Also, anything more than a basic grocer would still want real people to help people with purchasing etc.
I mean, this is a great example against your point (imo). Those self checkout stands, sure they do employ a staffer to monitor, but each of those stands is basically a line that doesn't have to be employed by a dedicated staffer.
They managed to potentially drastically reduce the number of required staffers via self checkouts. I say potentially, because 1 self checkout doesn't inherently equal one checkout clerk, but you get where i'm going with this.
If my safeway can fire the 6 clerks i regularly see staffing the checkout lines, and hire 1 to monitor.. that's still a drastic layoff.
And what about all the manual labor involved? I'm sure it won't be all robots stocking shelves, so mostly stockers can remain employed for the time being, but i'm sure at least a few employees who specialize in managing stock will be laid off as well.
Just because it's not 100% layoff doesn't mean it's any less serious, imo. We're slowly decreasing the available job market simply put. Where are these people going to go?
If we get rid of all the manual labor that humans do, why wouldn't we move the advice-givers to remote offices and improve their utilization? A call center to tell you where the milk is or which wine goes with your recipe might sound bad, but consider that you'd never wait another second to talk to a clerk, and everything would get even cheaper as more and more of the basic questions for the call center get moved onto intelligent bots.
Secondly, once people get used to shopping at stores where they don't have to line up to pay, the new experience will become expected by consumers.
So there is a double effect whereby stores who adopt the new tech will save money on payroll, and stores that don't will lose some business.
Why? They were being targeted to test stolen credit cards and it was costing the company a pretty penny having to deal with all those fraud checks/etc.
Not a detraction from your point - i just found it interesting. "Automation" seemed great there, but they were having difficulty managing how it was being used.
I wonder what might happen with the upcoming automation(s) in a similar manner?
I find it somewhat odd that another category of stores that often aren't a great match for self-checkout--big box home improvement stores--seem to have adopted it so broadly, at least around where I live.
As I mentioned, at least in the Northeast US, it seems to be particularly popular in big box home improvement stores (Home Depot, Lowes) even though it's problematic for a lot of purchases there. OTOH, I basically never see it in supermarkets here even though it's almost ubiquitous in London markets (albeit smaller stores with less fresh/un-barcoded produce).
Personally, I think if Amazon Go can follow through on its promise we'll see a drastic reduction in retail employment. The problem with existing self-checkout systems is that they're incredibly clunky and frequently require staff support/intervention. I've literally never had a successful self-checkout where everything worked properly.
As I understand it, grocery stores employ more people back-of-house and in areas like the deli counter, than they do at cash registers.
So "largest" may simply be an artifact of said binning.
I think this is too optimistic. Self-driving cars only work because they are in the minority. Can you imagine a city full of current state-of-the-art self driving cars and it not turning into a traffic chaos?
In particular, I think that self-driving cars cannot work fully autonomously without communicating with other cars or the road infrastructure. And I am not aware of any effort to create a cross-vendor car-to-car communication protocol.
There are trivial cases where pure autonomous following of traffic rules will lead to deadlock (or other issues). Take these two simple examples: 1) 4 cars arrive at the same time in a four-way intersection without signals or yields 2) on a three lane road, two cars from the outer lanes try to switch to the middle lane at the same time.
These are by no means difficult problems (I'm sure there are more difficult cases too), but they must be solved and so far they're not being worked on.
Sometimes the communication needs to be complex (I.e. Verbal). I've had a few instances when I've had to negotiate to unblock a traffic deadlock, mostly when a two way lane is constricted to one vehicle only due to parked cars, or a HGV which is too big to drive past. In London this happens quite frequently.
I really cannot think how an autonomous car, with no human inside, could handle these scenarios.
And driving in non-inclement weather. And driving in places that aren't meticulously mapped by Google. And being able to refuel themselves....
I'm not denying the accomplishments of current autonomous vehicles, but there is still a ways to go technically.
Designing for the unexpected edge cases is harder than designing for the normal cases. In accordance with Cargill's ninety-ninety rule, we can expect that the "fine tuning" you mention will be turn out to be a very big job.
As an extreme demonstration, consider the fact that you could rack up a million "autonomous" miles in a matter of months, using vehicles capable of nothing more than "lane keeping assist" and "adaptive cruise control" - just set 'em loose on a NASCAR loop and run them around in circles until this artificial example's point has been proven.
I am exited about autonomous cars, but I'm not convinced they are as ready as various companies want us to believe.
The advert's buzzwordy, bullshitty, vague explanation of the tech hints that they're not super confident themselves about how well it will face up against shoplifters.
The hardware requirements for any store that wants to adopt Amazon's tech are minimal: some cameras, an entry gate and possibly some pressure pads under the shelves.
Even if Amazon doesn't license out their tech -- and they would be foolish not to -- you can be sure that Google and Microsoft are working on their own versions. The market is staggeringly big.