News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:18PM (#13291942)
> terrible public schools

There are affordable parts of Long Island and Connecticut with great public public schools less than an hour from Manhattan by train.

We've grown accustomed to overporting our post-war suburban archetype of what a "middle class" family "deserves," i.e. lots of bedrooms, garages and lawn space, while diminishing previously (and still!) common practices like having roommates when young, not owning a car, et cetera.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by schoolsman on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:38PM (#13292064)
> There are affordable parts of Long Island and Connecticut with great public public schools less than an hour from Manhattan by train.

Nonsense. I'm a New Yorker. You literally CAN'T get to DOWNTOWN Manhattan from any part of Connecticut in under an hour. The first metro-north stop in CT (Greenwich, which, BTW, is NOT affordable to live near) is over 40 minutes from Grand Central at the best of times. And then you have to change to the subway to get downtown. Nuh-uh. An hour each way is not happening.

I'm not sure what your point was about suburban deserts (in the sense of things deserved,) but the point of the article is that even with things like not owning a car priced in, housing (in cities with jobs) is still unobtanium for people in the hole between section 8 and tech salaries, who didn't already buy their homes when they were cheaper. Editorializing a bit, this sucks in the long-term. The upper east side of manhattan west of park, which was expensive before "gentrification" was a word, shows what this leads to: a limestone-clad desert made of vertical money and not much else.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:57PM (#13292171)
> You literally CAN'T get to DOWNTOWN Manhattan from any part of Connecticut in under an hour

I live in Midtown. This time of year, I can't get downtown in less than an hour :).

It's reasonable for a productive person to demand any two of: space, a great location and disposable income.

My household of two chooses to enjoy our neck of Manhattan. We make do with like 400 square feet. If we had kids we would need to live in a city we get to enjoy less frequently or commute from the suburbs. Neither is particularly appealing to me, but I've heard kids are nice.

> "gentrification"...leads to a limestone-clad desert made of vertical money and not much else

Gentrification can lead to density in addition to urban deserts. Ironically, activists seem to prefer restricting housing supply. That means the latter.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by mildbow on Saturday December 31, 2016 @05:54PM (#13293650)
Trying not to be uncharitable here, but, if you live in Midtown, then why are you making assertions about Connecticut?

Apparently you know your comment wasn't too truthful which is why you backed off with "I live in Midtown [..even so..] I can't get downtown in less than an hour". So, what exactly was the point of your comment?

Also note: household of 2 is not a household when talking about middle-class income. Why? Well, household of 2 adults is basically the best case scenario financially (both have jobs without additional dependents).

As a anecdote/data point: even making >300+k with both parents working still is a drag in NYC when you have 2 kids, regardless of what BS you hear online.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @06:13PM (#13293709)
> if you live in Midtown, then why are you making assertions about Connecticut?

I've lived in Stamford. I would not want to live there again. Between ample space, proximity and disposable cash, I chose the latter two. If I wanted more space, Connecticut offers a fair deal for saving money or being close to the train station.

> you know your comment wasn't too truthful

Not sure why you went straight for the deep end. It's the holidays. I'm budgeting 45 minutes to the Upper West Side. The smiley implied facetiousness.

It's 50 minutes from Grand Central to Stamford [1]. That's comparable to the average American's 25-minute commute [2]. My core and recurring point is simply that cities are defined by density. If you want lots of space, you're fighting the current.

[1] http://as0.mta.info/mnr/schedules/sched_form.cfm

[2] http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/03/05/america...

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by mildbow on Saturday December 31, 2016 @06:18PM (#13293730)
tbh, I went for the "deep end" because your formula that one needs to "choose 2" as a fact of life is weird to me.

Your point of "choose 2" isn't anything more than a compromise you've made. That is, not something that is "correct" but a compromise you've settled on. I'm happy for you to settle on that as a baseline for your life, but it irks me to hear you spout it as a "truth".

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @06:33PM (#13293766)
> your formula...as a fact of life is weird to me

Cities are defined by density. What makes them valuable is density. Density is people per unit of space. You can do some things going vertically, but there are costs and limits associated with that, both practical and political.

Lots of people in high density means low average space per person. If you want more space it will be expensive and eat into your cash. If you want to keep that cash, you don't have options in a high-density city.

Yes, you can have all three with lots of cash. But you can't have a city with most having lots of space, because that means they live in low density and are no longer in a city.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @02:27PM (#13292664)
>We've grown accustomed to overporting our post-war suburban archetype of what a "middle class" family "deserves," i.e. lots of bedrooms, garages and lawn space, while diminishing previously (and still!) common practices like having roommates when young, not owning a car, et cetera.

"People's lives are too good, we need to make them worse."

What's your angle? What do you gain from advocating against mobility and personal space? Are you upset because you didn't have these things, and don't want "undeserving" people to have them? Or do you just want us all to live in worse conditions for the fun of it? I genuinely can't understand what moves someone to push for "people should not have their own bedrooms or time-efficient commutes."

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @03:19PM (#13292932)
> What do you gain from advocating against mobility and personal space?

What works in the suburbs isn't sustainable in cities. Suburbia is built for personal spaces. It's terrible, however, at supporting the rich social fabrics densely-packed humans spontaneously weave. (There's also the problems of commute and it's environmental impact.)

City-centre richness is a direct product of density. If everyone gets large, personal spaces you're back to suburbia and all its disadvantages.

Living in a city means accepting less personal space in exchange for the benefits of density. The only alternative is to have fewer people with more personal space, which means rationing or auctioning off that limited housing as well as a less "city-like" urban core.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @03:32PM (#13292997)
>If everyone gets large, personal spaces you're back to suburbia and all it's disadvantages.

This is true on the x-y plane but not the z-axis. We can have substantially more sqft available per sqft desired in the same land footprint by building up, which is currently heavily regulated or outright illegal.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @03:49PM (#13293071)
I support more density, but the relationship between density and personal space isn't side-stepped by building up. You're just adding a vertical commute component.

It's better than yards and boulevards, but a building of three-bedroom apartments to the edge of space will have a different human dynamic from one with mostly one-bedrooms.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @04:01PM (#13293122)
Well first, a 1-bedroom is the most expensive way to live, at the rate we're going we'll have 3-bedroom apartments with 3 families per bedroom instead of 3 bedrooms per family :). Back to the Industrial Revolution tenements.

You can get your human dynamic just fine on sidewalks, cafes, parks, etc. It doesn't need to be in-building. And even ~70 stories by elevator is still only a few minutes, nothing like the hour-plus train rides middle-class people in cities currently need to endure.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @04:08PM (#13293161)
> You can get your human dynamic just fine on sidewalks, cafes, parks, etc.

More density means fewer [EDIT: more] people within walking distance of each café, park and restaurant. That, in turn, affects how many of them there are and how eclectic they can be.

Density is people over space. If you give each person more space, you reduce density. This can't be avoided.

> nothing like the hour-plus train rides middle-class people in cities currently need to endure

They don't need to endure it. Stamford, CT and Rochester or Port Jefferson, NY are nice cities with middling densities.

But many people don't want that. They want restaurants and nightclubs and parks with rotating art installations that only emerge and make sense when you pack people together.

Sure, you can put one or two large units in the mix without screwing things up. But not a lot, not for everyone. Else you end up with urban deserts.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @04:29PM (#13293267)
>Some people don't want that--they want the restaurants and nightclubs and parks with rotating art installations that only emerge and make sense when you pack people together.

You really think a neighborhood of 70-story buildings can sustain these things as long as people share bedrooms, but can't the instant that children and young adults have their own doors to close?

>More density means fewer people within walking distance of each café, park and restaurant.

Vertical distance costs almost nothing in terms of time, given modern elevators and scheduling. I'll skip the cafe because it's a 40 minute walk instead of 10. You'd really skip the cafe because it's 20 floors down instead of 5? That's, like, one minute on a really bad day.

>If you give each person more space, you reduce density.

Well sure, but the advantages of density really come from compactness in time/ease of transportation rather than space. It doesn't matter that the restaurant is far away from its customers on the vertical axis, because elevators are fast.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @05:14PM (#13293485)
Manhattan contained 854,000 housing units in 2014 [1] and 1.6 million residents between 2010 [2] and 2013 [3]. The average Manhattan unit has 1.2 to 1.3 bedrooms [4]. (For Core Manhattan, that average falls to 1.0 to 1.2.) So 1 to 1.1 million bedrooms.

If you mandated one bedroom per person you'd have to expel 31 to 38% of the population or increase the number of bedrooms by 45 to 60%.

Manhattan's 33.6 square miles [5] are populated with 70,826 people per square mile. If we go the culling-people route, that drops to 44,000 to 49,000 people per square mile. That's the population density of West New York, in New Jersey [6]. Manhattan and West New York are radically different places.

If we go the building-units route, consider that Manhattan gained 13,189 units between 2011 and 2014, i.e. 4,400 a year [1; Table 2]. To build the 500,000 to 600,000 bedrooms we need you'd need to make 415,000 to 500,000 units, i.e. a century of construction. (If you built only three bedrooms, you'd cut that time down to 167,000 to 200,000 units, i.e. a mere 38 to 45 years.) To build them in 20 years, you'd need to increase construction by 4.7 to 5.7x (90% to 2.3x if only 3BR), and that's ignoring any additional infrastructure that new population may need as well as population growth.

Cities are a product of density. If you try to make a city with suburban-sized personal spaces, you end up with neither city nor suburbia. Building up is better than sideways, always, but we shouldn't delude ourselves regarding realistic sets of trade-offs.

[1] https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/hpd/downloads/pdf/2014-HVS-initi... Page 1

[2] http://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/data-maps/n... Table 1

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Manhattan

[4] http://furmancenter.org/files/FurmanCenter_FactBrief_RentSta... Table F

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_New_York,_New_Jersey

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @05:36PM (#13293583)
43% of the New York metro area is married, presumably many more are cohabiting. So, if we relax that constraint to "don't have to share a bedroom except with a romantic partner" then we are potentially already there.

Of course, the proportion of married couples could be much lower in Manhattan, and it's not necessarily the same 43%, but you get the idea.

More to the point I'm very interested what tradeoffs you think are worth literally never having the chance to be alone in a room. Without a shadow of a doubt I'd kill myself, and I'd never dream of brining a child into that miserable existence.

[0] https://censusreporter.org/profiles/16000US3651000-new-york-...

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 31, 2016 @05:56PM (#13293658)
> if we relax that constraint to "don't have to share a bedroom except with a romantic partner" then we are potentially already there

50% of the Manhattan population lives alone, the same as the fraction that has never married [1]. So yes, what you outlined is approximately what's going on. (Just 12% of New Yorkers in rent-regulated apartments had more than 1 person per room; 4.4% more than 1.5 [2].)

The status quo isn't crowded per se. It's just crowded relative to suburbia. The point of my illustration was that small tweaks to density, e.g. one instead of one and a half bedrooms per person, quickly spiral at the scales and within the constraints of a city.

[1] http://nypost.com/2010/01/05/all-the-single-people-in-manhat...

[2] https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/hpd/downloads/pdf/2014-HVS-initi... Table 19

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by ghaff on Saturday December 31, 2016 @04:19PM (#13293212)
I think you meant more people within walking distance.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by wcummings on Saturday December 31, 2016 @05:23PM (#13293531)
Not worse, just different. Times change. Maybe the lifestyle people expect and idralize isn't sustainable.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by closeparen on Saturday December 31, 2016 @08:39PM (#13294241)
Being unable to afford a room to yourself isn't "just different." The ability to be alone when needed is huge.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by gaius on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:29PM (#13292006)
Right. People expect to skip straight from 22 or even 18 to a late-20s or early-30s level of "stuff" and general lifestyle, without paying their dues in the middle. It's called a "property ladder" for a reason.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by rdlecler1 on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:53PM (#13292143)
It's less of a ladder than a Ponzi scheme. In SF housing prices have grown at a compound growth rate of 6% for over 50 years. Older generation squats on property paid for by debt, low taxes, and then retires at 60 -- all paid for by a younger generation that doesn't have jobs and can't afford housing.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by shostack on Saturday December 31, 2016 @02:18PM (#13292616)
Don't forget that Prop 13 disproportionately favors buyers who bought closer to when it was rolled out. Their rates were locked in a long time ago. I'm not sure how repeatable this will be for new buyers.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by dragontamer on Saturday December 31, 2016 @01:23PM (#13292318)
> In SF housing prices have grown at a compound growth rate of 6% for over 50 years.

When a good chunk of those years had interest rates in the 10%+ range, and when the years that were lower than 10% ended with "The Housing Bubble Pop" and "Great Recession", that 6% compounded growth is actually kinda awful.

In any case, compound growth is the center of most economies. Being the owner of things entitles you to profits, be it in stocks, bonds, or real estate.

The "buying on debt" depends on the rate that you got in at. If you're complaining that people in the 1970s were able to get 15% mortgages to earn lol 6% on Real Estate, then I don't think you fully appreciate the history of Stagflation and the 80s bond market.

---------

All in all, housing prices have rose because interest rates have fallen. More people can afford a house when mortgages are at 4% instead of at 15%, and the price of homes go up to compensate.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by rdlecler1 on Saturday December 31, 2016 @03:04PM (#13292875)
Housing is only a good financial investment if supply outstrips demand. The high cost of housing is less a function of low interest rates than zoning laws that restrict new development.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by shostack on Saturday December 31, 2016 @02:19PM (#13292621)
Surely refinancing impacts this equation some though, right?
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by dragontamer on Sunday January 01, 2017 @12:51PM (#13296508)
Yeah, go spend 3% of the loan amount to purchase a new 30-year loan, instead of paying off the house you already have... stay on debt perpetually.

Unless rates drop dramatically in a short-period of time (like in 2012), refinancing opportunities are rare. From the 1980s, you wouldn't have had a refinance opportunity until the mid 90s.

Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by albedoa on Saturday December 31, 2016 @01:12PM (#13292261)
This is either some thinly veiled Millennial shaming or just pure ignorance. After you read the other replies to your comment, read this one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13292046
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by wavefunction on Saturday December 31, 2016 @12:41PM (#13292077)
Those 'entry-level' houses are being bought up by idle capital and rented on AirBnB.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by stale2002 on Saturday December 31, 2016 @01:22PM (#13292309)
The entry level houses aren't even being built in the first place.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by alistairSH on Saturday December 31, 2016 @03:47PM (#13293062)
That's true in my area. While there is plenty of construction, the land is too valuable for entry-level homes. If it's zoned for SFHs, the market will tolerate a 3000sqft+ mini-mansion with a high level of finish. If it's zoned for THs, they'll be 4 stories with an elevator. Condo development caters more to rich retirees than young professionals. The underground parking at the nearest high-rise is full of $100 cars.
Re:The Middle Class Can't Afford to Live in Cities Anymore by nommm-nommm on Saturday December 31, 2016 @07:06PM (#13293921)
What are the affordable parts of Long Island or Connecticut that are affordable and close to Manhattan? The parts of Connecticut that are suburbs close to NYC are known for being where the rich people live. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_Coast_(Connecticut)