News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by anexprogrammer on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @08:14PM (#13267712)
That's sensible. What isn't is the often vast oversize of Amazon packaging. Like sending one hard drive in a 2cu ft box with lots of packaging. There's now lots of scope for the item to move around so the single item inevitably ends up in a corner against the outer box.

Amazon never seem to actually bubble wrap anything any more - which has led to damage more than once. Neither the string of air pockets, as in the article, or paper is as effective as they rarely use enough to prevent movement.

Here in the UK Amazon seems to have switched solely to paper inner packaging. Environmentally I prefer this.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by massysett on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @08:41PM (#13267822)
Amazon ships a huge box, then loads it halfway with paper or air bubbles. Everything shifts around, so it protects nothing in transit. They often ship non-delicate items like clothes in cardboard boxes, where plastic bags would be less wasteful and more protective. Overall, the result of their shipping is that I spend a lot of time deflating plastic, breaking down boxes, and moving lots of garbage to my garage and, subsequently, the curb. Then a truck hauls it some more. All for packaging that ultimately protected paper towels, or that was so loose that the box rattled anyway. It's worse than worthless--it destroys value, takes time, is inconvenient, and hurts the environment, all for no useful result at all.

And Amazon does not seem to care. It is so bad that I have shifted purchases offline to Costco in part so I don't have to deal with all this shipping waste. Costco doesn't even give me a bag.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by function_seven on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:54AM (#13268726)
I recently ordered this decal[1]. It came in this box[2].

If you don’t want to visit the links below, the sticker is 4 inches square, and the box is 7” x 5” x 10”. Why a cardboard mailer wasn’t enough, I don’t know. At least the seven air pouches included with it protected it from high G forces...

1. http://a.co/ew4OGOB 2. http://imgur.com/qCsvJu7

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by Godel_unicode on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:07AM (#13268542)
> And Amazon does not seem to care.

This might be of interest to you; send your gently used stuff to Goodwill, in Amazon boxes, for free.

https://www.givebackbox.com

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by huac on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @09:48PM (#13268040)
Amazon owns East Dane/ShopBop, clothing sites which do always use plastic bags. I guess for mainline Amazon they don't care enough about to differentiate what they ship products in.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by Laforet on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:21AM (#13268808)
Boxes are easier to stack and move especially if you are handling Amazon volumes of goods. Quite often the amount of items that can be carried by a truck or plane is limited by their weight not size, so it may not be as wasteful as it seems.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by gumby on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @09:52PM (#13268054)
> Here in the UK Amazon seems to have switched solely to paper inner packaging. Environmentally I prefer this.

It's not clear to me you should (perhaps you should, the balance simply isn't clear to me).

A plastic air cushion weighs almost nothing, so shipping it to the merchant and then to you uses almost no fuel.

It is rarely recycled but instead become sequestered carbon in a landfill. For me, they are convenient to recycle in Palo Alto but this article says, to my surprise, that that's uncommon. I'm not sure of the carbon impact of recycling PE.

While paper uses a lot of water and chemicals to make, and involves cutting down trees. It's also very heavy so costly in terms of fuel to transport and recycle.

Aesthetically, I agree that paper is much nicer.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by hueving on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:08AM (#13268551)
>and involves cutting down trees

Which they plant more of. Using this as an argument against paper is silly because it only applies to unsustainable approaches to paper. If we judged every process by the worst way to do it, then no process would be acceptable.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by gumby on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:58AM (#13268922)
I'm not sure what your point is here.

The whole point of recycling paper is to avoid cutting down trees (and as a minor secondary point reduce landfill, though most paper is compostable). Paper recycling is quite energy and chemical intensive when compared to virgin paper production. If you want to talk about "sustainable" and consider planting trees to be fine, then you don't want to recycle.

I don't consider cutting down trees and replanting them that great, frankly. You take a large tree with a large surface area that's transpiring lots of carbon and replace it with a sapling with a small surface area. Yes that sapling is, over time, turning carbon into tree trunk, but that time scale for that is decades while the paper releases carbon immediately through its production and transport and then continues to do so over decades as it decomposes.

This calculus can be improved by making the paper out of something with a better yield and shorter growth time (hemp is claimed to be such but I have no idea if that's true) and by using non-fossil fuel. But you have to look at the chemistry required as well...and in any case paper is heavy (a box of paper is basically a box of wood) which is inherently fuel intensive.

Plastic film (and plastic toys) are sequestered if you can stick them in landfills. Of course the best carbon sequestration will be to leave the oil in the ground...not yet an option in 2017.

But the best lifecycle analysis has to be done on base of most accurate costs possible, not emotion. Paper is pretty shitty.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by morsch on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:05AM (#13269146)
Conventional wisdom is that recycled paper uses less resources than new paper.

https://archive.epa.gov/wastes/conserve/materials/paper/web/...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_recycling

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by gumby on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @09:24AM (#13270627)
The box on the first link summarizes the benefits pretty well, thanks.

Still, I am not yet convinced vs the lifetime oil consumption & carbon release of paper packaging vs plastic.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by juhanima on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @11:06AM (#13271365)

  You take a large tree with a large surface area that's transpiring lots of carbon and replace it with a sapling with a small surface area. Yes that sapling is, over time, turning carbon into tree trunk, but that time scale for that is decades
Actually the growth peaks in a young forest as soon as there is at least one leaf or needle on most possible paths of a sunray. This is called canopy closure, and as soon as it has been achieved the growth starts to decline. This has been studied extensively, here is one example:

https://www.nrs.fs.fed.us/pubs/2397

The reason in a nutshell is that when trees start to compete on the available sunlight by out-growing and overshadowing each other, they need to work harder to pull water up to the top where most of the photosynthesis happens. The leaves or needles in the shadow produce almost nothing but still consume resources for respiration.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by anexprogrammer on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:25AM (#13268830)
You may be right. I don't have answers. I'm not sure anyone does. I've often wished it were easier to see all the externalities and environmental issues in our stuff. So I can make decisions with my eyes open. I think it's likely we're making many poor choices for the right reasons at the moment.

I'd be surprised if unbleached brown paper, screwed up as padding, came out worse environmentally than oil derived plastic. It's probably polythene or variant which doesn't really biodegrade and lasts for centuries. Or leaches chemicals or ends up in the ocean and photodegrades to little bits.

How do we evaluate 1,000 year lifespan vs months for impact? Does that change if we consider it ending up inside wildlife or the ocean foodchain?

Here in my part of the UK at least it's essentially non-recyclable.

I think I'd like to use less, but that's very much an instinctive view. I'd rather corn starch replacements for much packing as it better suits a one time temporary use.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by gumby on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:47AM (#13268898)
> I'd be surprised if unbleached brown paper, screwed up as padding, came out worse environmentally than oil derived plastic.

I would not be surprised; the production even of unbleached Kraft paper is quite energy intensive and environmentally bad (look up "black liquor" for example). Oil derived plastics (not very nice either by any stretch of the imagination) appear to use less energy to produce and of course much much less to transport.

> It's probably polythene or variant which doesn't really biodegrade and lasts for centuries. Or leaches chemicals or ends up in the ocean and photodegrades to little bits.

PE doesn't really biodegrade in any meaningful sense of the word. But if stuck in the ground it doesn't release any more carbon into the atmosphere, unlike decaying organic matter. Typical PE film doesn't contain interesting plasticisers so there's nothing to leach out.

The nasty end result of PE film is when it flies about and gets eaten by animals. That's why plastic bags are so horrible. I don't know if these air bags suffer the same fate; I suspect they do. That's bad.

But you said "envoronmentally" not just waste stream: when I look at the total life cycle it's not clear to me that paper is better.

Note that if oil were only involved as feedstock (so both products were produced with only wind or solar electricity) then the calculus could be different.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by anexprogrammer on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @03:30AM (#13269258)
Interesting. I wasn't aware there was quite so much liquor (by weight) created from paper production. It does seem like they get most of their energy from it now they don't just dump it in rivers.

Recycled changes the numbers too if you don't need to bleach it back to white. Though you've a load of ink and finishers to deal with. At least paper is regularly recycled.

So I think we're in agreement that we don't know!

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by GFischer on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:05PM (#13272294)
Actually, "black liquor" is usually burned, and some pulp mills are even energy-positive. The main problem is not energy, it's pollution (a huge source of controversy here in Uruguay, we have several huge pulp mills).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_liquor

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UPM_(company)#Uruguay :

"provides CO2-neutral biomass-based electricity "

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by douche on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:12PM (#13272346)
Some mills will even produce paper at a loss, in order to produce black liquor to make power from. Especially when there are "green" power subsidies involved.

It's kind of insane, but there was a mill near where I grew up that was doing exactly this a few years ago.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by gm-conspiracy on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @08:45AM (#13270375)
I would like to see the numbers (dollars and calories) on what it costs to recycle these materials, including transport and collection costs.

It appears the trend is to externalize the sorting of materials, as this appears to be the most expensive part.

Are there dedicated paid human sorters? Would people volunteer to help in such a way?

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by kalleboo on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @10:54PM (#13268313)
Here in Japan the packaging I see most from Amazon is where they strap the item down with a strong plastic wrap to a thick piece of cardboard that's glued to the bottom of the box. This keeps it centered and they don't need any filler at all.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by dpark on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @11:51PM (#13268474)
I see that occasionally in the US (except not glued down) but mostly for things that don't have their own display boxes like books, sometimes electronics or DVDs. Since it's not glued, they still rely on air bags to fill the space.

You probably want something to fill the space. Empty boxes are easy to unintentionally crush, exposing the contents to damage, weather, and loss.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by flavor8 on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @06:39AM (#13269901)
Paper or air cushions aren't going to make a substantial difference to whether a box is crushed.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by dpark on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @09:53AM (#13270797)
They actually do. If you fill the space, it's much harder to crush the box, because you not only have to exert enough force to break down the cardboard but enough force to pop the air bags inside. The air bags especially add a lot of support in the very center, where the tape is actually taking most of the force. You can test this yourself. Get a couple of identical shipping boxes, fill one with air bags and the other with nothing, tape them up identically. Start stacking 10 pound weight plates on top and watch which one crushes first.

Paper will probably add less support unless it's really packed, but it will still add some.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by uxp on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @11:50PM (#13268473)
I've seen this packaging before. Notably, Apple uses this design when shipping iPhones. Overall, however, it doesn't seem to be very common in the States.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by ethbro on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @11:49PM (#13268468)
Curious question: what condition due the boxes typically arrive in? Are punctures and crushed boxes common or rare?

It definitely seems like a better method, but I'm curious if the shipping handling is different there.

(For reference, in the SE US I'd say about 1:15 Amazon boxes arrives with some kind of damage. 1:40 with worrisome damage)

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by kalleboo on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:41AM (#13268684)
I guess it may only be workable in Japan - the delivery companies here are exceptionally good. I've never received a package in anything other than 100% perfect condition. I used to subscribe to a monthly beer club that would send 5 glass bottles of beer though the post office's "5-7℃ chilled delivery" service and they were barely packed at all, no issues.

That said I used to often have CDs and DVDs delivered from Amazon.jp to Sweden when I lived there that were packed the same way and they arrived safely, but CDs and DVDs are probably the easiest thing to ship.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by cyberferret on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:29AM (#13268646)
I had to go into the warehouse of a local shipping company the other day to identify and pick up an oversized package, and I couldn't believe how brutal the conveyor systems were. In the few minutes i was there, i saw a couple of boxes fall of a belt, and one particular box caught in a junction of a couple of belts with every other box coming through bashing against it, and no one treating any of these occurrences as a problematic issue.

I can see now how a majority of the parcels may get through ok, but the few that end up caught or trapped will end up in very poor condition.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by lucaspiller on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:17AM (#13268798)
I'm in the UK, and basically every package I get has some sort of minor damage. Squashed corners, punched sides, etc. I had a box that looked like somebody had ripped it open the other day. The inner manufacturers box was fine though (it had paper packaging).
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by mirimir on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @10:54PM (#13268316)
Yes, Amazon seems to have no clue about shipping HDDs. Especially OEM HDDs. They have come loose, in a huge box, in just thin plastic "cases", embedded in air pockets. Which had been pounded flat in transit. New Egg, in contrast, shipped HDDs with molded cardboard padding (as I recall).
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by colejohnson66 on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:08AM (#13268549)
I've rarely buy from NewEgg, so I don't know how their return policy works, but for Amazon, if I ordered a hard drive and it was DOA, I tell them and they send me a new one before I even ship the first one back. No RMA numbers, no warranty problems, no "it was fine when it shipped, so that's UPS' fault". A simple "defective or doesn't work" and a new one is shipped that day.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by shiven on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @12:19AM (#13268600)
This, this and so much this. This is why the majority of my electronics and parts come from Amazon. All other vendors are a morass of justificational cowdung compared to Amazon.

Dear vendor: You can take your RMAs, your restocking fees and your lame-ass excuses for shirking responsibility and shove it where the sun don't shine. Because, Amazon.

Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by mirimir on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @02:51AM (#13269093)
Sure, Amazon does make returns effortless. But there are two complications. First, DOA is not really a problem. Second, it seems that Amazon nukes accounts that return too much stuff. Or so I've read. So if you order many HDDs from Amazon, you're faced with many decisions about borderline poor packaging.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by colejohnson66 on Friday December 30, 2016 @02:33PM (#13286704)
Sure their packaging could be better, but in my anecdotal evidence, it's generally enough. I've order dozens of "fragile" items from Amazon, including two hard drives and a graphics card, and none of them were DOA or showed any signs of damage. Regarding them nuking accounts, if you're returning so much that they nuke you, you're probably return an obscene amount.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by lucaspiller on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:12AM (#13268783)
I'm in the UK, and over the past few months I've received Amazon packages with paper, air cushions and bubble wrap (glass tea pot) - I assume it depends on what you order.
Re:About Those Air Cushions in Amazon Packages by camiller on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @10:12AM (#13270948)
vast oversize? Like this: https://goo.gl/photos/qCcNFNBvp7RmXh1Q6

Sorry for the poor quality. Box is roughly 24" x 18" x 6" containing one approximately 13 inch long kitchen utensil (a silicon whisk) and 7-8 useless air cushions.