News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by woodruffw on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:18AM (#13253204)
I'm not sure why you were downvoted here -- the mind-body problem isn't nearly as trivial as this article makes it sound.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by dang on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:26AM (#13253224)
I don't think the article makes the problem sound trivial. The title does, because it's the usual baitiness. We replaced it with a primary phrase from the text itself.
Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by inlikelitude on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:55AM (#13253289)
You lost the essence of the article by changing the title to a trite observation. The point the author is (presumably) making is a bit outrageous: that you not live just in your own brain but in the brain of the others you're related to.

I say presumably because I haven't read Siegel's book, but am extrapolating from the same thread which was woven by Hofstadter in "I am a Strange Loop". A more popular yet similar exposition of this idea is the word Ubuntu, which you can roughly grasp using the aphorism "A person is a person through other people".

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by woodruffw on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:39AM (#13253249)
The article title definitely colored my perception, thanks for replacing it.

That being said, there are parts of this article that come across as trivializing the issue:

> Mental life for an anthropologist or sociologist is profoundly social. Your thoughts, feelings, memories, attention, what you experience in this subjective world is part of mind.

Neither monists nor dualists would dispute this, but the article makes it sound like it's a sole necessary result of the dualist view. I guess I'm not being a charitable reader, but this does a disservice to both sides (and to Siegel, whose actual claim is much more nuanced than the article makes it out to be).

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by edblarney on Sunday December 25, 2016 @02:08AM (#13253318)
"mind-body problem" is indeed not trivial.

But the 'mind' does not have a location, it does not make sense describe it as 'in your head' or 'in your body' or anywhere else.

Your brain has matter/energy. It has a location.

Your mind has neither, it's a abstraction. It has no location.

If it did, you'd be able to say where it was without fuss.

You'd have to get into fancier metaphysics (i.e. non-materialist) to go too far beyond that.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by titzer on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:36PM (#13254961)
Not sure if you're positing dualism or just being cautious.

Thought exercise: how many lightyears wide would you have to draw a box that contains all the physical processes necessary to simulate your brain (and the experience your brain is having right now)? Any answer in the form of a number implies that you don't really believe in dualism.

One could do the same with other "abstractions" (quoting just because of the vagueness of the term in comments sections on hackernews). What about the operating system in your computer? Where is "Windows" or "Linux"? It's a lot of different pages of code and data in memory, but pages are just collections of cache lines and memory activation lines and disk sectors...it's hard to pin down what is "operating system" and what is not "operating system". But even so, one can easily draw a box around your physical computer and say that your operating system definitely _is_ in there.

Why should your mind be any different? It is just the software of your brain. It inhabits time and space just as anything else does.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by edblarney on Sunday December 25, 2016 @01:53PM (#13255023)
I'm not hinting at dualism, but I accept someone might infer that.

"how many lightyears wide would you have to draw a box that contains all the physical processes necessary to simulate your brain "

Well - if you want to map physical processes to the locations of their abstractions, you could say 'the mind is in the brain'.

But if you posit your mind and brain are different things (and I think it's pragmatic to do so), then the mind does not have a location.

It doesn't matter 'what particles are where'.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by armitron on Monday December 26, 2016 @02:11PM (#13259369)
The brain gives rise to the mind, in the same way that the physical computer, in operation, gives rise to abstract computational processes. Could you pinpoint these processes exactly in space/time? No. You can pause the computer and _inspect the state of the system_, but this not the same as pinpointing the _process itself_. The process does not exist inside the debugger.

Yet you can not say that these processes do not exist or that they don't have an (abstract) location. Assuming a non-distributed model, if you kill the physical computer, you also kill whatever emergent properties it has. The same is true for brain and mind.

Re:Mind as an emergent self-organizing process by titzer on Sunday December 25, 2016 @08:36PM (#13256419)
I don't think it follows from "the mind and brain are separate things" that the mind does not have a location.