Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by binarymax on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @07:00PM
(#13267373)
Maybe I'm blind, but I didn't know Tarkin was CGI until someone told me several days after I'd seen the film.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by melling on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @07:40PM
(#13267553)
Most of the people here have convinced themselves that they could tell and it was awful. However, I bet if there was some sort of scientific comparison, a lot fewer people would guess right.
Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by basch on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @08:35PM
(#13267794)
I am willing to bet you would get different results if you broke the people up into groups of people who watch eyes and people who read lips. I think the eyes were way more convincing than the lips. People who lip read could tell something was off. I also wonder if it would work better if they superimposed human lips onto the cgi face.
Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by cairo_x on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @08:10PM
(#13267697)
Perhaps more interesting are the people who can't understand that their own perceptual blind-spots are not universal standards. This is especially interesting in the social realm, but I think what makes this example so interesting is it may fall somewhere in between (physical and social.)
Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by sssilver on Tuesday December 27, 2016 @09:03PM
(#13267897)
My wife has never seen the original trilogy, and she exclaimed "Is he CG??" 200ms after grand moff's face was on the screen.
Come on guys, both characters were deep in the uncanny valley.
Re:How ‘Rogue One’ Brought Back Familiar Faces
by pkroll on Wednesday December 28, 2016 @01:25AM
(#13268831)
That may well be true... but the uncanny valley isn't the same for everyone. Tarkin looked great to me. For the two seconds she's on screen, Leia looked fine, if oddly happy given the situation. I'm guessing there's a LOT of variance between people's perception of the uncanny valley.