somewhat volatile because what is legally or ethically correct isn't necessarily what happens in reality. Combine that with other motivators like politicians and deep pockets and it gets pretty scary.

I am glad my spouse works in what I would call a more moral side of prosecution that's hard to argue the other way. She can't and I can't say that entirely good things happen in other areas of prosecution like piracy and digital crimes. If someone wants to cause you trouble, they can often find a "way" or at the very least dig and bother enough until they invent something or shake things up to find something. The cost of a legal battle alone sometimes is its own form of extortion and can be a deterrent. Gross behavior, but it happens.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by pervycreeper on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:13PM (#13298430)
I think it boils down to the culture of those kinds of sites, which reportedly encourage an elitist secret club type of mindset over one which encourages preservation or dissemination of information.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by orik on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:51PM (#13298554)
You can try to critique the culture of What.CD but the truth is that WCD did a better job at preserving music than a community with the express purpose of 'preserving or disseminating information' would have done.

The mindset cultivated seeders with the fear of getting kicked out if one was a bad peer / leech; ratios, bounties and freeleech items created a gamification for uploading material and seeding otherwise unpopular items for other users.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by xg15 on Sunday January 01, 2017 @09:06PM (#13298601)
...until it all was gone.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by joeberon on Monday January 02, 2017 @05:43AM (#13300383)
Yeah but now that is all for nothing. They could release the torrent database but they're not gonna are they? There's just too much pride attached to it to let it go.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by legatus on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:18AM (#13300725)
Well, the database contains data about users too... doing so would put users at risk. An interesting concept is ZeroNet [1], which allows entire websites to be shared in a peer to peer way.

[1] https://zeronet.io/

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by pervycreeper on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:42AM (#13299313)
Why can't both those goals be combined?
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by davidgerard on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:52AM (#13300619)
>WCD did a better job at preserving music than a community with the express purpose of 'preserving or disseminating information' would have done.

This appears to be the precise 180 degree opposite of what the case is as at 2 January 2017.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by 1337biz on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:48PM (#13298541)
Interesting topic! People are ptobably also feeling more motivate to contribute in an isolated community than to some greater good perspective.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by biggerfisch on Monday January 02, 2017 @12:35AM (#13299288)
Some of the current sites still up are likely to be exploring their options in that regard. The core problem comes down to the fact that a (potential) compromise (as in w.cd) results in the admins hitting the Big Red Button and nuking everything from orbit.

Additionally, while much metadata was lost in w.cd's demise, a large amount of the files have already been recovered through various replacements.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by voltagex_ on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:51AM (#13299675)
Where did w.cd disperse to?
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:42PM (#13303778)
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by ue_ on Monday January 02, 2017 @08:50AM (#13301121)
Do you have any idea where to? I was going to do the WCD interview a few days before it closed for good, not knowing this would happen.
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:26PM (#13305664)
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Sunday January 01, 2017 @07:02PM (#13298153)
I'm not sure, I've never run such a site myself. Maybe someone behind 7 proxies could explain?

I do think this could be solved, with for instance public-key addressed content (e.g., a DHT where the content is references to files, addressed by pubkey and muteable only to the owner of the corresponding private key). I've been trying to figure out why this isn't done in practice for a while now.

Maybe it's a selection bias, where all dark file distribution networks run that well/securely drop off the map completely?

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by davidgerard on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:51AM (#13300615)
The trouble was that What.CD wasn't a loss for anyone who didn't have the patience to sit through an examination to be allowed to look at the site.

http://rocknerd.co.uk/2016/11/19/what-the-death-of-what-cd-f...

tl;dr the way to preserve culture for all of humanity is to make lots of copies.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:45PM (#13303798)
It's an examination over IRC, so yes, you'd have to have your second laptop on idle next to you for 4 hours, but if you're not staring at the chatroom all the time its not much of a chore.

There also was a site called "What.CD Interview Prep" with all the knowledge you were supposed to have before joining, e.g. about lossy and lossless encoding and "The Golden Rules". I'm sure no one ever had that open on a second computer, or just closed it for a sec when making the screenshot proof.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by davidgerard on Monday January 02, 2017 @06:25PM (#13305358)
I’m hard pressed to see how this isn’t a description of a resource sabotaged by its own snobbery. Completely artificial scarcity is not an effective gain for all of humanity, rather than a vanishingly tiny part of it, and now zero.

You do realise the attitude you're defending is why What.CD has completely failed to preserve culture.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by cryptarch on Saturday January 07, 2017 @12:54PM (#13345483)
While I do agree it would have been nice if they had released a torrent with all torrent files on their site, I also think they did a very good job overall.

Their users might have dispersed, but the content is still out there and the good sharing habits will stick with the ex-members. It has also caused many, many CD's to be ripped, curated and massively distributed to very high standards, for years. The curated metadata and social structure might have been lost, but the content survives.

I think they were mostly sabotaged by lack of anonimization and by their centralized architecture.

Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by webmaven on Monday January 02, 2017 @07:51AM (#13300862)
TL/DR: "Lots Of Copies Keep Stuff Safe."
Re:What Could Have Entered the Public Domain on January 1, 2017 by aluhut on Sunday January 01, 2017 @08:17PM (#13298444)
Those are the reasons why we need not-sharing illegal libraries. For everything. For when the times get better...or worse...